UC Riverside study shows that, while people can come to appreciate recycled water’s benefits, they still don’t want to use it
If people are educated on recycled water, they may come to agree it’s perfectly safe and tastes as good — or better — than their drinking water. They may even agree it’s an answer to the critical water imbalance in California, where the northern third of the state holds 75% of the water despite 80% of the demand coming from the southern two-thirds. But that doesn’t mean they’re going to use recycled water — and it sure doesn’t mean they’ll drink it. And the reason lies in the word “disgust.”
That’s the result of a series of studies by UC Riverside psychology researchers Mary Gauvain and Daniel Harmon published recently in the journal Basic and Applied Social Psychology.
Past research by Harmon and Gauvain explored whether people sense a difference in taste among recycled water, conventional tap water, and commercially bottled water. That study, released in spring 2018, was based on a blind taste test and found people actually preferred the taste of recycled water over conventional tap water.
However, “The idea of recycled wastewater in general evokes disgust reactions,” Harmon said at the time.
This idea was addressed in the psychologists’ latest research. If people disgusted by the notion of recycled wastewater are educated on its safety and benefits, will their attitudes change? And, will they change their behaviors?
In the research paper, “disgust” is defined as “a strong repulsion to a potentially harmful substance.” In addition to disgust, the research considered other factors that dissuade people from using recycled water. Those included misinformation, ignorance, and peoples’ desire to conform to social norms.
The research involved three separate studies and a total of 886 participants.
In study one, half of the subjects viewed a brief, pro-conservation internet video. The other group watched a short video about water, but not conservation, about the urban myth that crocodiles live in the sewer system of New York City.
Researchers found both groups failed to budge in their willingness to endorse sustainable water. Ninety-six percent of participants cited disgust as the reason. Distilling the reasoning even more, the researchers asked if participants were motivated by cleanliness or fear of illness. Sixty-five percent said cleanliness.
In study two, the videos were used again. But this time, an educational video demonstrating recycled wastewater is contaminant-free was also shown to address the disgust reaction. The pro-conservation and disgust videos had a “small but unsubstantial effect on peoples’ willingness to use recycled wastewater” the research found.
In the last study, participants viewed all three videos. But this time, after completing a post-video survey, they were offered a bottle of water labeled “SMARTdrop—Pure Recycled Water” and asked to sign a conservation petition.
Researchers hypothesized participants who watched the video addressing disgust would be more likely to accept the water and sign the petition. In fact, a similar number across all three groups — about two-thirds — took the water bottle and signed the petition.
The results of the three studies run counter to previous findings that assert media information can influence peoples’ water conservation attitudes. Instead, they show internet messages may encourage people to view water sustainability more positively, but they do not encourage more sustainable water behaviors.
The article drawn from the research, “Influence of Internet-Based Messages and Personal Motivations on Water-Use Decisions,” discourages using pro-recycled wastewater internet videos about water scarcity and conservation alone. Instead, researchers urge a focus on the more visceral roadblock of disgust. As an example, the researchers suggest a video stressing the extent of water purification in recycling plants as part of larger campaigns to change behaviors.
“Disgust is an exceptionally robust motivation that may require stronger intervention to overcome,” Harmon said.
Learn more: Get over it? When it comes to recycled water, consumers won’t
The Latest on: Recycled water
- Scranton resident finds personnel files of city employees left out for recycling at City Hallon May 2, 2024 at 1:55 pm
After finding a box of confidential files left outside of City Hall for recycling, a resident found himself in some hot water, he told Scranton City Council this ...
- Pixel 8a has a matte finish and is made with ‘recycled materials,’ leaked product page sayson May 2, 2024 at 10:48 am
The Pixel 8a is likely only a couple of weeks away from its debut and the leaks keep on coming. In another new leak, a Pixel 8a product page reiterates and confirms details about the upcoming device, ...
- Engineers create dissolving circuit boards that can be recycled over and over againon May 2, 2024 at 5:00 am
Electronic waste is the fastest growing waste problem in the world. Instead of burning it to recover gold and copper, this new method separates the components for reuse.
- Santa Barbara Proposes Rate Hikes for Water and Wastewater Utilitieson May 2, 2024 at 3:26 am
The average single-family home with water, wastewater, and trash and recycling services would see their utility bill increase from $241.65 to $253.31 a month for Fiscal Year (FY) 2025, reflecting a ...
- Scrapped: ABC Recycling is leaving Bellinghamon May 1, 2024 at 6:00 pm
ABC’s lease with the Port was terminated in March after allegations of polluting activity earlier this year. Now, the company has withdrawn its application to build a metal shredder on Marine Drive.
- Poland Spring rolling out water in aluminum bottleson May 1, 2024 at 7:37 am
Poland Spring parent company BlueTriton announced the aluminum bottles are part of a long-term sustainability plan.
- High Plains Agriculture: Local dairies recycling wateron May 1, 2024 at 5:16 am
The water table in the High Plains continues to decline. Despite the decrease, local dairies in the area are recycling and reusing water in the midst of drought. Three million gallons is how much ...
- Used bottles turned into water tanks: Uganda ramps up efforts to recycle single-use plasticson April 30, 2024 at 7:17 pm
Uganda’s capital Kampala produces more than 13,000 tonnes of plastic every year. Nearly half of that is not properly disposed of or recycled.
- Phoenix wants to build one of the world's largest water recycling plants. That's a game changeron April 26, 2024 at 6:01 am
Opinion: Sending ultra-purified recycled water directly to taps could change metro Phoenix, even if it remains a fraction of the water we drink.
- 5 Ways to Recycle Water and Hydrate Your Plantson April 26, 2024 at 6:00 am
Pasta water? Aquarium water? Dehumidifier water? Find out five ways that you can safely reuse water from around your home to water plants!
via Bing News
The Latest on: Sustainable water
- SSA's Fine & Country: Eco-home trends, sustainable tipson May 2, 2024 at 4:10 pm
Environmental consciousness is at the forefront of global conversations and the concept of green living has transcended from a mere trend to a fundamental lifestyle choice.Source: Supplied.As more ...
- Fuzion Field Services Redefines Sustainability and ESG Compliance Standards in Waste Managementon May 2, 2024 at 9:37 am
Fuzion's water recycling program represents a giant step forward in waste management sustainability efforts. By recycling 100% of the water from their portable toilets, Fuzion conserves millions of ...
- BlueTriton CEO Joey Bergstein on sustainability and premiumisation in wateron May 2, 2024 at 12:42 am
US bottled-water manufacturer BlueTriton has launched five of its brands in aluminium packaging amid a “premiumisation” trend in water as well as sustainability demands. Arrowhead, Deer Park, ...
- How Sustainable Design Is Elevating Multifamily Living Spaceson May 1, 2024 at 8:55 am
Experts from CRG, Marquette Cos. and Optima highlight how sustainable design principles are enhancing resident well-being and pave the way for a greener future in multifamily housing.
- Hemp is more sustainable than timber – here’s how it could transform low-carbon constructionon May 1, 2024 at 5:01 am
A hemp renaissance could transform the construction industry – this fast-growing crop sequesters or stores carbon and has multiple environmental benefits and practical applications.
- Minister emphasizes RI's commitment on sustainable water managementon May 1, 2024 at 3:21 am
Coordinating Minister for Maritime Affairs and Investment Luhut Binsar Pandjaitan emphasized the government's commitment to realizing integrated and ...
- Wellness Tops Sustainability Wish Lists In New Design Industry Studyon April 30, 2024 at 2:59 am
While there have always been individuals on both sides who saw the link between a healthy planet and a healthy house, it took a global pandemic to literally and ...
- CCSWB makes sustainability their businesson April 30, 2024 at 2:59 am
Sustainability is a large focus for CCSWB, one of the largest Coca-Cola bottlers in the United States. Despite the company’s large presence – CCSWB has seven production plants and 37 distribution ...
- Longer-Lasting and More Sustainable Green Hydrogen Productionon April 29, 2024 at 4:47 pm
New catalyst offers better stability and significantly longer lifetime, improves extraction of hydrogen from water ...
- Ecolab, ITE partner to harness water management knowledge for Singapore data center engineerson April 29, 2024 at 12:23 pm
The agreement will advance education and hands-on experience in the field of water management and sustainable operations.
via Bing News