via Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
Computer scientists propose systemic changes in automatic content curation
As the volume of available information expands, the fraction a person is able to absorb shrinks. They end up retreating into a narrow slice of thought, becoming more vulnerable to misinformation, and polarizing into isolated enclaves of competing opinions. To break this cycle, computer scientists say we need new algorithms that prioritize a broader view over fulfilling consumer biases.
“This is a call to arms,” said Boleslaw Szymanski, a professor of computer science at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute. “Informed citizens are the foundation of democracy, but the interest of big companies, who supply that information, is to sell us a product. The way they do that on the internet is to repeat what we showed interest in. They’re not interested in a reader’s growth; they’re interested in the reader’s continued attention.”
Szymanski and colleagues at the University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign, the University of California, Los Angeles, and the University of California, San Diego, explore this troubling “paradox of information access,” in a paper published on arXiv.org.
“You would think that enabling everybody to be an author would be a blessing,” said Szymanski, an expert in social and cognitive networks, with previous work that includes findings on the power of a committed minority to sway outcomes. “But the attention span of human beings is not prepared for hundreds of millions of authors. We don’t know what to read, and since we cannot select everything, we simply go back to the familiar, to works that represent our own beliefs.”
Nor is the effect entirely unprecedented, said Tarek Abdelzaher, a professor and University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign lead on the project.
“It’s not the first time that affordances of connectivity and increased access have led to polarization,” said Abdelzaher. “When the U.S. interstate freeway system was built, urban socioeconomic polarization increased. Connectivity allowed people to self-segregate into more homogenous sprawling neighborhoods. The big question this project answers is: how to undo the polarizing effects of creating the information super-highway?”
The effect is exacerbated when our own human limitations are combined with information curations systems that maximize “clicks.”
To disrupt this cycle, the authors contend that the algorithms that provide a daily individualized menu of information must be changed from systems that merely “give consumers more of what these consumers express interest in.”
The authors propose adapting a technique long used in conveying history, which is to provide a tighter summation for events further back from the present day. They call this model for content curation “a scalable presentation of knowledge.” Algorithms would shift from “extractive summarization,” which gives us more of what we consumed in the past, to “abstractive summarization,” which increases the proportion of available thought we can digest.
“As long as you do balance content, you can cover more distant knowledge in much less space,” said Szymanski, who is also the director of a Network Science and Technology Center at Rensselaer. “Although readers have a finite attention span, they still have a slight knowledge in new areas, and then they can choose to shift their attention in a new direction or stay the course.”
Few analytical models exist to measure the trend toward what the authors call “ideological fragmentation in an age of democratized global access.” But one, which the authors considered, treats individuals as “particles in a belief space” — almost like a fluid — and measures their changing positions based on the change in content they share over time. The model “confirms the emergence of polarization with increased information overload.”
The more ideologically isolated and polarized we are, the more we are vulnerable to disinformation tailored to reinforce our own biases. Szymanski and his colleagues offer a slew of technical solutions to reduce misinformation, including better data provenance and algorithms that detect misinformation, such as internal consistency reasoning, background consistency reasoning, and intra-element consistency reasoning tools.
“The very sad development discussed in this paper is that today, people are not conversing with each other. We are living in our own universe created by the data which is coming from these summarization systems, data that confirms our innate biases,” Szymanski said. “This a big issue which we face as a democracy, and I think we have a duty to address it for the good of society.”
Szymanski and his co-authors are working on mathematical models that both measure the extent of polarization in various media, and predict how trends would change under various mitigating strategies.
The Latest Updates from Bing News & Google News
Go deeper with Bing News on:
Automatic content curation
- Sony’s most affordable Cognitive Processor XR TVs start at $1,300on April 6, 2021 at 12:20 am
Along with the new XR technologies, Sony has moved into full support for HDMI 2.1, including HDMI eARC, 4K resolution at 120Hz, auto low-latency ... adds a layer of content curation ...
- Everything wrong with the Nintendo Switch eShopon April 4, 2021 at 2:59 am
Inputting game names manually is usually a surefire way to find something, and high-profile titles will come up in an auto ... temporary content categories, like BAFTA-winning games, at certain times ...
- Adobe Photoshop Elementson April 1, 2021 at 11:35 pm
The Organizer search bar lets you filter content by people ... The first time I tried to check this, it said Auto Curation was in progress—understandable, since it analyzes your entire photo ...
- Digital paid subscriptions expected to double to over 100 million by 2023: FICCI-EY reporton March 29, 2021 at 9:16 pm
While certain sectors like travel showed a marked decline, sectors like M&E, Auto ... The proposed content code will require the implementation of processes for content curation, checks, and ...
- MIT study finds ‘systematic’ labeling errors in popular AI benchmark datasetson March 29, 2021 at 6:32 am
The processes used to construct corpora often involve some degree of automatic annotation or crowdsourcing ... test accuracy and to follow dataset curation practices that maximize high-quality ...
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Automatic content curation
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- A Concert of Powers Is an Idea Whose Time Has Come—and Goneon April 7, 2021 at 4:59 pm
The era of Western material dominance and ideological supremacy is over ... The concert would also likely encourage the world’s fragmentation into at least tacit spheres of influence, as ...
- Jordan's volatility alerts the US to Middle East realityon April 6, 2021 at 9:00 pm
Arab/Muslim violence is documented by the 11 m. Muslims killed in wars and terrorism since 1948, of which 35,000, (0.3%) died during the Arab wars against Israel.
- Jordan’s Volatility Could Shake Up the Middle Easton April 6, 2021 at 8:24 am
Jordan’s inherent political and ideological vulnerability has been fueled by intra-fragmentation and conflicts, dating back to 1921, when the Hashemite Bedouin family was imported to Jordan — from ...
- Spain’s conservative revolutionon April 3, 2021 at 5:00 pm
“Pedro Sánchez’s only hope is fragmentation, the division of all us who love ... “He’s a very young person but with deep ideological convictions,” Zarzalejos said. “He represents the most conservative ...
- Hindu vs Hindu: Fighting fanaticism within, the Lohia wayon March 22, 2021 at 6:38 pm
To prevent fragmentation The fanatical in Hindu mind ... Lohia was convinced that only an ideological revolution – synthesis of spirituality and reality – can help liberal in Hindu mind ...