These are maps and satellite images, real and fake, of one Tacoma neighborhood. The top left shows an image from mapping software, and the top right is an actual satellite image of the neighborhood. The bottom two panels are simulated satellite images of the neighborhood, generated from geospatial data of Seattle (lower left) and Beijing (lower right).
Zhao et al., 2021, Cartography and Geographic Information Science
A fire in Central Park seems to appear as a smoke plume and a line of flames in a satellite image. Colorful lights on Diwali night in India, seen from space, seem to show widespread fireworks activity.
Both images exemplify what a new University of Washington-led study calls “location spoofing.” The photos — created by different people, for different purposes — are fake but look like genuine images of real places. And with the more sophisticated AI technologies available today, researchers warn that such “deepfake geography” could become a growing problem.
So, using satellite photos of three cities and drawing upon methods used to manipulate video and audio files, a team of researchers set out to identify new ways of detecting fake satellite photos, warn of the dangers of falsified geospatial data and call for a system of geographic fact-checking.
“This isn’t just Photoshopping things. It’s making data look uncannily realistic,” said Bo Zhao, assistant professor of geography at the UW and lead author of the study, which published April 21 in the journal Cartography and Geographic Information Science. “The techniques are already there. We’re just trying to expose the possibility of using the same techniques, and of the need to develop a coping strategy for it.”
As Zhao and his co-authors point out, fake locations and other inaccuracies have been part of mapmaking since ancient times. That’s due in part to the very nature of translating real-life locations to map form, as no map can capture a place exactly as it is. But some inaccuracies in maps are spoofs created by the mapmakers. The term “paper towns” describes discreetly placed fake cities, mountains, rivers or other features on a map to prevent copyright infringement. On the more lighthearted end of the spectrum, an official Michigan Department of Transportation highway map in the 1970s included the fictional cities of “Beatosu and “Goblu,” a play on “Beat OSU” and “Go Blue,” because the then-head of the department wanted to give a shoutout to his alma mater while protecting the copyright of the map.
But with the prevalence of geographic information systems, Google Earth and other satellite imaging systems, location spoofing involves far greater sophistication, researchers say, and carries with it more risks. In 2019, the director of the National Geospatial Intelligence Agency, the organization charged with supplying maps and analyzing satellite images for the U.S. Department of Defense, implied that AI-manipulated satellite images can be a severe national security threat.
To study how satellite images can be faked, Zhao and his team turned to an AI framework that has been used in manipulating other types of digital files. When applied to the field of mapping, the algorithm essentially learns the characteristics of satellite images from an urban area, then generates a deepfake image by feeding the characteristics of the learned satellite image characteristics onto a different base map — similar to how popular image filters can map the features of a human face onto a cat.
Next, the researchers combined maps and satellite images from three cities — Tacoma, Seattle and Beijing — to compare features and create new images of one city, drawn from the characteristics of the other two. They designated Tacoma their “base map” city and then explored how geographic features and urban structures of Seattle (similar in topography and land use) and Beijing (different in both) could be incorporated to produce deepfake images of Tacoma.
In the example below, a Tacoma neighborhood is shown in mapping software (top left) and in a satellite image (top right). The subsequent deep fake satellite images of the same neighborhood reflect the visual patterns of Seattle and Beijing. Low-rise buildings and greenery mark the “Seattle-ized” version of Tacoma on the bottom left, while Beijing’s taller buildings, which AI matched to the building structures in the Tacoma image, cast shadows — hence the dark appearance of the structures in the image on the bottom right. Yet in both, the road networks and building locations are similar.
The untrained eye may have difficulty detecting the differences between real and fake, the researchers point out. A casual viewer might attribute the colors and shadows simply to poor image quality. To try to identify a “fake,” researchers homed in on more technical aspects of image processing, such as color histograms and frequency and spatial domains.
Some simulated satellite imagery can serve a purpose, Zhao said, especially when representing geographic areas over periods of time to, say, understand urban sprawl or climate change. There may be a location for which there are no images for a certain period of time in the past, or in forecasting the future, so creating new images based on existing ones — and clearly identifying them as simulations — could fill in the gaps and help provide perspective.
The study’s goal was not to show that geospatial data can be falsified, Zhao said. Rather, the authors hope to learn how to detect fake images so that geographers can begin to develop the data literacy tools, similar to today’s fact-checking services, for public benefit.
“As technology continues to evolve, this study aims to encourage more holistic understanding of geographic data and information, so that we can demystify the question of absolute reliability of satellite images or other geospatial data,” Zhao said. “We also want to develop more future-oriented thinking in order to take countermeasures such as fact-checking when necessary,” he said.
The Latest Updates from Bing News & Google News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- Deepfake Geography: How AI Can Now Falsify Satellite Imageson June 8, 2021 at 9:32 pm
As AI technology grows more sophisticated, the rise of “deepfake geography” could become a growing problem for investigative journalists.
- What constitutes an ideal social media policy?on June 2, 2021 at 12:38 am
Technologies are rapidly advancing too. Consider just artificial intelligence and deepfake, each of which poses unique and unforeseen challenges. Constant oversight, and a fast-evolving set of ...
- Deepfake Geography: The Problem of AI Falsifying Satellite Photoson June 1, 2021 at 11:35 pm
A group of researchers at the University of Washington (UW) are tacking the problems related to deepfake geography. The lead author of ...
- Why Asian corner shop is in declineon May 24, 2021 at 5:00 pm
The revealing snapshot of Asian Britain today is the result of research by David McEvoy, Professor of Urban Geography at Liverpool John Moores University. Lecturing at the Royal Geographical ...
- FNS Globally Launches an App Service for FANTOO, a Network-Based Platform for K-Fanson May 17, 2021 at 5:03 am
The FANTOO app provides a fan club creation, user reward, multi-lingual chatting & translation, a messenger with improved security, FANTOO Karaoke for live concert, artists’ live streaming, voice call ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- E-mail spoofing attacks double in a monthon June 15, 2021 at 1:39 am
Although spoofing may seem primitive when compared to some of the other techniques used by attackers, it can be highly effective.
- What is spoofing in Pokemon GO?on June 14, 2021 at 9:22 pm
Spoofing is an act of tricking your mobile device's GPS into thinking it’s in another location in the world. There are multiple reasons why a Pokemon GO player would spoof. For instance, during ...
- Spoofing WiFi AP Based Geolocationon June 11, 2021 at 5:00 pm
[Pierre Dandumont] just finished up a little project that will give Google Maps’ location feature a run for its money. It’s a technique that spoofs WiFi networks in order to relocate the ...
- How to spoof your location for Pokémon GO on Androidon June 11, 2021 at 3:52 am
While all of the best VPN services can make regular websites think you're in a different location by using regional servers, hardly any can spoof your GPS location for Pokémon GO. So, while using ...
- Deon and Roxanne Avent Taylor Talk ‘Meet the Blacks 2’ and Blazing Their Own Path With Hidden Empire Film Groupon June 10, 2021 at 4:00 pm
Hidden Empire Film Group founders Deon Taylor and Roxanne Avent Taylor are at it again with “The House Next Door: Meet the Blacks 2,” the sequel to their hit horror spoof “Meet the Blacks.” In ...