“In most cases, companies do not offer any explanation about how they gain access to users’ profiles, from where they collect the data, and with whom they trade their data. It’s not just fairness that’s at stake; it’s also trust.”
Tae Wan Kim
Associate Professor of Business Ethics
Increasingly, businesses rely on algorithms that use data provided by users to make decisions that affect people. For example, Amazon, Google, and Facebook use algorithms to tailor what users see, and Uber and Lyft use them to match passengers with drivers and set prices. Do users, customers, employees, and others have a right to know how companies that use algorithms make their decisions?
In a new analysis, researchers explore the moral and ethical foundations to such a right. They conclude that the right to such an explanation is a moral right, then address how companies might do so.
The analysis, by researchers at Carnegie Mellon University, appears in Business Ethics Quarterly, a publication of the Society for Business Ethics.
“In most cases, companies do not offer any explanation about how they gain access to users’ profiles, from where they collect the data, and with whom they trade their data,” explains Tae Wan Kim, Associate Professor of Business Ethics at Carnegie Mellon University’s Tepper School of Business, who co-wrote the analysis. “It’s not just fairness that’s at stake; it’s also trust.”
In response to the rise of autonomous decision-making algorithms and their reliance on data provided by users, a growing number of computer scientists and governmental bodies have called for transparency under the broad concept of algorithmic accountability. For example, the European Parliament and the Council of the European Union adopted the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in 2016, part of which regulates the use of automatic algorithmic decision systems. The GDPR, which launched in 2018, affects businesses that process the personally identifiable information of residents of the European Union.
But the GDPR is ambiguous about whether it involves a right to explanation regarding how businesses’ automated algorithmic profiling systems reach decisions. In this analysis, the authors develop a moral argument that can serve as a foundation for a legally recognized version of this right.
In the digital era, the authors write, some say that informed consent—obtaining prior permission for disclosing information with full knowledge of the possible consequences—is no longer possible because many digital transactions are ongoing. Instead, the authors conceptualize informed consent as an assurance of trust for incomplete algorithmic processes.
Obtaining informed consent, especially when companies collect and process personal data, is ethically required unless overridden for specific, acceptable reasons, the authors argue. Moreover, informed consent in the context of algorithmic decision-making, especially for non-contextual and unpredictable uses, is incomplete without an assurance of trust.
In this context, the authors conclude, companies have a moral duty to provide an explanation not just before automated decision making occurs, but also afterward, so the explanation can address both system functionality and the rationale of a specific decision.
The authors also delve into how companies that run businesses based on algorithms can provide explanations of their use in a way that attracts clients while maintaining trade secrets. This is an important decision for many modern start-ups, including such questions as to how much code should be open source, and how extensive and exposed the application program interface should be.
Many companies are already tackling these challenges, the authors note. Some may choose to hire “data interpreters,” employees who bridge the work of data scientists and the people affected by the companies’ decisions.
“Will requiring an algorithm to be interpretable or explainable hinder businesses’ performance or lead to better results?” asks Bryan R. Routledge, Associate Professor of Finance at Carnegie Mellon’s Tepper School of Business, who co-wrote the analysis. “That is something we’ll see play out in the near future, much like the transparency conflict of Apple and Facebook. But more importantly, the right to explanation is an ethical obligation apart from bottom-line impact.”
More from: Carnegie Mellon University
The Latest Updates from Bing News & Google News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- Like a Child, This Brain-Inspired AI Can Explain Its Reasoning
A new algorithm generates a kind of CliffsNotes for programmers that explain its conclusions about patterns it found in the data in plain English.
- The Algorithm for Equality
When these algorithms are built on flawed data ... fostering collaboration and understanding among people of different languages and cultures. This not only enhances our ability to work together ...
- How 'Yoga With Adriene' Crushed the YouTube Algorithm
That's just one reason why Adriene Mishler and her now-near-iconic YouTube yoga channel are so impressive. Because not only is Yoga With Adriene found, it is found often, by millions and millions. A ...
- Insurance company ratings explained
The most well-known insurance specific rating company, the scores provided by AM Best are often considered the yardstick for financial strength in the industry. The highest rating offered is A++ ...
- New bill would let defendants inspect algorithms used against them in court
A pair of Democratic lawmakers are seeking to give defendants more information about algorithms used against ... least give them a starting point for understanding whether a program matches ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
[google_news title=”” keyword=”explaining algorithms” num_posts=”5″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- How This Data Expert Is Simplifying Complex Data For Everyone
In today's data-driven world, the ability to interpret and understand complex data is becoming increasingly essential across various domains. Siva Karthik Devineni, a prominent data expert, has been ...
- Exploring Key Trends in Big Data Analytics: Essential Insights for You
In the dynamic landscape of big data analytics, remaining ahead of the curve holds paramount importance. From the integration of machine learning to the advent of real-time data processing, numerous ...
- Data Analysis for Management
Develop the skills you need to analyse, interpret and communicate data with confidence and impact within your organisation. It has been estimated that organisations experience a 5% increase in ...
- Translating brain activity data into audiovisual experiences
Complex neuroimaging data can be explored through translation into an audiovisual format – a video with accompanying musical soundtrack – to help interpret what happens in the brain when performing ...
- 'Movies' with color and music visualize brain activity data in beautiful detail
Complex neuroimaging data can be explored through translation into an audiovisual format—a video with accompanying musical soundtrack—to help interpret what happens in the brain when performing ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
[google_news title=”” keyword=”data interpreters” num_posts=”5″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]