A long-running philosophical debate is being rehashed in the world of business, and big money is at stake, says Stephen Ornes
AT SOME point in their career every mathematician comes up against the question, is mathematics invented or discovered? The query makes some cranky. The answer doesn’t directly affect their work, after all, and the discussion often leads nowhere useful. Spending time debating the ultimate nature of mathematics takes away from actually doing it.
Some scholars take issue with the terms themselves. In his 2008 essay Mathematical Platonism and Its Opposites, Harvard University mathematician Barry Mazur called discovery and invention “those two too-brittle words”. One might be tempted to defuse the question altogether with a merger: perhaps maths involves inventing new relationships between things we have discovered.
It’s a metaphysical query, a nerdy way to ask whether or not some pre-existing truths underlie our existence. Here we bump up against theology. If mathematical ideas are discovered – the Platonist position – then a proof is a real-world encounter with an immortal truth. But then where, exactly, is this ethereal pool of truths? Did prime numbers exist before the big bang?
If, on the other hand, mathematics is invented, then proofs spring from human intelligence a bit like art or law. But then why do mathematicians across time and space always agree on what’s right and wrong?
The question about invention versus discovery flares up every few years, often in a different guise. The latest incarnation concerns something very down to earth: money. In this case, the discovery versus invention question has profound consequences. In fact, there may be no mathematical question with higher stakes. That’s because mathematics powers the algorithms that drive computer software, and software is big business, worth over $300 billion a year to the global economy.
One of the most hotly contested issues in software is whether it should be patentable. At present not all of it can be, because of its dependence on mathematics. Patents are granted for inventions, and most mathematical formulas are deemed to be abstract ideas, not inventions, although the rules vary from country to country; some grant software patents, some don’t. Where patents are granted, they are tantamount to big money.
Writing in the April 2013 issue of Notices of the American Mathematical Society, David Edwards from the University of Georgia in Athens points out that the debate over patents boils down to the difference between discovery and invention. He argues that because abstract mathematical ideas are regarded as “discoveries”, the system is fundamentally Platonic – and broken.
“There is no economic basis for the distinction between discovery and invention,” he told me. “Economically speaking, the difference between discovery and invention should be done away with.” He argues patents should be granted for every new formula and algorithm, including those that power computer software. Such a change would jump-start innovation. “If math were patentable, then you could have independent groups of mathematicians form a group or small company and support themselves that way,” he says.
His position is extreme, but proponents of software patentability similarly argue that the system fuels growth and rewards people for their work.
Critics, notably the nonprofit Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) in San Francisco, say the current patent system actually stymies innovation, because getting a patent requires years and tens of thousands of dollars.
Another criticism is that hazy wording in software patent laws has given rise to “patent trolls”, predatory companies that purchase old, cheap patents simply to use them to sue other companies for infringement. Trolling cost US companies $29 billion in 2011, according to a report from the Boston University School of Law.
The Chicago-based company Soverain Software, for example, has been accused of being a patent troll. It has racked up tens of millions of dollars suing companies including Amazon and Gap over patents for basic online shopping software. The online computer retailer Newegg, sued by Soverain for $2.5 million, fought back – and in January a US District Court in East Texas ruled against Soverain.
Even if trolls get banished, weak patents exist.
The Latest Bing News on:
Patenting mathematics
- Inside the Rise of Jesse Lyu and the Rabbit R1on April 26, 2024 at 5:00 pm
A big fan of Liverpool FC, he sprung at the opportunity to attend the University of Liverpool, where he majored in mathematics ... there’s no other route and we have some pretty strong patents.” ...
- It doesn’t matter how many Vision Pro headsets Apple sellson April 26, 2024 at 7:31 am
This week, there was a lot of back and forth about Apple Vision Pro production numbers. Here's why they don't matter.
- Atomera (ATOM) Q1 2024 Earnings Call Transcripton April 25, 2024 at 11:00 pm
Hello, everyone, and welcome to Atomera's first quarter fiscal year 2024 update call. I'd like to remind everyone that this call and webinar are being recorded, and a replay will be available on ...
- How The FTC’s Ban On Noncompetes Will Transform The Tech Industryon April 25, 2024 at 3:13 pm
As leaders, we are tasked with not only navigating the current landscape but also envisioning and creating the future.
- UNESCO alleges social media affects girls’ career choiceson April 25, 2024 at 3:04 pm
UNESCO released a report that claimed girls "are steered away from studying science, technology, engineering and mathematics" as a result of social media usage.
- Google’s New Infini-Attention And SEOon April 25, 2024 at 1:55 pm
Google's Infini-attention can easily be added into existing models, including those of Google's core algorithm ...
- Meet The Company Beating Theme Parks At Their Own Gameon April 25, 2024 at 9:36 am
Few industries are as offbeat as the theme park sector. So it's hard to see how expertise in the field could apply to other sectors but actually this couldn't be further from the truth.
- How a pair of socks inspired me to study and make a career in the STEM fieldon April 24, 2024 at 9:56 am
Exposing girls to science, technology, engineering and math and encouraging them at home and school is the best way to close the STEM gender gap.
- The Showdown Over Who Gets to Build the Next DeLoreanon April 24, 2024 at 3:00 am
Decades after her dad’s iconic sports car time-traveled into movie history, Kat DeLorean wants to build a modern remake. There’s just one problem: Someone else owns the trademark on her name.
- Noncompetes Are Dead—and Tech Workers Are Free to Roamon April 23, 2024 at 4:21 pm
A new rule from the US Federal Trade Commission invalidates most noncompete agreements, frequently used to bind tech workers. It could unlock higher wages and more entrepreneurship and innovation.
The Latest Google Headlines on:
Patenting mathematics
[google_news title=”” keyword=”patenting mathematics” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
[/vc_column_text]
The Latest Bing News on:
Patent trolls
- All Galaxy smartphones affected: Samsung loses patent lawsuiton April 25, 2024 at 5:00 pm
Datang actively develops radio technology and products, so it is not just a so-called patent troll that lives off patent lawsuits. heise online has a redacted version of the judgment from April 12, ...
- Moderna Investors Should Beware Patent-Dispute Fallouton April 23, 2024 at 11:40 am
Moderna's stock soared on positive cancer vaccine trial results, but legal troubles loom as a patent dispute threatens massive damages. Read my analysis here.
- Megan Fox Responds to Trolls Saying Her Makeup-Free Selfie Looks Like AIon April 18, 2024 at 6:33 am
And the comments simply do not pass the vibe check. Mostly thanks to trolls feeling the need to comment on Megan's appearance and claim this photo looks nothing like her. Some examples ...
- How two small Texas towns became the patent-law centre of Americaon April 16, 2024 at 12:06 pm
Patent litigation could reasonably warrant a specialised court, similar to the system America uses to handle bankruptcy cases, stacked with experienced judges. “There are compelling reasons why ...
- KnowBe4 sued for patent infringement by 'patent troll'on April 16, 2024 at 4:12 am
The lawsuit alleges KnowBe4's offerings infringe on another patented technology. A South Florida-based IP attorney said it is not an easy case for the plaintiff.
- We need to pass U.S. Farm Bill, but we can't undermine it with harmful patent legislationon April 12, 2024 at 1:41 am
PERA, a paradigm-shifting piece of patent legislation, is quietly being considered in the halls of Congress, former U.S. Sen. Pat Roberts warns.
- Empirical Evidence on the Behavior and Impact of Patent Trolls: A Surveyon April 7, 2024 at 5:00 pm
Cohen, Lauren, Umit Gurun, and Scott Duke Kominers. "Empirical Evidence on the Behavior and Impact of Patent Trolls: A Survey." In Patent Assertion Entities and Competition Policy, edited by D. Daniel ...
- Patent Trolls: Evidence from Targeted Firmson April 7, 2024 at 5:00 pm
Cohen, Lauren, Umit Gurun, and Scott Duke Kominers. "Patent Trolls: Evidence from Targeted Firms." Management Science 65, no. 12 (December 2019): 5461–5486. (Cited in the United States Federal Trade ...
- Meta Transfers AI-Related Patents to Midjourney to Thwart Patent Trollson April 3, 2024 at 9:49 am
But the specter of the patent troll threatens to keep companies bogged down in distracting and costly legal battles. “An open approach to AI leads to better, safer products, faster innovation ...
- Intel files lawsuit to overturn European patent that threatens to block its exports to Germanyon March 28, 2024 at 4:34 am
Speaking to MarketWatch, an Intel spokesperson called R2 a “patent troll” and said that “as with its invalidated U.S. patent, we strongly believe R2’s patent at issue in the German case is ...
The Latest Google Headlines on:
Patent trolls
[google_news title=”” keyword=”patent trolls” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]