via University of Cambridge
Farming should be as high-yield as possible so it can be limited to relatively small areas, allowing much more land to be left as natural habitats while still meeting future food targets, according to a major new analysis of over a decade of research.
Most species fare better under this “land sparing” approach than if farming tries to share land with nature – as wildlife-friendly agriculture still damages most biodiversity and requires far more land to produce the same amount of food.
This is the conclusion of research that takes into account over 2,500 individually assessed plant, insect and vertebrate species from five continents. The review, conducted by Prof Andrew Balmford, also suggests that “land sparing” sequesters more carbon, and may well benefit marine life if applied to oceans.
“Figuring out how to feed, clothe and power 11 billion people without causing mass species extinction and wrecking the climate is this century’s greatest challenge,” he said. “Preserving diverse life while meeting humanity’s needs will mean enormous trade-offs, but the evidence is starting to point in one direction.”
In a paper published in the Journal of Zoology, Balmford lays out the case for securing the highest levels of production we can from land – and water – already farmed, in order to spare remaining wilderness from cows, ploughs, chainsaws and trawler nets.
“Most species fare much better if habitats are left intact, which means reducing the space needed for farming. So areas that are farmed need to be as productive as we can possibly make them,” he said.
Some species thrive on traditional farmland, particularly in Europe, where light grazing by livestock can imitate “disturbance” once caused by large prehistoric mammals, creating habitats for many species that otherwise struggle. As such, some low-yield farming should be factored in, says Balmford, but at a low level.
The UK Government-commissioned National Food Strategy (NFS), published in the summer, recommended that Balmford’s “three-compartment” model – harnessing high-yield farming in order to leave space for many more protected habitats, with pockets of traditional agriculture to preserve farmland-associated species – should form the basis of a new “Rural Land Use framework”.
The NFS points out that around 21% of farmed land in England will need to be re-wilded to some extent or used for biofuel if the UK is to meet its net zero targets, and that the entire bottom third of farmed land produces just 15% of English agricultural output.
Balmford’s latest paper summarises a decade of global research on trade-offs between crop production and biodiversity. This includes Cambridge-led studies on bird and tree species in India and West Africa, finding that – while all species are “losers” if mid-century food targets are met – more species “fare least badly” under extreme land sparing: concentrated farming that allows for more natural habitat.
“Colleagues have replicated these findings in field sites ranging from Mexico and the Pampas to Colombia and Kazakhstan,” said Balmford. “Most species are specialized to particular environments. Even minor disruptions reduce their populations. This is why so many species decline even with gentler farming.”
Retaining and increasing habitats to create patchwork landscapes of nature and mostly high-yield farming will not just preserve species in isolated areas but allow them to “seed” and repopulate entire regions and nations.
Balmford highlights the success of just four square kilometres of restored wetland near Lakenheath in the east of England. Covered with carrot fields as recently as 1995, the site is now a launchpad for egrets spreading northwards under climate change, and home to the first breeding cranes seen in The Fens for over 300 years.
In addition to biodiversity benefits, emerging evidence from areas including the Andes, the US and the UK suggests “land sparing” is an ally in the fight against climate change, as carbon storage levels are higher if high-yield production allows for more natural vegetation.
Previous research by Balmford suggests that if 30% of UK land was spared for woods and wetlands, it could store enough carbon to offset almost all emissions from UK farming by 2050 – and provide a colossal boost to British wildlife.
Support for “land sparing” is not a whole-hearted endorsement of industrial production, says Balmford. Driving up farm yields also means supporting smallholder farmers and adopting nature-based agricultural science.
For example, when millions of Chinese farmers turned to a simple system that matched methods to local soil and weather conditions, yields went up 11% while fertiliser use fell by a sixth.
Farming carp in rice paddies – the fish eat pests, provide fertiliser through faeces, and are themselves an extra crop – is another of numerous possibilities that utilise natural ecosystems. Emerging technologies such as boosted photosynthesis in rice also offer hope for sustainably high yields.
More recently, the concept of “land sparing” has been used by researchers to investigate recreation, forestry and even urban planning – with early evidence pointing to this approach as the most promising way of meeting human demands at least cost to nature.
The effects of tourism on wildlife appear to be reduced by concentrating visitors to wild areas into small portions of the landscape, while New Zealand is already taking a “sparing” approach to its forests: over 70% is now protected, while timber is intensively harvested from pockets of pine plantation.
Early research suggests the “sparing” philosophy also offers hope for depleted oceans. Aquaculture farming and locally intensive fishing could provide enough “output” to allow dramatic expansion of “no-take” Marine Protected Areas, and avoid the costs of trying to regulate equipment and catch sizes across all open water.
However, support for high-yield techniques must be tied to saving or restoring habitats – and not exploited to increase profit. Linking financial support for smallholders or access to high-value markets with land-use restrictions that preserve forests has already proved successful in India and the Brazilian Amazon.
Public pressure on business and government to commit to sparing land for nature will be vital, says Balmford. As with emissions, the organisations causing most damage to habitats may find it increasingly difficult to hide.
“Some giant corporations, often the worst offenders for land conversion, are actually in a position to think longer-term than many democratic governments,” he said.
Balmford’s research is partly inspired by Cambridge polymath David MacKay, who died of cancer in 2016 aged just 48. Mackay had a no-nonsense take on sustainability – insisting that low-carbon initiatives can only be meaningfully compared at the same level of output. Without that, humanity risks getting distracted by solutions that don’t come close to meeting energy needs.
Similarly, farming systems can only be usefully compared when they’re actually meeting society’s food needs. “You can’t convince people to save nature if they are hungry. We need to ensure we can harvest enough from the biosphere while preserving the planet,” said Balmford.
“Conservation has to be pragmatic if we are to interrupt an ecological catastrophe.”
Original Article: Concentrate farming to leave room for species and carbon
More from: University of Cambridge
The Latest Updates from Bing News & Google News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- Land Sparing or Land Sharing? Study Suggests Biodiversity in Coffee Lands Requires Bothon July 29, 2022 at 9:35 am
Given the fact that commercial farming of any kind requires large swaths of land, the very concept of sustainable coffee production remains paradoxical. As the authors of a groundbreaking new ...
- Supreme Court Regains Sanity Sparing Thousands of Jewish Settlers from Uprootingon July 28, 2022 at 12:33 am
What worked for Mitzpe Kramim should work for an estimated 2,000 to 3,000 other Jewish homes in Judea and Samaria.
- New fossil shows four-legged fishapod that returned to the water while Tiktaalik ventured onto landon July 20, 2022 at 8:00 am
A meme has been circulating online during the pandemic featuring Tiktaalik roseae, the iconic, four-legged "fishapod" that first made the transition from water to land 375 million years ago. Most ...
- Equilibrium/Sustainability — To preserve wildlife, share landon July 18, 2022 at 3:39 pm
That approach differs from the dominant North American tactic of “land sparing” — a strategy marked by a clear division between protected natural areas and ecologically inhospitable zones of ...
- Electric cars sales in the US ‘could prevent one-tenth of global cropland expansion’on July 18, 2022 at 12:09 pm
This land sparing would bring “substantial” emissions savings, in addition to the direct benefits of electrifying US road transport, the researchers say. The findings come as campaigners and some ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- 600 animals and their savior are living their best lives on this N.J. farm that’s free for visitorson August 1, 2022 at 6:56 am
Tucker, a black 4-year-old German Shepherd, followed Laurie Zaleski everywhere as she worked on her 15-acre farm in Mays Landing last month. Nothing out of the ordinary for anyone who knows the love ...
- The Power of Cow Manure: How Farms of the Future Are Transforming Waste-to-Energy Operationson July 31, 2022 at 9:18 pm
The use of renewable energy in the agriculture industry is an exciting new frontier that—with the right partners—can bring environmental and economic benefits to farmers, surrounding communities, and ...
- Green Plate Special: A Limington farm is making labne, a Middle Eastern yogurt cheese delicious no matter how you spell iton July 31, 2022 at 1:00 am
But I will tell you that I absolutely loved Chef Michael Boomhower’s tomato salad with whipped garlic labne, puffed amaranth and mint. Like all the food I tasted that night (order the boned half ...
- Boyd makes case for regenerative farmingon July 30, 2022 at 12:21 pm
The Lumbee Tribe's Kara Boyd recently advocated for federal recognition of her tribe and regenerative agricultural practices before the U.S. House of Representatives Subcommittee on Environment. Rep.
- Africa: Could Turning Urine into Fertiliser Make Farming More Sustainable? #AfricaClimateHopeon July 29, 2022 at 7:50 am
Do you know that instead of flushing urine down our toilets to wastewater treatment facilities, it could be recycled and used as fertiliser?