Researchers show reputation concerns can encourage people to take part in real world ‘public-good’ programs
Whether it’s an effort to increase recycling rates, reduce energy usage or cut carbon emissions, the conventional wisdom says that the best way to get people to do the right thing is to make it worth their while with cold, hard cash.
But Harvard researchers say there may be an easier, cheaper way – by appealing to people’s reputation, not their wallets.
Using enrollment of thousands of people in a California blackout prevention program as an experimental test bed, a team of researchers that included Erez Yoeli, a researcher at the Federal Trade Commission, Moshe Hoffman, a visiting researcher at Harvard’s Program for Evolutionary Dynamics (PED), David Rand, formerly a post-doctoral fellow at PED (now a professor at Yale University), and PED Director Martin Nowak, showed that while financial incentives boosted participation only slightly, making participation in the program observable – through the use of sign-up sheets posted in apartment buildings – produced a three-fold increase in sign-ups. Their work is described in a study published this week in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
“We wanted to see how observability compares to a cash incentive for getting people to act to benefit the common good. The answer is that observability is really dramatically better,” Rand said.
Using a cash incentive of $25, the utility company sponsoring the program had seen participation increase from about three percent to four percent. When researchers made people’s participation observable, however, participation jumped from three to nine percent. To get the same result using a cash incentive, Yoeli estimated, the company may have had to offer every person as much as $175.
Observability proved to be the key factor in the results, the researchers said, because it puts people’s reputation at stake, encouraging those who might not otherwise sign up to do so.
“When people know it’s a cooperative effort, they feel peer pressure to take part,” Rand explained. “They think, ‘If I don’t do this, I’m going to look like a jerk.’ But if it’s not observable, then there’s no problem with not participating.”
“In fact, we think this is one reason why the Prius, for instance, is such a different-looking car,” said Hoffman. “The designers at Toyota seem to have intuitively had this idea, designing a car that didn’t look like any other car so your neighbors can tell you’re driving a hybrid.
“You can also see this phenomenon when you go to vote, and you get an ‘I voted’ sticker,” he added. “Or when you go to give blood and you get a pin you can put on your backpack.”
To directly demonstrate the effect of observability in a highly relevant real world setting, Yoeli and colleagues turned to a large-scale California blackout prevention program. As part of the program, residents were asked for permission to install a monitoring device on their air-conditioning system. If power demand spiked, the device would automatically adjust the air-conditioning temperature to reduce electricity demand and not overload the power grid.
As part of their study, researchers randomly offered people one of two ways to sign up for the program.
In the first, people received a mailer that described the program, and were encouraged to sign up in their apartment building using a unique identification number. In the second, people received a similar mailer and identification number, but also had to write their name and apartment number when they signed up.
“The idea was that in one case, it’s anonymous, and in the other, it’s observable – everyone can see who has and hasn’t signed up,” Rand said. “When participation is observable, people worry about their reputation, and wanting to seem cooperative drives them to sign up.”
The Latest Bing News on:
Reputation
- The United States on Wednesday denounced Hong Kong's ban on a protest song sung by pro-democracy demonstrators, saying it further tarnished the financial hub's reputation.on May 8, 2024 at 11:04 am
The United States on Wednesday denounced Hong Kong's ban on a protest song sung by pro-democracy demonstrators, saying it further tarnished the financial hub's reputation. "The decision to ban this ...
- Ban On Protest Song 'Latest Blow' To Hong Kong Reputation: USon May 8, 2024 at 11:04 am
The United States on Wednesday denounced Hong Kong's ban on a protest song sung by pro-democracy demonstrators, saying it further tarnished the financial hub's reputation.
- Star Wars Outlaws Explains How the Reputation System Workson May 8, 2024 at 8:36 am
Star Wars Outlaws developers describe its Reputation system, which shapes how missions play out based on the player's standing with certain factions.
- Star Wars Outlaws' Reputation system will change "the gameplay around the story" rather than "the story itself"on May 8, 2024 at 4:38 am
Star Wars Outlaws devs say the game's reputation system is designed to shape the world around protagonist Kay Vess, rather than the story that you're playing through. Speaking to Game Informer, senior ...
- Lotte E&C's reputation severely impacted after construction site collapseon May 8, 2024 at 12:45 am
Cash-strapped building developer faces lawsuit from serviced apartment buyers Lotte E&C is witnessing a deterioration of the image regarding its apartment brand, Lotte Castle, after the recent ...
- Boeing's failed launch attempt of Starliner raises stakes for company's reputationon May 7, 2024 at 5:36 pm
After Boeing's Starliner mission was scrubbed due to technical difficulties, the company is betting on a relaunch of the rocket to revitalize the brand amid safety concerns and scrutiny.
- Why Ron Howard’s ‘Nice’ Reputation Is So Fitting (Guest Column)on May 7, 2024 at 11:20 am
Ron Howard is receiving Variety’s Profile in Excellence Award May 16 at the Cannes Film Festival, where his documentary “Idea Man” will screen.
- Google: Site Reputation Abuse Manual Actionson May 7, 2024 at 10:56 am
Google's SearchLiaison confirmed that the site reputation abuse policy enforcement "is really kicking off today" ...
- France tries to shed its rude reputation ahead of the Olympicson May 7, 2024 at 7:35 am
Are Parisians really unfriendly to tourists? A resident goes undercover to find out as the city tries to shed its rude reputation before the Olympics.
- Is Tesla’s reputation ruined? It depends on who you askon May 6, 2024 at 1:58 pm
Conversations around Tesla's reputation leaned toward the negative throughout 2023, but it depends on who you're talking to, reports YouGov.
The Latest Google Headlines on:
Reputation
[google_news title=”” keyword=”reputation” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
The Latest Bing News on:
Reputation can trump money
- Donald Trump Hush-Money Trial Accents 'Pattern of Behavior': Ex-WH Officialon May 8, 2024 at 11:51 am
New York State Supreme Court Justice Juan Merchan threatened Trump with jail time this week following violations of the gag order in the criminal trial.
- Trump, House Dems defend Texas congressman accused of accepting Mexican bribes, but for very different reasonson May 8, 2024 at 9:18 am
Both former President Trump and Democratic Caucus Chair Pete Aguilar defended Rep. Henry Cuellar after he was indicted by the DOJ on bribery charges.
- Key takeaways from Stormy Daniels' testimony in Trump hush money trialon May 8, 2024 at 5:13 am
It's the biggest spectacle yet in the first criminal trial of a former American president, now in its third week of testimony in Manhattan.
- Trump fined $1,000 for gag order violation in hush money case as ex-employee recounts reimbursementson May 6, 2024 at 6:35 pm
The judge presiding over Trump's trial fined him again for contempt and threatened jail time if he violated the gag order again.
- Witness testimony in Trump's hush money trial wraps for the dayon May 6, 2024 at 2:30 pm
Former President Donald Trump's hush money trial continues in New York. Follow here for the latest live news updates, analysis and more.
- Judge corrects Trump claim he “can’t testify” in hush money trial due to gag orderon May 3, 2024 at 10:03 am
Donald Trump is in no way limited by what he can say about witnesses at his Manhattan hush money trial if he chooses to take the stand in his own defense, the judge presiding over the case told him ...
- Michael Cohen hasn't taken the stand in Trump's hush money trial. But jurors are hearing his wordson May 2, 2024 at 9:30 pm
The second week of testimony Donald Trump's hush money case will wrap up Friday after jurors heard a recording of the former president that's central to the case ...
- "Losing all credibility": Trump's hush money lawyer the latest to torch his reputation for nothingon May 2, 2024 at 3:00 am
Todd Blanche was once regarded as a great lawyer, but now he's making embarrassing arguments to please his client ...
- How the overturned Harvey Weinstein conviction could echo in Donald Trump’s hush money trialon May 2, 2024 at 2:00 am
The message from the highest court in the state of New York was clear last week: No matter who they are or how unpopular they might be, defendants are entitled to a fair trial.
- Trump could avoid trial this year on 2020 election charges. Is the hush money case a worthy proxy?on April 22, 2024 at 9:15 pm
While the charges are felonies, the New York case is seen as the least consequential against the former president. In the two election cases, Trump is accused of more direct involvement in trying to ...
The Latest Google Headlines on:
Reputation can trump money
[google_news title=”” keyword=”Reputation can trump money” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]