In recent years, the circular economy has become a guiding principle in industrial and environmental policies. But how good is it really?
The definition of a circular economy is unclear and lacks substance, according to a team of researchers from Lund University and the Royal Institute of Technology in Sweden. It risks becoming counterproductive, unless we stop referring to it as a panacea for all kinds of environmental problems.
The circular economy has become a well-known and recognised model among businesses, regions, cities and NGOs worldwide – from China and Latin America to the EU and the USA. However, what is less discussed is that the model has received a great deal of criticism from both practitioners and researchers.
Researchers have now compiled these criticisms:
- The concept of a circular economy is so diffuse and sprawling that it is not possible to measure its impact. It includes everything from recycling systems, renting, replacing products with services, to developing apps for the sharing economy, etc.
- Advocates of a circular economy tend to ignore the vast amount of materials and products that people have already accumulated. The concept is reduced to a question of choosing between linear and circular products and disregards physical laws about the physical limitations of materials and the complexity of the waste; even though these issues are crucial if a circular economy is to become a reality.
- Some businesses only develop circular activities for parts of their operations. This may be due to the difficulty of scaling up pilot projects; often it is only a small part of the operation that is characterised by a circular economy, while the core activities continue as usual.
- Contrary to what the advocates say, there is poor knowledge about how a circular economy will affect the utilisation of resources and growth. This makes it difficult to measure the environmental impact, especially in the long term and over larger geographical scales. Some claim that a circular economy only delays, rather than eliminates, the negative environmental impact of the linear economy.
- Although advocates of a circular economy claim to contribute to a socially sustainable future for all, the concept tends to be reduced to a debate about resource consumption. There is no connection to how the concept would lead to greater social equity.
- Some critics argue that the circular economy depoliticises industrial and environmental policies while advancing the power of the market and businesses. It is an enticing concept which promises that everyone will benefit from its implementation. It enables discussions about synergies, win-win and possibilities rather than about compromises, problems and limitations.
“In conclusion, criticism of the circular economy does not challenge the concept of circularity”, says Hervé Corvellec, principal author of the study.
Rather, it is a case of how the supposed benefits are based on inconsistencies, an incomplete picture, hidden assumptions, agendas and unclear consequences. These are the questions we have to ask ourselves: how do we know that a circular solution is good for the environment? Who benefits from it and who does not? Will it phase out the linear economy – extract, produce, consume, discard?
Hervé Corvellec and the other researchers behind the compilation propose a more modest circular economy, which is not presented as a panacea but as a real solution to concrete problems.
“Clarity is required regarding precisely what type of circularity it applies and what the conflicting objectives are”, he concludes.
Original Article: Circular economy is not the panacea many had hoped for
The Latest Updates from Bing News & Google News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- CBA pushes sustainability and the circular economyon May 13, 2022 at 4:40 am
Across the country, companies are adopting more sustainable business practices, exploring options in the renewable, “circular economy” as they await technological breakthroughs to drive the great leap ...
- European packaging industry representatives call for a harmonised circular economy that protects the Single Marketon May 13, 2022 at 4:38 am
In a joint letter to the European Commission, representatives from the European packaging industry caution that the fragmented implementation of circular economy initiatives on a national scale risks ...
- GM Has Become an ‘Energy Star’ with Efficiency and Circular Programson May 13, 2022 at 4:16 am
GM committed to a 20% reduction in carbon intensity by 2020. It achieved that goal in 2017. And in January 2021, it said it would source 100% renewable energy to power GM facilities in the U.S. by ...
- Circular economy approach for US textileson May 13, 2022 at 1:54 am
Only about 15% of used clothes and other textiles in the United States get reused or recycled – the other 85% goes to landfill or an incinerator, ...
- Going green: The rise of circular economy and how S’pore bizs are stepping up sustainabilityon May 12, 2022 at 11:36 pm
are resulting in a change in the local economy — away from the pollutive models of the linear economy, and towards the sustainable model of the circular economy. The circular economy is an ideal of ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- Oura sues smart ring rival Circular for allegedly copying technologyon May 13, 2022 at 7:03 am
Even smart rings aren't immune to patent wars. Wareable notes Oura has sued fledgling rival Circular for allegedly violating patents covering both ring design and biometric data collection. Circular's ...
- Woodworking Circular Saw Blades Market Estimated to Account for a Net Worth of US$ 68.3 Mn By 2029, Future Market Insightson May 12, 2022 at 7:30 am
Companies Profiled in Woodworking Circular Saw Blades Market are Freud SpA, Robert Bosch GmbH, Stanley Black and Decker, Tenryu Saw Mfg. Co. Ltd., Hilti Corporation, DEWALT, HiKOKI, Diablo Tools, ...
- Braskem taps Terra Circular to form plastic recycling JVon May 12, 2022 at 5:27 am
Brazilian petrochemical producer Braskem BRKM5.SA said on Thursday it had formed a joint venture with Terra Circular aiming to convert low-quality pl ...
- Circular fashion: Exciting to talk about, tough to implementon May 12, 2022 at 2:30 am
Circular fashion requires turning old clothes into new ones ... And, as the industry rushes to implement resale, the issue she says is they “don't have the solution set for the products that don't ...
- Digital product passports: What does the Sustainable Products Initiative bring?on May 11, 2022 at 1:01 am
Digital product passports can enable the EU’s transition to a circular economy, and the recent Sustainable Products Initiative provides a policy framework for the long way forward. A circular economy ...