‘We conclude’ or ‘I believe’? Rationality declined decades ago
The use of rationality related words has been on the rise since 1850, but started an accelerating decline around 1980. This is concluded by research published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences this week. The discovery implies that a loss of interest in facts and rational arguments already started decades before the rise of social media.
Scientists from Wageningen University and Research (WUR) and Indiana University discovered that the increasing irrelevance of factual truth in public discourse is part of a groundswell trend that started decades ago. While the current ‘post-truth era’ has taken many by surprise, the study shows that over the past forty years public interest has undergone an accelerating shift from the collective to the individual, and from rationality towards emotion.
From ratio to sentiment
Analysing language from millions of books the researchers found that words associated to reasoning such as ‘determine’ and ‘conclusion’ rose systematically since 1850, while words related to human experience such as ‘feel’ and ‘believe’ declined. This pattern reversed over the past 40 years paralleled by a shift from a collectivistic to an individualistic focus as reflected by the ratio of singular to plural pronouns such as ‘I’/‘we’.
“Interpreting this synchronous sea-change in book language remains challenging.” says co-author Johan Bollen of Indiana University. “However, as we show, the nature of this reversal occurs in fiction as well as non-fiction. Moreover, we observe the same pattern of change between sentiment and rationality flag words in New York Times articles, suggesting that it is not an artefact of the book corpora we analysed.”
“Inferring the drivers of long-term patterns seen from 1850 until 1980 necessarily remains speculative.” Says lead author Marten Scheffer of WUR. “One possibility when it comes to the trends from 1850 to 1980 is that the rapid developments in science and technology and their socio-economic benefits drove a rise in status of the scientific approach, which gradually permeated culture, society, and its institutions ranging from the education to politics. As argued early on by Max Weber, this may have led to a process of ‘disenchantment’ as the role of spiritualism dwindled in modernized, bureaucratic, and secularized societies.”
What precisely caused the observed reversal of the long-term trend around 1980 remains perhaps even more difficult to pinpoint. However, according to the authors there could be a connection to tensions arising from changes in economic policies since the early 1980s, which may have been defended on rational arguments but the benefits of which were not equally distributed.
The authors did find that the shift from rationality to sentiment in book language accelerated around 2007 with the rise of social media, when across languages the frequency of fact-related words dropped while emotion-laden language surged, a trend paralleled by a shift from collectivistic to individualistic language.
Co-author Ingrid van de Leemput from WUR: “Whatever the drivers, our results suggest that the post-truth phenomenon is linked to a historical seesaw in the balance between our two fundamental modes of thinking: reasoning versus intuition. If true, it may well be impossible to reverse the sea-change we signal. Instead, societies may need to find a new balance, explicitly recognizing the importance of intuition and emotion, while at the same time making best use of the much needed power of rationality and science to deal with topics in their full complexity.”
Original Article: ‘We conclude’ or ‘I believe’? Rationality declined decades ago
The Latest Updates from Bing News & Google News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
Decline of rationality
- Today's letters: Readers comment on guns, student loans, schools and the decline of morals
What to do about guns “Guns, guns, guns!” Maybe if we say it enough, buy enough weapons and experience enough mass shootings, the words won’t have any meaning and the shooti ...
- Despite delivering investors losses of 33% over the past 1 year, EnerSys (NYSE:ENS) has been growing its earnings
EnerSys ( NYSE:ENS ) shareholders should be happy to see the share price up 14% in the last month. But that is ...
- The Dual Population Problem: People and Things
We can advocate for collectively setting limits as an important part of rational and responsible planning ... So if birthrates were to continue to decline, slowing population growth, and people were ...
- Population and housing census 2022: Family planning paying dividends
About the decline, officials and experts say Bangladesh ... Besides, women empowerment, rational decision-making, rising education levels, especially among women, are the reasons for which the ...
- Investors in Warpaint London (LON:W7L) have made a notable return of 71% over the past three years
Just take a look at Warpaint London PLC (LON:W7L), which is up 51%, over three years, soundly beating the market decline of 7.4% (not including dividends). So let's investigate and see if the longer ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Decline of rationality
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- Ugly truth behind Senate President Susan Lines’ push to ditch Lord’s Prayer
There is so much that is so nauseating and wrong about new Senate President Susan Lines’ campaign to ditch the Lord’s Prayer from Parliament that as I write this opening sente ...
- Enhancing China-Africa media cooperation to fight post-truth narratives
In this 21st century era, the greatest existential threat to China-Africa cooperation is the weaponization of post-truth narratives packaged as fake news, misinformation or propaganda. As a weapon of ...
- The crass truth of the cashless ploy
AN CAILÍN RUA AIB may have reversed its decision to go cashless in 70 branches, but the attempt still signals the cashless society to come ...
- The post-Dobbs era begins with chaos
Even in a barn-red state like Indiana, the politics of abortion in a post-Dobbs environment are complicated. That messy reality played out in full public view at the Indiana Statehouse today, where ...
- Truth, the shaken pillar of democracy
Politicians have long been accused of concealing the truth or failing to accept it. But such suspicion has never been so widespread. The relationship between politics and truth has always been ...