
New research from the University of Delaware’s A.R. Siders and Katharine Mach, from the University of Miami, found that managed retreat can’t be seen as a last resort — it must be paired with existing (flood walls) or future (floating cities) measures to be effective.
CREDIT: Jeffrey C. Chase/ University of Delaware
University of Delaware disaster researcher A.R. Siders said it’s time to put all the options on the table when it comes to discussing climate change adaptation.
Managed retreat — the purposeful movement of people, buildings and other assets from areas vulnerable to hazards — has often been considered a last resort. But Siders said it can be a powerful tool for expanding the range of possible solutions to cope with rising sea levels, flooding and other climate change effects when used proactively or in combination with other measures.
Siders, a core faculty member in UD’s Disaster Research Center, and Katharine J. Mach, associate professor at the University of Miami Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric Science, provide a prospective roadmap for reconceptualizing the future using managed retreat in a new paper published online in Science on June 17, 2021.
“Climate change is affecting people all over the world, and everyone is trying to figure out what to do about it. One potential strategy, moving away from hazards, could be very effective, but it often gets overlooked,” said Siders, assistant professor in the Joseph R. Biden, Jr. School of Public Policy and Administration and the Department of Geography and Spatial Sciences. “We are looking at the different ways society can dream bigger when planning for climate change and how community values and priorities play a role in that.”
Retreat does not mean defeat
Managed retreat has been happening for decades all over the United States at a very small scale with state and/or federal support. Siders pointed to Hurricanes Harvey and Florence as weather events that caused homeowners near the Gulf of Mexico to seek government support for relocation. Locally, towns such as Bowers Beach, near the Delaware coast, have used buyouts to remove homes and families from flood-prone areas, an idea that Southbridge in Wilmington is also exploring.
People often oppose the idea of leaving their homes, but Siders said thinking seriously about managed retreat sooner and in context with other available tools can reinforce decisions by prompting difficult conversations. Even if communities decide to stay in place, identifying the things community members value can help them decide what they want to maintain and what they purposely want to change.
“If the only tools you think about are beach nourishment and building walls, you’re limiting what you can do, but if you start adding in the whole toolkit and combining the options in different ways, you can create a much wider range of futures,” she said.
In the paper, Siders and Mach argue that long-term adaptation will involve retreat. Even traditionally accepted visions of the future, like building flood walls and elevating threatened structures, will involve small-scale retreat to make space for levees and drainage. Larger-scale retreat may be needed for more ambitious transformations, such as building floating neighborhoods or cities, turning roads into canals in an effort to live with the water, or building more dense, more compact cities on higher ground.
Some, but not all these futures currently exist.
In the Netherlands, the municipality of Rotterdam has installed floating homes in Nassau harbor that move with the tides, providing a sustainable waterfront view for homeowners while making room for public-friendly green space along the water. In New York City, one idea under consideration is building into the East River to accommodate a floodwall. Both cities are using combination strategies that leverage more than one adaptation tool.
Adaptation decisions don’t have to be either/or decisions. However, it is important to remember that these efforts take time, so planning should begin now.
“Communities, towns, and cities are making decisions now that affect the future,” said Siders. “Locally, Delaware is building faster inside the floodplain than outside of it. We are making plans for beach nourishment and where to build seawalls. We’re making these decisions now, so we should be considering all the options on the table now, not just the ones that keep people in place.”
According to Siders, the paper is a conversation starter for researchers, policymakers, communities and residents that are invested in helping communities thrive amid changing climate. These discussions, she said, shouldn’t focus solely on where we need to move from, but also where we should avoid building, where new building should be encouraged, and how we should build differently.
“Managed retreat can be more effective in reducing risk, in ways that are socially equitable and economically efficient, if it is a proactive component of climate-driven transformations,” said Mach. “It can be used to address climate risks, along with other types of responses like building seawalls or limiting new development in hazard-prone regions.”
Globally, Siders said the U.S. is in a privileged position, in terms of the available space, money and resources, relative to other countries facing more complicated futures. The Republic of Kiribati, a chain of islands in the central Pacific Ocean, for example, is expected to be under water in the future. Some of its islands already are uninhabitable.
The Kiribati government has bought land in Fiji for relocation and is developing programs with Australia and New Zealand to provide skilled workforce training so the Kiribati people can migrate with dignity when the time comes. Challenges remain, though, since not everyone is on board with moving.
In a recent special issue of the Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences, edited and introduced by Siders and Idowu (Jola) Ajibade at Portland State University, researchers examined the social justice implications of managed retreat in examples from several countries, including the U.S., Marshall Islands, New Zealand, Peru, Sweden, Taiwan, Austria and England. The scientists explored how retreat affects groups of people and, in the U.S., specifically considered how retreat affects marginalized populations.
So, how can society do better? According to Siders, it starts with longer-term thinking.
“It’s hard to make good decisions about climate change if we are thinking 5-10 years out,” said Siders. “We are building infrastructure that lasts 50-100 years; our planning scale should be equally long.”
Original Article: Managed retreat: A must in the war against climate change
More from: University of Delaware
The Latest Updates from Bing News & Google News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
War against climate change
- On day two of Mexico Summit, Biden to talk Ukraine-Russia war, clean energy with Canada
President Joe Biden and Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to discuss clean energy and Ukraine. A trilateral meeting with Mexico expected Tuesday.
- Ukraine's fight against Russia. Climate catastrophe. International news to watch in 2023
Still, there are some international story lines that are likely to dominate global headlines in 2023. Here's a selection to watch for. There appears to be no end in sight to a war that was started by ...
- WaPo torched for 'nonsense' piece linking domestic violence to climate change
Martha MacCallum criticized The Washington Post's move to link climate change to domestic violence, saying it "siphons off" what people are suffering from.
- What 2023 Holds for the Fight Against Climate Change
This is what the first 20 episodes of Bloomberg Green’s Zero podcast tell us about the future of climate action.
- Would Nuclear Winter Cancel Out Global Warming?
Nuclear war was very much a front-of-mind issue during ... degrees of humor that it could help cancel out the effects of global warming. But what is the truth? Hard data is isn’t really ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
War against climate change
[google_news title=”” keyword=”war against climate change” num_posts=”5″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
Go deeper with Bing News on:
Climate change adaptation
- Hawaii speaks on importance of climate change action
A conference was held at the east-west center Monday, January 9, 2023, to highlight existing actions and the possible next steps to ensure readiness for the effects of climate change.
- Project Empowers Farmers On Climate Change Resilience
INADES Formation Tanzania, a Non-Governmental Organisation (NGO), which is affiliated to the international association of Inades Formation, has implemented a special project on climate change ...
- FG is Scaling Up Climate Change Adaptation Efforts, Says Sadiya Farouq
The federal government, through the Federal Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs, Disaster Management and Social Development (FMHADMSD), is scaling up climate change adaptation efforts in Nigeria so ...
- Misreading Climate Change in Bangladesh
Perilously close to rising sea levels and vulnerable to floods, erosion, and cyclones, Bangladesh is one of the top recipients of development aid earmarked for adaptation to climate change.
- State, federal lawmakers direct millions toward climate resilience, adaptation projects
Millions of dollars, for projects large and small, will flow to each of Maine's counties in 2023 from state and federal coffers.
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Climate change adaptation
[google_news title=”” keyword=”climate change adaptation” num_posts=”5″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]