During a traditional lineup, eyewitnesses are either shown six photographs of individuals at the same time (simultaneous lineup) or presented one picture at a time (sequential lineup). The paired comparison (PAR) method asks the eyewitness to choose the picture that is more similar to the culprit when shown two photographs at the same time. A technique called signal detection analysis is then used to reveal the structure of the witness’s recognition memory and eliminate unconscious bias.
Credit: Gepshtein et al., Nature Communications
Salk scientists devise a new lineup method to help eyewitnesses more accurately identify suspects
People wrongfully accused of a crime often wait years—if ever—to be exonerated. Many of these wrongfully accused cases stem from unreliable eyewitness testimony. Now, Salk scientists have identified a new way of presenting a lineup to an eyewitness that could improve the likelihood that the correct suspect is identified and reduce the number of innocent people sentenced to jail. Their report is published in Nature Communications on July 14, 2020.
“Misidentification by eyewitnesses is a long-standing problem in our society. Our new lineup method uncovers the structure of eyewitness memory, removes decision bias from the identification process, and quantifies performance of individual witnesses,” says Salk Professor Thomas D. Albright, co-corresponding author of the study. “This study is a great example of using laboratory science to bring about criminal justice reform.”
In the United States, nearly 70 percent of DNA exonerations are due to misidentifications by eyewitnesses, according to the Innocence Project. To overcome this societal problem, research has focused on factors that influence the likelihood that a witness will identify the correct person. One key factor is the way individuals are presented to the eyewitness during the lineup, according to Albright, who co-chaired a National Academy of Sciences committee to examine the validity of eyewitness identification. Albright, an expert in the fields of visual perception and recognition, taps into decades of research suggesting that people commonly misperceive visual events, and memories of those events are continuously augmented and deteriorate over time.
Currently, the two most common (or traditional) methods used by law enforcement are known as simultaneous and sequential lineups. In the simultaneous method the eyewitness views six photographs of individuals at the same time; in the sequential method the eyewitness views six photos, one at a time. The witness then either identifies a suspect or rejects the lineup if no face matches their memory of the crime scene.
The research team sought to create a new lineup method that would help estimate the strengths of memories for each face and eliminate unconscious biases that shape decisions without awareness.
“Traditional lineups just reveal the top choice—the tip of the iceberg. But the cause of the witness’s decision is ambiguous. It may reflect strong memory for the culprit, or it may mean that the witness was not very discerning,” says Albright. “Our new procedure overcomes that ambiguity by revealing the strength of recognition memory for all lineup faces.”
The scientists used a technique, called the method of paired comparisons, which works similar to how an optometrist gives an eye exam: Just like looking through pairs of lenses and stating which lens is clearer, the eyewitness is shown two photographs of individuals at a time and they choose the one that looks more similar to the person they remember from the crime scene. The procedure yields an estimate of the strength of recognition memory for each lineup face. Statistical analysis of these memory strengths then reveals the probability of correctly identifying the culprit.
“Our methods derive from a branch of science called sensory psychophysics,” says Staff Scientist Sergei Gepshtein, first and co-corresponding author of the paper, who founded and directs the Collaboratory for Adaptive Sensory Technologies at Salk. “Psychophysical tools are designed to reveal how properties of the physical world are ordered—or ‘scaled’—in the mind. Our approach allowed us to peek into the ‘black box’ and measure how lineup faces are organized in the witness’s memory in terms of their similarity to the culprit.”
The paired comparison method yields greater information about the identity of the culprit than previous methods. What is more, it offers an unprecedented quantitative index of certainty for individual eyewitnesses, which is what the judge and jury really need to know.
“The conduct of a lineup is just one application of our method,” says Gepshtein. “Another application is selection of lineup ‘fillers,’ which are faces of people known to be innocent. The fillers should not be too similar or too dissimilar to the suspect. Because the new method reveals the perceived similarity of faces, it can be used to optimize the choice of lineup fillers.”
The paired comparison lineup holds much promise as a research tool as well as a practical tool for investigation and prosecution of crimes. The authors hope that the new technique will soon be applied in real police casework, leading to more correct identifications and fewer wrongful convictions.
“Convictions should be based on science, not precedent,” says Albright.
The Latest Updates from Bing News & Google News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
Keeping innocent people out of jail
- ‘Released to harm people’: Nashville Police Chief questions role of outside organizations posting defendant’s bail
A Nashville non-profit is pushing back after facing criticism for paying for community members to get out of jail. The Nashville Community Bail Fund posts bail for people charged with a crime and ...
- Broome County Jail detainees worked without pay despite being promised compensation, lawsuit alleges
A new federal lawsuit alleges that pretrial detainees at the Broome County Correctional Facility were forced to perform unpaid labor, despite being promised pay ...
- Getting out of prison is only the beginning of a new set of problems with probation
Serving your time in prison doesn't end when you get out. I know. I spent 20 years inside for one mistake. But the probation system is broken and that only makes crime worse.
- Debate: The ethics and economics of keeping nonviolent elderly and gravely ill in prison
Compassionate release gained momentum during the COVID-19 pandemic, when the federal government released thousands of vulnerable prisoners.
- Keeping former inmates out of jail and in their communities | Beyond the Bars
"There's nothing wrong with asking for help and you'll find out that people care. There are a lot of good people in the world." All the work done through the ministry aims to stop the prison ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Keeping innocent people out of jail
[google_news title=”” keyword=”keeping innocent people out of jail” num_posts=”5″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
Go deeper with Bing News on:
Science of perception
- Commentary: Science is closing in on the frailties of old age
Research is finding ways to extend animal lifespans but regulators are still wary of treating ageing as a disease, says the Financial Times' Camilla Cavendish.
- Memorable images slow our sense of time
When we look at memorable images, time appears to slow down, according to a recent study. Why it matters: The findings could help inform efforts to develop AI that can sense the passage of time — ...
- The Science of Aging: New Insights Into When “Old Age” Begins
Increases in life expectancy and later retirement could explain the shift in public perception of when old age begins. Middle-aged and older adults believe that old age begins later in life than their ...
- Positive perceptions of solar projects
Factors like aesthetics, economics and perceptions of fairness in the planning process strongly influence attitudes. Residents largely oppose increased state-level decision-making on future LSS ...
- Your Perception of Time Is Skewed by What You See
How the brain processes visual information — and its perception of time — is heavily influenced by what we’re looking at, a study has found. In the experiment, participants perceived the amount of ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Science of perception
[google_news title=”” keyword=”science of perception” num_posts=”5″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]