University scientists and academic organizations are uncharacteristically vocal about the government’s blunt preference for commercially applicable science
Canada’s National Research Council is the country’s premier scientific institution, helping to produce such inventions as the pacemaker and the robotic arm used on the American space shuttle. But last year, its mission changed.
The Canadian government announced a transformation of the 98-year-old agency, formerly focused largely on basic research, into a one-stop “concierge service” to bolster technological innovation by industry — historically weak — and generate high-quality jobs.
This has set off a dispute over the future of Canada’s capacity to carry out fundamental research, with university scientists and academic organizations uncharacteristically vocal about the government’s blunt preference for commercially applicable science.
“We are not sure the government appreciates the role that basic research plays,” said Kenneth Ragan, a McGill University physicist and president of the Canadian Association of Physicists: “The real question is, How does it view not-directed, nonindustrial, curiosity-driven blue-sky research? I worry the view is that it is irrelevant at best and that in many cases they actually dislike it.
The remodeling of the research council is one in a series of policy changes that have generated fierce pushback by Canadian academics in recent years. The Conservative government of Prime Minister Stephen Harper is also under fire for closing research libraries, shutting down research facilities and restricting when government scientists can speak publicly about their work. Last year the Canadian Association of University Teachers began a national campaign, “Get Science Right,” with town-hall meetings across the country to mobilize public opposition to the policies. Scientists have even taken to the streets of several Canadian cities in protest.
While the transformation of the National Research Council has been criticized, the government as well as some science-policy analysts say that better connecting businesses with research is an important step for Canada.
Having examined models in other countries, the National Research Council chose to streamline its operations to act as “the pivot between the two worlds” of industry and academics, with an eye toward new products and innovations, said Charles Drouin, a spokesman for the council. He said the agency had not moved away from support for fundamental research but wanted to focus such efforts better. “There is basic research, but it is directed, as opposed to undirected as you would find it in universities.”
Another battleground for the future of basic research has been the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council, a federal granting agency that serves as the first stop for financing fundamental research by Canadian scientists.
In 2011-12, the latest year for which data are available, the council’s “discovery” grants for fundamental research accounted for 38.4 percent of its budget, down from 50.1 percent in 2001-2. Its “innovation” grants, which encourage the transfer of university-developed technology to industry, rose to 31.4 percent in 2011-12, up from 25.3 percent a decade earlier. (The council also directs part of its roughly $1-billion budget to postdoctoral fellowships and other awards for young researchers.)
“The government has invested proportionately more on the innovation side, where it was seen that we had more challenges,” said Pierre J. Charest, vice president of research grants and scholarships at the government agency. He noted that the council was “on track” to double the number of scientists forming partnerships with industry.
Mr. Charest said criticism about a smaller percentage of funds for discovery grants missed a larger point — that the budget had grown over the past decade to almost $325 million in 2012-13. However, much of that increase comes from a special supplement for a select group of researchers to explore potentially transformative concepts.
One who has felt the pinch is Norman Hüner, an internationally recognized plant biochemist and physiologist at the University of Western Ontario, who holds a prestigious Canada Research Chair in environmental-stress biology. A longtime recipient of discovery grants, he and his research collaborators are exploring a potential breakthrough in the use of photosynthesis to trick plants to grow in suboptimal conditions — relevant research in Mr. Hüner’s view, given concerns about climate change.
The Latest on: Basic Research
[google_news title=”” keyword=”Basic Research” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
via Google News
The Latest on: Basic Research
- U.S. research funding should support American values, not antisemitismon May 10, 2024 at 2:38 am
College campuses across America – and in particular across the Ivy League – have erupted with antisemitic, pro-Hamas encampments and riots. These anti-American activities are not the peaceful protests ...
- Scientists learn basics of sperm whale language after years of researchon May 9, 2024 at 4:16 pm
even that basic knowledge is lacking. “What's new in this study is that they are trying to look at the basis for the whales' communication system ... not just particular calls they're making,” she ...
- Rutgers-Led Statewide Translational Research Institute Is Awarded $39.7 Million National Institutes of Health Granton May 9, 2024 at 1:32 pm
The National Institutes of Health (NIH) has awarded the Rutgers Institute for Translational Medicine and Science $39,673,786 over seven years to build and improve upon infrastructure that promotes ...
- Research Roundup: NU researchers discover catalyst to remove carbon dioxide, assess hazard maps’ efficacyon May 8, 2024 at 5:00 pm
Since raising more than $1 billion in research funding in the 2023 fiscal year ... “Now it looks like there’s no fundamental problem with them. Because the basic method looks sound, we can expect ...
- DHS Releases Broad Agency Announcement for CWMD Research & Developmenton May 8, 2024 at 2:59 pm
A notice posted Tuesday on SAM.gov states that the broad agency announcement is valued at $182.3 million and will remain open for five years until May 6, 2029, to support the DHS Countering Weapons of ...
- Mobile medical research tour focused on marginalized communities coming to Rochesteron May 8, 2024 at 2:52 pm
The All of Us Journey mobile tour from the National Institutes of Health stopped at the Ibero-American Action League Wednesday, The tour is gathering data from residents in communities that are ...
- 5 things to know about election administration funding: A research-based tip sheeton May 8, 2024 at 2:17 pm
Elections in the U.S. are usually run at the local level. It's important to know who funds election administration in the areas you cover.
- Using AI Tools To Improve Research Integrity Processeson May 8, 2024 at 8:59 am
4 However, as alluded to in Dr. David’s blog post, cancer research (and thus cancer treatment) is built upon the foundation of basic research. Tragically, if that research is fraudulent, enormous ...
- ACM Research Reports First Quarter 2024 Resultson May 8, 2024 at 5:00 am
FREMONT, Calif., May 08, 2024 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- ACM Research, Inc. (“ACM”) (NASDAQ: ACMR), a leading supplier of wafer processing solutions for semiconductor and advanced wafer-level packaging ...
- The Biden Administration opens $285 million funding for ‘digital twin’ chip research instituteon May 6, 2024 at 10:28 am
The Biden Administration has opened applications for $285 million in CHIPS Act funding for an institute to develop digital twins for the chip manufacturing industry. The investment aims to speed up ...
via Bing News