A new air purification strategy by USC Viterbi researchers might reduce the risk of COVID-19 transmission in classrooms and other indoor spaces by as much as tenfold.
University classrooms are forums for intellectual exchange. But the COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted how important it is for classrooms to also be sites of efficient air exchange—that is, good ventilation.
Air sampling technology developed by Constantinos Sioutas, a professor at the USC Viterbi School of Engineering, helped pave the way for the understanding that COVID-19 is an airborne virus. When the virus is exhaled in small respiratory droplets in indoor environments, the water content quickly evaporates because of the much lower relative humidity indoors than outdoors, leaving viral particles suspended in the air. That insight, in turn, led to the knowledge that replacing indoor air with fresh or filtered outdoor air (aka “air exchange”) can help dissipate viral particles that would otherwise linger for hours.
Now, a new study by Sioutas and his team conducted in USC classrooms demonstrates that high-efficiency in-line filters within HVAC systems can significantly improve indoor air quality. The study, published in the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, also reveals that operating such a system at the same time as a portable air purifier with a HEPA filter can maximize the removal of tiny airborne particles.
Running these filtration systems simultaneously, “You reduce the risk of the students and the professor becoming infected [with COVID-19] by more than tenfold,” says Sioutas, Fred Champion Professor and Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering and Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering.
The study’s implications extend well beyond USC to other educational institutions, as well as to residences, businesses and public transportation.
When Sioutas’ team began planning the research—which was partially financed by the USC Viterbi Dean’s office—in the summer of 2021, they used data from USC Facilities Planning and Management (FPM) to determine which classrooms to evaluate. They wanted to measure indoor air quality across a range of building ages, classroom sizes and ventilation systems.
At the time, FPM was collaborating with USC Environmental Health and Safety (EH&S) to create the Building Readiness Dashboard, a portal that has allowed the USC community to see at a glance which campus buildings meet Centers for Disease Control (CDC) recommendations for ventilation. Gathering the data allowed FPM to identify buildings that needed additional filtration.
“It was a herculean effort by FPM Engineering Services and the EH&S team,” says Mark Mosley, FPM’s Executive Director of Engineering and Asset Management.
For the study, Sioutas’ team selected nine classrooms in seven different buildings, all of which had HVAC systems with MERV-14 in-line filters — except for one, which had a MERV-13 filter. MERV stands for the Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value; the higher the MERV rating, the more efficient the filter is in capturing particles from the air.
“We were sort of ahead of the curve,” says Mosley, citing the CDC recommendation of MERV-13. “We had actually retrofitted a lot of our units to MERV-14s,” about four years prior to the pandemic.
Sioutas also told Christopher J. Toomey, FPM’s Vice President and Executive Director, about his plans to simultaneously study the impact of portable air purifiers with HEPA filters on classroom air quality. “To my delightful surprise, [Toomey] said, ‘You know, we actually bought about 1,000 of these units,’” says Sioutas. The 1,200 portable purifiers purchased by FPM were intended for use in classrooms whose ventilation systems did not have filtration efficiency that met CDC guidelines.
Sioutas was able to employ the purifiers in his study. “I’m very glad that USC, without even consulting with me, ordered these particular units,” says Sioutas.
Sioutas was interested in measuring the effect of ventilation and filtration not only on pollutants we exhale, including carbon dioxide (CO2), but also on particulate matter (PM) that can infiltrate indoors and negatively impact human health. Indoor air pollution causes almost 3.8 million premature deaths annually, according to the World Health Organization (WHO).
His team first evaluated air quality in the nine classrooms during two-hour lectures, while students were present and the ventilation systems were operating. It turned out that all of the ventilation systems had high enough air exchange rates to dilute indoor CO2 concentrations to safe levels recommended by the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE). But when it came to reducing PM and particulate number (PN) concentrations, ventilation systems with MERV-14 filters were far superior to the one with the MERV-13 filter. The former reduced PM and PN concentrations by more than 80 percent, while the latter reduced them to 49 percent and 55 percent, respectively.
Next, Sioutas’ team repeated the air quality measurements while concurrently operating a portable air purifier. When Sioutas saw the first results, he was incredulous. Within 15 minutes, PM and PN were reduced to less than 10 percent of their initial values. In some classrooms, he says, the aerosol concentrations approached those of a semiconductor-industry cleanroom, which is a factory where PM is stringently controlled to facilitate the manufacture of silicon wafers into semiconductor chips.
Sioutas figured there must have been some mistake in the calculations. “I told my students, ‘Go back and do this experiment again—these results cannot be right,’” he says. But the results held. “That’s when we realized that once you activate the purifier…you have this drastic reduction in the pollution.”
In the second part of the study, Sioutas and his team introduced an indoor source of air pollution—nebulized sodium chloride particles, which were roughly the same size as exhaled COVID-19 particles—to an empty classroom. Operating the ventilation system along with the air purifier at its highest speed reduced the concentration of sodium chloride in the air to less than 10 percent of its initial value in about 15 minutes. Since the risk of airborne virus transmission is directly proportional to an indoor space’s viral aerosol concentration, the results suggest a more than tenfold reduction in COVID-19 risk.
Air purifiers with HEPA filters work by forcing air through fine mesh made of plastic or fiberglass fibers that capture tiny particles. Since COVID-19 cannot survive on most solid surfaces for long periods, the viral particles trapped on the filter die off, posing no further risk.
The study validates FPM’s approach of using high-efficiency in-line filters wherever possible and augmenting less efficient ventilation systems with portable air purifiers. “It just confirmed…that we were on the right path,” says Mosley.
Sioutas hopes that the study draws renewed attention to the importance of air purification in COVID-19 prevention in educational institutions. He notes that portable air purifiers are an effective, affordable and energy-efficient way to slash the risk of COVID-19 transmission not just in classrooms, but in any indoor environment: “homes, restaurants, pubs, movie theaters, office buildings, sports arenas, you name it,” he says.
“I’m a fierce advocate of using this technology,” he adds. “I could not recommend it more strongly.”
Original Article: Clearing the (Classroom) Air
The Latest Updates from Bing News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
Air purification strategy
- Air Purification Spray Market is anticipated to boost sales at a Impressive CAGR
Feb 07, 2023 (The Expresswire) -- "Air Purification Spray Market" Size, Share andamp; Trends Analysis Report 2023 - By Applications (Supermarket, ...
- SinglePoint, Inc. Highlights Market Trading in First Spinoff of Non-core Business Unit to Shareholders
(OTCQB:SING) ("SinglePoint" or "the Company"), a renewable solar energy and sustainable solutions provider, announced today that the Company's first spinoff to shareholders, 1606 Corp. (OTC:CBDW) has ...
- Air Purification Machine Market 2023 : Development, Growth, Key Factors And Forecast To 2029
Air Purification Machine Market Size is projected to Reach Multimillion USD by 2029, In comparison to 2022, at ...
- Mumbai Civic Body Allocates Funds to Tackle City's Growing Air Pollution
More air purification units, new AQI monitoring stations, and dust screens around construction sites are some of the initiatives tabled by the BMC as part of their plan to curb pollution.
- BMC announces clean air initiative, shares list of plan to control air pollution
The Municipal Commissioner Iqbal Singh Chahal on Saturday presented the BMC budget 2023-24 which included the civic body`s clean air initiative to curb the increasing air pollution in Mumbai.
Go deeper with Bing News on:
High-efficiency in-line filters
- Nuera Air High Efficiency Central Vacuum Filter Bag (3-Pack)
3 genuine Husky high efficiency filtration bags. Husky central vacuums provide exceptional air quality for your living area. To maintain the same level of efficiency, use only the high performance ...
- iRobot iRobot Roomba e and i Series High.Efficiency Filter, (3.Pack)
The Roomba e and i Series High.Efficiency Filter captures 99% of mold, pollen, dust mite, dog and cat allergens. Compatible with Roomba e and i Series Robot Vacuums Only. Replacement Filters. High ...
- High Efficiency Air Filter Market Dynamics with Top Players, Gross Margin, Regional Demand, Plans and Demand Status Forecast to 2028
Jan 28, 2023 (The Expresswire) -- Final Report will add the analysis of the impact of Russia-Ukraine War and COVID-19 on this High Efficiency Air Filter industry. "High Efficiency Air Filter ...
- High Efficiency Particulate Air Filter (Hepa) Market 2023 : Size (value & volume) by Company, Key Regions, Type, and Application 2028
"High Efficiency Particulate Air Filter (Hepa) Market" Insights 2023 ... leaders and industry experts (such as experienced front-line staff, directors, CEOs, and marketing executives), downstream ...
- High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC)
High Efficiency Video Coding also makes use of an improved deblocking filter and sample adaptive offset, which helps in reducing artifacts at block edges. In HEVC, there is improvement in variable ...