
via Earth.com
New research by a team at Queen Mary University of London shows that bumblebees can modify their response to ‘noxious’ (painful) stimuli in a manner that is viewed in other animals as consistent with the ability to feel pain.
The researchers showed that bumblebees are capable of modifying their response to ‘noxious’ (painful) stimuli in order to get a higher sugar reward. The possibility of insect pain and suffering should therefore be taken seriously, they say.
Queen Mary’s Professor Lars Chittka, author of the new book The Mind of a Bee, who led the research, said “Insects used to be regarded as simple reflex automatons, responding to damaging stimuli only by withdrawal reflexes. Our new work shows that bees’ responses are more flexible and that they can suppress such reflexes when it suits them, for example if there is an extra-sweet treat to be had. Such flexibility is consistent with the capacity of a subjective experience of pain”
Study first-author Matilda Gibbons, PhD student at Queen Mary University of London said, “Scientists traditionally viewed insects as unfeeling robots, which avoid injury with simple reflexes. We’ve discovered bumblebees respond to harm non-reflexively, in ways that suggest they feel pain. If insects can feel pain, humans have an ethical obligation not to cause them unnecessary suffering. But the UK’s animal welfare laws don’t protect insects – our study shows that perhaps they should.”
In the paper, published today in?Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), the researchers used a ‘motivational trade-off paradigm’, where animals must flexibly trade-off two competing motivations. Bees were given the choice between either unheated or noxiously-heated (55°C) feeders with different sucrose concentrations and marked by different colours. (Images available here- please credit Pippa Ager).
When both feeders were high-quality and one of them was noxiously heated, bees tended to avoid the heated feeder. But the bees were more likely to use the heated feeders when they contained a higher concentration sucrose.
The team also expanded on the motivational trade-off paradigm by ensuring that the trade-off relied on cues (colours) that the bees had learned to associate with a higher sugar reward. Because the bees used learnt colour cues for their decisions, the trade-off was based on processing in the brain, rather than just peripheral processing. In other words, the bees decided to undergo some pain or discomfort in order to get a higher sugar reward.
This showed that the trade-off is mediated in the central nervous system – an ability that is viewed in other animals as consistent with the capacity to feel pain. The researchers say that because of the subjective nature of pain experience, this not a formal proof, but the possibility of insect pain and suffering should be taken seriously.
Professor Chittka said: “Insects (unlike vertebrates) are not currently protected by any legislation regarding their treatment in research laboratories and in the growing industry that produces insects for human consumption or as food for conventional livestock. The legal framework for the ethical treatment of animals may have to be expanded.
“The increasing evidence for some form of sentience in insects places on us an obligation to conserve the environments that have shaped their unique and seemingly alien minds. We humans are only one of many species capable of enjoyment and suffering, including pain-like states. Even miniature creatures such as insects deserve our respect and ethical treatment and a duty to minimise suffering where it is in our power to do so.”
Original Article: Bumblebees appear to feel pain
More from: Queen Mary University of London
The Latest Updates from Bing News & Google News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
Insect pain
- 21-Year-Old Woman Died of Rare Bone Cancer After Being Told a Lump Was 'Nothing to Worry About'
A young woman died of a rare bone cancer one year after being told that a lump on her shoulder was "nothing to worry about." Jenna Patel, from the U.K., was 20 years old when she noticed a lump on her ...
- Do Insects Have Feelings and Consciousness?
Science isn't sure if insects have feelings, but you might want to think twice before stomping a roach or squishing a bee.
- A 20-year-old thought she had an insect bite. She was diagnosed with an aggressive form of cancer and died months later.
Jenna Patel, a teaching student, was diagnosed with Ewing's sarcoma while her dad was receiving cancer treatment.
- What's Going Around: COVID, strep, stomach bug
WellSpan Pediatric Medicine Physicians across the Midstate are seeing COVID, a viral stomach bug and non-COVID upper respiratory illnesses. The CVS MinuteClinic in York also reports COVID and viral ...
- I thought my daughter just had a nasty insect bite but months after her 21st birthday she was dead
A YOUNG woman has died after a nasty looking insect bike turned out to be a rare but deadly disease. Jenna Patel, 21, was training to be a primary school teacher when she first noticed a bump ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Insect pain
[google_news title=”” keyword=”insect pain” num_posts=”5″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
Go deeper with Bing News on:
Insect pain and suffering
- S'pore woman, 40, sprayed neighbour's bird with insecticide, likely led to its breathing difficulties
The 40-year-old woman, Chee Huiru, had sprayed insecticide at her neighbour's caged bird. She used a fan to blow the mist upwards from her flat window towards the cage, resulting in the bird suffering ...
- My little boy died of Strep A after being sent home twice by doctors – he was left to suffocate on the floor
A HEARTBROKEN mum has claimed her little boy was left to suffocate on the floor whilst suffering with Strep A. Mohammad Izaan Danish became unwell on December 9 and sadly died on January 6 from ...
- David Sovka: The joys and perils of backyard beekeeping
To the horror of my long-suffering next door neighbours, my backyard sported two healthy hives, providing upwards of 80,000 bees with access to Victoria’s bountiful flowers AND up-market houses and ...
- Woman on trial for spraying insecticide at neighbour's bird, causing it to develop breathing difficulties
A video taken by a witness showed an arm extending out of a third-floor flat, spraying insecticide upwards towards birds in cages, with a fan blowing the mist upwards.
- I was rushed to hospital with an ear infection – now I’ve got just months to live
A DAD who was rushed to hospital with an ear infection has been told he has just months to live. Dave Whitford, 49, is now trying to live his life to the full after he was diagnosed with an ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Insect pain and suffering
[google_news title=”” keyword=”insect pain and suffering” num_posts=”5″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]