While the Justice Department wages a public fight with Apple over access to a locked iPhone, government officials are privately debating how to resolve a prolonged standoff with another technology company, WhatsApp, over access to its popular instant messaging application, officials and others involved in the case said.
No decision has been made, but a court fight with WhatsApp, the world’s largest mobile messaging service, would open a new front in the Obama administration’s dispute with Silicon Valley over encryption, security and privacy.
WhatsApp, which is owned by Facebook, allows customers to send messages and make phone calls over the Internet. In the last year, the company has been adding encryption to those conversations, making it impossible for the Justice Department to read or eavesdrop, even with a judge’s wiretap order.
As recently as this past week, officials said, the Justice Department was discussing how to proceed in a continuing criminal investigation in which a federal judge had approved a wiretap, but investigators were stymied by WhatsApp’s encryption.
The Justice Department and WhatsApp declined to comment. The government officials and others who discussed the dispute did so on condition of anonymity because the wiretap order and all the information associated with it were under seal. The nature of the case was not clear, except that officials said it was not a terrorism investigation. The location of the investigation was also unclear.
To understand the battle lines, consider this imperfect analogy from the predigital world: If the Apple dispute is akin to whether the F.B.I. can unlock your front door and search your house, the issue with WhatsApp is whether it can listen to your phone calls. In the era of encryption, neither question has a clear answer.
Some investigators view the WhatsApp issue as even more significant than the one over locked phones because it goes to the heart of the future of wiretapping. They say the Justice Department should ask a judge to force WhatsApp to help the government get information that has been encrypted. Others are reluctant to escalate the dispute, particularly with senators saying they will soon introduce legislation to help the government get data in a format it can read.
Whether the WhatsApp dispute ends in a court fight that sets precedents, many law enforcement officials and security experts say that such a case may be inevitable because the nation’s wiretapping laws were last updated a generation ago, when people communicated by landline telephones that were easy to tap.
“The F.B.I. and the Justice Department are just choosing the exact circumstance to pick the fight that looks the best for them,” said Peter Eckersley, the chief computer scientist at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a nonprofit group that focuses on digital rights. “They’re waiting for the case that makes the demand look reasonable.”
A senior law enforcement official disputed the notion that the government was angling for the perfect case, and said that litigation was not inevitable.
This is not the first time that the government’s wiretaps have been thwarted by encryption. And WhatsApp is not the only company to clash with the government over the issue. But with a billion users and a particularly strong international customer base, it is by far the largest.
Learn more: WhatsApp Encryption Said to Stymie Wiretap Order
The Latest on: Encryption privacy
[google_news title=”” keyword=”encryption privacy” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
via Google News
The Latest on: Encryption privacy
- What is WhatsApp's End-to-End Encryption policy, for which the company is ready to leave India?on April 27, 2024 at 6:24 am
In recent years, WhatsApp, the popular messaging platform owned by Meta Platforms Inc. (formerly Facebook Inc.), has found itself embroiled ..|News Track ...
- WhatsApp will leave India, if asked to break encryptionon April 27, 2024 at 12:08 am
WhatsApp would rather leave India, than break its encrypted messages and phone calls. This is what the social media platform, told Delhi High Court on Thursday. WhatsApp made it clear that if it ...
- What is row over end-to-end encryption & why WhatsApp is threatening to leave India over iton April 26, 2024 at 8:30 pm
Experts suggest that there exist alternative methods to tackle digital crimes & law enforcement agencies should utilise metadata instead of weakening end-to-end encryption.
- WhatsApp Threatens India Exit: Privacy Standoff Heats Up Over Encryption Ruleson April 26, 2024 at 11:07 am
WhatsApp faces an ultimatum in India - comply with new regulations that break user privacy or exit the market. Read to know more!
- WhatsApp To Leave India If Forced To Break Encryptionon April 26, 2024 at 10:13 am
WhatsApp, the popular instant messaging service, on Thursday, told the Delhi High Court that it would shut down operations in India if it is forced to ...
- Privacy Protected: WhatsApp's End-To-End Encryption Explained Simplyon April 26, 2024 at 8:22 am
WhatsApp has challenged Information Technology Rule 4(2) of the 2021 IT (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code).
- WhatsApp Threatens To Leave India If Forced To Break Message Encryptionon April 26, 2024 at 7:32 am
WhatsApp counsel argued in the Delhi HC that users use the messaging platform because of the privacy it assures ...
- WhatsApp Will Exit India If Forced To Break Encryption; HC Tells Privacy Rights Not Absoluteon April 25, 2024 at 11:05 pm
Rules 2021, WhatsApp and Facebook’s parent Meta filed a petition at the Delhi HC. The rule stipulates that a social media intermediary/platform should furnish the information of the first originator ...
- WhatsApp Threatens to Exit India if Forced to Break Encryptionon April 25, 2024 at 9:09 pm
WhatsApp has petitioned against rule 4(2) of Information Technology Rules, that it will continue encrypting or exit India if asked otherwise.
- Nearly all Chinese keyboard apps have encryption flaws, exposing millions of users to keyloggingon April 25, 2024 at 5:00 pm
Normally, any internet-based typing utility comes with inherent risk, but the companies offering cloud-based pinyin apps guarantee user privacy through encryption. Researchers from the University of ...
via Bing News