BLUNT criticism is an essential part of science, for it is how bad ideas are winnowed from good ones.
So when Randy Schekman, one of the 2013 crop of Nobel prize-winners (for physiology or medicine, in his case), decided to criticise the way scientific journals are run, he did not hold back.
Dr Schekman chose the week of the prizegiving (the medals and cheques were handed over on December 10th) to announce that the laboratory he runs at the University of California, Berkeley, will boycott what he describes as “luxury journals”. By that he meant those commonly regarded as the most prestigious, such as Cell, Nature and Science.
He levels two charges against such journals. The first is that, aware of their pre-eminence and keen to protect it, they artificially restrict the number of papers they accept—acting, as he put it in an interview with the Guardian, a British newspaper, like “fashion designers who create limited-edition handbags or suits…know[ing] scarcity stokes demand”. Their behaviour, he says, is more conducive to the selling of subscriptions than the publishing of the best research.
Second, he argues that science as a whole is being distorted by perverse incentives, especially the tyranny of the “impact factor”, a number that purports to measure how important a given journal is. Researchers who publish in journals with a high impact factor—like the three named above—can expect promotion, pay rises and professional accolades. Those that do not can expect obscurity or even the sack, a Darwinian system known among academics as “publish or perish”.
The Latest on: What’s wrong with Science
[google_news title=”” keyword=”What’s wrong with Science” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
via Google News
The Latest on: What’s wrong with Science
- Ousted ABC News weatherman Rob Marciano clashed with ‘GMA’ meteorologist Ginger Zee: sourceson May 1, 2024 at 6:04 pm
Ousted weatherman Rob Marciano’s stormy tenure at ABC News included clashes with fellow meteorologist Ginger Zee — a bitter feud that was kept tightly under wraps for years at the ...
- 'My First Seance' toy Ouija board isn't real. Image was created with AI | Fact checkon May 1, 2024 at 1:43 pm
Experts and an online detection tool say the image was created with artificial intelligence. It originated in a Facebook group for AI-generated art.
- Don't use science fiction to inspire public policy on AIon April 30, 2024 at 11:01 pm
At the end of "Terminator 2: Judgment Day," Arnold Schwarzenegger’s T-800 character is lowered into the molten metal to prevent his processing chip from falling into the wrong hands ... AI except in ...
- AI death calculator? People are searching for their ‘death date’ with this creepy (fake) boton April 30, 2024 at 8:56 am
In December, a group of Danish researchers unveiled life2vec, an AI chatbot that could theoretically predict when a person will die. The group's findings were published in a paper and the models have ...
- A Post About Book Sales Went Viral. Here’s What It Gets Wrong.on April 29, 2024 at 5:00 pm
Still, many of the statistics here are wrong or misleading in part because they were intended ... But for some genres, especially science fiction and fantasy, e-book sales can easily exceed print ...
- Anatomy of a medical mistake: What led one surgeon to perform the wrong procedure — and then go public about iton April 29, 2024 at 12:28 pm
Most importantly, Ring says, the team never performed a “time out” – a pre-surgery huddle, in which they review who the patient is, what procedure they’re about to do, where exactly it’s being done, ...
- What's Wrong With My Weeping Cherry Tree?on April 27, 2024 at 6:38 am
The weeping tree with the pretty flowers is called a scion. Scion sounds like real science-fiction here. And what it is, it's grafted on top of a tall, straight trunk, which is called the under stock.
- NPR whistleblower highlights everything wrong with journalism todayon April 26, 2024 at 6:59 am
Journalistic malpractice, whether about Russiagate, concocted claims of electoral fraud, COVID-19 or Hunter Biden’s laptop, is epidemic.
- News digest: Science communicator on what to look for regarding conspiracieson April 22, 2024 at 7:23 am
Good evening. Here is the Monday, April 22 edition of Today in Slovakia - the main news of the day in less than five minutes. How to enjoy the capital on a budget Going to visit Bratislava soon? Here ...
- How Anti-Trans Efforts Misuse and Distort Scienceon April 19, 2024 at 8:58 am
Three types of misinformation are being used against transgender people: oversimplifying scientific knowledge, fabricating and misinterpreting research and promoting false equivalences ...
via Bing News
