ASM experimental interface. The left-side monitor displays the lead Soldier’s point of view of the task environment. The right-side monitor displays the ASM’s communication interface.
What does it take for a human to trust a robot? That is what Army researchers are uncovering in a new study into how humans and robots work together.
Research into human-agent teaming, or HAT, has examined how the transparency of agents–such as robots, unmanned vehicles or software agents–influences human trust, task performance, workload and perceptions of the agent. Agent transparency refers to its ability to convey to humans its intent, reasoning process and future plans.
New Army-led research finds that human confidence in robots decreases after the robot makes a mistake, even when it is transparent with its reasoning process. The paper, “Agent Transparency and Reliability in HumanRobot Interaction: The Influence on User Confidence and Perceived Reliability,” has been published in the August issue of IEEE-Transactions on Human-Machine Systems.
To date, research has largely focused on HAT with perfectly reliable intelligent agents–meaning the agents do not make mistakes–but this is one of the few studies that has explored how agent transparency interacts with agent reliability. In this latest study, humans witnessed a robot making a mistake, and researchers focused on whether the humans perceived the robot to be less reliable, even when the human was provided insight into the robot’s reasoning process.
“Understanding how the robot’s behavior influences their human teammates is crucial to the development of effective human-robot teams, as well as the design of interfaces and communication methods between team members,” said Dr. Julia Wright, principal investigator for this project and researcher at U.S. Army Combat Capabilities Development Command’s Army Research Laboratory, also known as ARL. “This research contributes to the Army’s Multi-Domain Operations efforts to ensure overmatch in artificial intelligence-enabled capabilities. But it is also interdisciplinary, as its findings will inform the work of psychologists, roboticists, engineers, and system designers who are working toward facilitating better understanding between humans and autonomous agents in the effort to make autonomous teammates rather than simply tools.
This research was a joint effort between ARL and the University of Central Florida Institute for Simulations and Training, and is the third and final study in the Autonomous Squad Member project, sponsored by the Office of Secretary of Defense’s Autonomy Research Pilot Initiative. The ASM is a small ground robot that interacts with and communicates with an infantry squad.
Prior ASM studies investigated how a robot would communicate with a human teammate. Using the Situation awareness-based Agent Transparency model as a guide, various visualization methods to convey the agent’s goals, intents, reasoning, constraints, and projected outcomes were explored and tested. An at-a-glance iconographic module was developed based on these early study findings, and then was used in subsequent studies to explore the efficacy of agent transparency in HAT.
Researchers conducted this study in a simulated environment, in which participants observed a human-agent Soldier team, which included the ASM, traversing a training course. The participants’ task was to monitor the team and evaluate the robot. The Soldier-robot team encountered various events along the course and responded accordingly. While the Soldiers always responded correctly to the event, occasionally the robot misunderstood the situation, leading to incorrect actions. The amount of information the robot shared varied between trials. While the robot always explained its actions, the reasons behind its actions and the expected outcome of its actions, in some trials the robot also shared the reasoning behind its decisions, its underlying logic. Participants viewed multiple Soldier-robot teams, and their assessments of the robots were compared.
The study found that regardless of the robot’s transparency in explaining its reasoning, the robot’s reliability was the ultimate determining factor in influencing the participants’ projections of the robot’s future reliability, trust in the robot and perceptions of the robot. That is, after participants witnessed an error, they continued to rate the robot’s reliability lower, even when the robot did not make any subsequent errors. While these evaluations slowly improved over time as long as the robot committed no further errors, participants’ confidence in their own assessments of the robot’s reliability remained lowered throughout the remainder of the trials, when compared to participants who never saw an error. Furthermore, participants who witnessed a robot error reported lower trust in the robot, when compared to those who never witnessed a robot error.
Increasing agent transparency was found to improve participants’ trust in the robot, but only when the robot was collecting or filtering information. This could indicate that sharing in-depth information may mitigate some of the effects of unreliable automation for specific tasks, Wright said. Additionally, participants rated the unreliable robot as less animate, likable, intelligent, and safe than the reliable robot.
“Earlier studies suggest that context matters in determining the usefulness of transparency information,” Wright said. “We need to better understand which tasks require more in-depth understanding of the agent’s reasoning, and how to discern what that depth would entail. Future research should explore ways to deliver transparency information based on the tasking requirements.”
Learn more: When it comes to robots, reliability may matter more than reasoning
The Latest on: Human-agent teaming
via Google News
The Latest on: Human-agent teaming
- This Plano Agent Is Engineering Continued Success in a New Careeron August 6, 2022 at 2:04 am
In our latest agent profile, Jeffrey McKee of Plano explains how engineering taught him to succeed in a real estate career.
- People are faster at understanding human actions than robotic movements – studyon August 4, 2022 at 12:15 am
Researchers say the study highlights potential challenges for a future where robots are incorporated more into our daily lives.
- Feds spotlight Aurora in human trafficking crackdown, arrest 70 in PNWon August 2, 2022 at 3:04 pm
On average, 300 people buy sex along Aurora Avenue in King County every day, according to HSI Special Agent Jayme McFarland.
- Dying Light 2 Stay Human Patch 1.5 and Second Chapter brings New Missions, Bounties, and Enemieson August 1, 2022 at 7:36 am
Dying Light 2 Stay Human is already huge, with a ton of content for gamers to get involved in. Very soon though the Techland team behind it will be dropping Patch 1.5 to the masses, rolling out a ...
- Retired HSI Supervisory Special Agent Joins Xenith Solutionson August 1, 2022 at 7:05 am
Xenith Solutions today announced Matthew Peterson will be joining Xenith as a DHS Client Executive, effective 1 August 2022. Matt is joining the company from the Department of Homeland Security's (DHS ...
- 'In plain sight every single day:' Feds crackdown on human trafficking in King Countyon July 30, 2022 at 3:03 am
Homeland Security Investigations are working to crack down on human trafficking in King County, not just by making arrests, but also by making connections.
- State agencies join forces to combat human traffickingon July 28, 2022 at 7:01 pm
In January 2022 Pate launched the Iowa Businesses Against Trafficking (IBAT) initiative. Pate says he has recruited hundreds of businesses across Iowa to help spot and stop human trafficking through.
- Trio of key Raiders arrive at camp with team-first mentalityon July 27, 2022 at 9:26 pm
And while they’re leaders in their respective units — and the trio comes with no guarantees for their futures with the team — all three had similar mindsets during the first week of camp. “I’m focused ...
- Hydrogen generated by Si-based agent attenuates inflammation in ulcerative colitis mouse modelon July 25, 2022 at 6:24 am
Osaka University researchers designed a silicon-based agent that successfully generated hydrogen continuously in the mouse gastrointestinal tract in an ulcerative colitis (UC) model. The hydrogen ...
- Laivly adds AI, ML and automation to improve CXon July 18, 2022 at 7:51 am
“Your frontline team is dealing with your customers ... “Service delivered by human agents (not robots) is what drives positive customer outcomes.” Forrester predicts that companies will ...
via Bing News