Personal technology such as fitness trackers and smartphones that record users’ daily activities are likely to be used increasingly in criminal investigations, raising questions about individuals’ rights that the legal system is not yet fully prepared to address, according to a new RAND Corporation study.
Information such as location, travel patterns and even physiological details such as heart rate and activity levels could be retrieved from devices as a part of criminal investigations. Such technology offers new tools to law enforcement, but raises unique issues regarding important constitutional rights such as self-incrimination, according to the report.
Courtrooms also are poised to change because of technology, with teleconferencing, digital records and even virtual reality entering the scene — all intended to speed up proceedings and reduce the cost to the justice system. These technologies raise issues of fairness for defendants and may change the notion of whether a trial by videoconference is equal to proceedings where everyone appears in person, according to the report.
“When changes are gradual, the law and the criminal justice systems have time to react and adapt naturally as conflicts appear,” said Brian Jackson, lead author of the study and a physical scientist at RAND, a nonprofit research organization. “But new technologies are developing rapidly and are likely to create conflicts before the legal system is fully prepared to deal with them.”
Both the courts and law enforcement agencies need to make greater efforts to identify the conflicts ahead, as well educate the criminal justice workforce about how to both properly use and address concerns regarding the emerging tools, according to the report.
These efforts should focus on trying to identify and arbitrate disputes about technology before they reach a critical point. One example of such a conflict was when investigators probing the mass shooting that took place in San Bernardino in 2015 wanted to unlock a smartphone belonging to one of the shooters. Those efforts were delayed while investigators unsuccessfully tried to convince the phone’s manufacturer to aid their efforts.
Researchers say working through the issues surrounding new technologies outside the pressure of a public safety crisis is needed to better balance the value of using technologies in investigations versus the potential infringements on privacy and individual rights.
As a part of a multi-year project to look at the challenges that technology poses for the criminal justice system, researchers from RAND and RTI International assembled a group of practitioners, legal scholars and advocates to examine issues involving technology and individual rights.
The group of 13 experts identified more than three dozen needs, each related to a specific problem or challenge posed to the protection of individual rights by new technology.
The area they flagged as requiring the most attention is assuring the quality and integrity of data used by the criminal justice system across a wide range of uses, according to the report. This includes both the quality of information gathered about crimes and placed into a digital record, as well as how that data is analyzed such as in risk assessment tools used by both police and the courts.
For example, significant effort has been devoted to the creation of risk assessment models that predict the likelihood that a person will fail to appear at their trial or commit crimes in the future.
When used in courts, these models may allow an individual to be released with a lower bail or no bail if they are assessed to be a low risk — creating cost savings for both the public and the defendant, according to the report. To the extent the tools increase consistency between judges, the models could increase fairness. But if the predictive models unknowingly incorporate bias, then the tools could create systematic bias in the process.
The report also recommends better technical training and education for workers across the criminal justice system about how to properly use digital tools. And having that capability broadly available is key for the system to do its job well. While a database of evidence may be available to both the prosecution and defense, if an overworked public defender does not have a skilled data analyst as a part of his or her team, then digital tools may tip the scales of justice in one direction, experts warn.
“Digital tools hold the promise to speed proceedings and increase fairness, but both sides should have the skills and resources necessary to use them,” Jackson said. “For example, hundreds of hours of surveillance recordings may hold important evidence, but will both parties have the skills and resources to comb through and analyze all the data?”
The report notes that personal technology devices already have become important tools in criminal investigations. In at least one case, a fitness tracker was used in court to disprove a women’s allegation that she was sexually assaulted in her home — the fitness tracker showed she had been awake and walking the entire night.
As medical devices such as cardiac pacemakers become more advanced to include features such as Wi-Fi, it opens the possibility that life-sustaining technology also could be used to collect evidence against a user, according to the report.
Learn more: Rise of Technology in Criminal Proceedings Poses Risk to Protecting Individuals’ Rights
[osd_subscribe categories=’privacy’ placeholder=’Email Address’ button_text=’Subscribe Now for any new posts on the topic “PRIVACY”‘]
Receive an email update when we add a new PRIVACY article.
The Latest on: Personal technology and criminal proceedings
[google_news title=”” keyword=”personal technology and criminal proceedings” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
via Google News
The Latest on: Personal technology and criminal proceedings
- Bank Officials Must Cooperate In Criminal Investigations; Allahabad High Court Granted Bail To Alok Jha Amidst Delay In Proceedingson April 30, 2024 at 2:57 am
CASE TITLE Alok Jha vs State of Uttar Pradesh DATE OF ORDER April 24 2024 BENCH Honble Mr Justice Ajoy Bhanot PARTIES Applicant Alok Jha Opposite Party State of ...
- Former Cambridge Analytica director, personal data advocate praises blockchain techon April 27, 2024 at 1:55 pm
Blockchains have emerged as key players in protecting personal data, security and sovereignty in the digital age.
- Full Jury Is Chosen in Trump Criminal Trialon April 19, 2024 at 5:59 am
Donald J. Trump is accused of falsifying business records to cover up a sex scandal that threatened to derail his 2016 campaign. Jury selection in his trial could wrap up Friday as lawyers work to ...
- First 7 jurors are chosen for Trump's hush money criminal trial; 11 more still neededon April 17, 2024 at 3:39 am
The first seven jurors for Donald Trump’s New York hush money trial have been chosen after lawyers grilled members of the jury pool about their social media posts, political views ...
- First 7 jurors are chosen for Trump’s hush money criminal trial, with 11 more still neededon April 16, 2024 at 5:19 pm
political views and personal lives to decide whether they can sit in fair judgment of the former president. The panelists who were selected are an information technology worker, an English teacher, an ...
- Federal Judge Presses for Extending Use of Videoconferencing in Criminal Proceedingson March 27, 2024 at 10:10 am
A Federal Rule of Criminal ... technology in criminal hearings post-pandemic. In a March 24 letter, U.S. District Judge Brett Ludwig stated that Rule 43 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure ...
- Arnold Schwarzenegger was detained and faces criminal proceedings in Germany over luxury watchon January 18, 2024 at 6:28 am
MAINZ, Germany — Arnold Schwarzenegger was detained and is facing criminal tax proceedings after being ... that Schwarzenegger was asked to provide personal, financial information and had ...
- Chinese Courts and Criminal Procedureon December 17, 2023 at 5:35 am
The second part of the book shifts the perspective to three controversial themes of criminal procedure reform ... first ensure [email protected] is added to your Approved Personal Document ...
- The Constitution and the Future of Criminal Justice in Americaon November 5, 2023 at 10:42 pm
Check if you have access via personal or ... the current state of criminal justice and its future challenges. '… essential reading for persons who want to increase their understanding of contemporary ...
via Bing News