Finding natural gas leaks more quickly and at lower cost could reduce methane emissions. Ten promising technologies mounted on drones, trucks and airplanes were tested last year. The results are in.
On trucks, drones and airplanes, 10 promising technologies for finding natural gas leaks swiftly and cheaply competed in the Mobile Monitoring Challenge, the first independent assessment of moving gas leak detectors at well sites. The organizers of the contest – Stanford University’s Natural Gas Initiative and the Environmental Defense Fund – describe the outcomes in a study published Sept. 10 in Elementa by University of California Press.
While billed as a “challenge,” the organizers had no intention of declaring a winner, as the technologies focused on different aspects of leak detection, such as exact location or size of the leak. While the technologies are still in development, overall, they all found gas leaks quite well.
The study examined finding leaks at production equipment that can be found in a gas field, not on finding below-ground leaks that might occur from pipes in cities.
Leaks in the production, processing and transport of natural gas emit methane – the main constituent of natural gas – into the atmosphere. A greenhouse gas, methane is 36 times more potent than carbon dioxide. In 2016, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency moved to reduce methane emissions across the natural gas industry, which spurred the development of faster, less expensive detection technologies. Late last month, however, the EPA moved to roll back these methane regulations.
“The technologies are generally effective at detecting leaks, and can act as a first line of defense,” said Adam Brandt, an associate professor of energy resources engineering and the senior author of the study. “Gas system operators will often want to confirm leaks with conventional optical gas imaging systems, but these mobile technologies usually tell you where to look for leaks very quickly.”
A crew of two people using a conventional imaging system can visit four to six well pads a day. All the mobile technologies are considerably faster than that, though their speeds vary a lot. Plane-based systems work more quickly than trucks, which are faster than drones. Because worker time is a large part of detection cost, speeding up detection allows oil and gas companies to find more leaks while spending less money.
As part of the Mobile Monitoring Challenge, nine corporations and a university research team participated last year at controlled testing facilities in Fort Collins, Colorado, and near Sacramento, California. All technologies were effective at detecting leaks. Eight of nine detected leaks correctly 75 percent of the time. (One technology did not have enough flights to be included in the study’s summary.) Five of nine systems detected 90 percent or more of the leaks, including tiny emissions of one cubic foot of gas per hour.
However, most of the systems tested need to improve their ability to quantify the size of the leaks. Also, the technologies varied in their ability to detect the precise location of the leaks, though this is often by design.
For example, one startup’s drone-based system detected 100 percent of leaks and had no false positives. Further, it accurately identified the leaking piece of equipment – rather than just the well pad – 84 percent of the time. However, when quantifying the size of leaks, the system’s estimates were relatively close just 36 percent of the time. For the other eight systems, by the same relatively strict measure, quantification accuracy ranged from 18 to 53 percent.
“This is only the first step to demonstrating that these technologies could help reduce emissions on a level equivalent to existing approaches,” Brandt said. “The tests were run in the spring of 2018, and I’m sure most – if not all – of these technologies have been improved since then.”
Further advances could be in jeopardy, however.
“The recent U.S. EPA announcement about rolling back methane regulations is not just bad for the environment, but also deprives oil and gas communities of high-paying, local jobs that these innovative technology companies could create. Rolling back the regulations could stifle development of these technologies,” said Arvind Ravikumar, lead author of the study. Ravikumar was a postdoctoral scholar at Stanford at the time of the project and is now an assistant professor at the Harrisburg University of Science & Technology.
An assessment like this can help regulators better understand these systems and provide a possible path to large-scale adoption for compliance purposes, the researchers said.
Designs for different uses
The Mobile Monitoring Challenge was not a head-to-head competition because the technologies tested are designed to accomplish different things.
“No single technology can meet all the requirements for leak detection and quantification across the natural gas supply chain,” Ravikumar said. “The key to large-scale deployment is to match the strength of each technology, like speed, accuracy and cost, with the right leak detection application. What works for a complex processing facility might not work for long-distance transmission pipelines.”
The systems of some participants focus on identifying leaks only as coming from a cluster of equipment, which could include a wellhead, a separator and a tank, for example. In such cases, operators would use optical gas imaging systems or similar technology to identify the specific source of the leak before initiating repairs.
Similarly, two of the technologies tested are designed to quickly find big leaks, rather than all leaks. More than half the methane lost in natural gas production and processing comes from just 5 percent of leaks. Finding and fixing these “super-emitters” is critical to reducing methane emissions.
Even without strict regulations, natural gas companies could reduce emissions voluntarily. Inexpensive detectors combined with focused use of optical gas imaging systems could pay for themselves by reducing losses of company product. This is particularly true in parts of the world where natural gas prices are higher than in North America.
The Latest on: Methane emissions
[google_news title=”” keyword=”methane emissions” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
via Google News
The Latest on: Methane emissions
- Scientists tackling livestock emissions problemon November 29, 2023 at 4:12 pm
Despite these promising results, researchers want to keep developing more products to suppress methane emissions from livestock. Huws said a long-term concern is that rumen microbes will adapt and ...
- 'A no-brainer solution': Canada bolsters fight against powerful pollutant methane to help country reach climate goalson November 29, 2023 at 12:37 pm
Canada is ramping up its climate battle by strengthening its regulations for methane, a greenhouse gas that environmental experts say has a more potent warming effect than carbon dioxide, as the ...
- Politics and technology are pushing oil firms to cut methaneon November 29, 2023 at 11:32 am
As delegates gather in Dubai for the COP28 summit, an annual UN-sponsored climate chinwag, much attention will be focused on methane instead. Unlike CO2, which lingers in the air for centuries, ...
- Tackling Methane Emissions: Triple Crown’s Secret to Successon November 28, 2023 at 9:03 pm
Triple Crown Resources, the private Permian Basin operator, is cutting methane emissions and delivering returns.
- ExxonMobil makes U-turn on monitoring its methane emissionson November 28, 2023 at 9:01 pm
ExxonMobil has agreed to join the UN’s flagship methane emissions reporting programme as it seeks to present a more transparent image after years of resisting external monitoring of its approach to ...
- What the EU’s new methane emissions limit will mean for businesson November 28, 2023 at 10:49 am
Methane, the second-biggest cause of climate change after carbon dioxide (CO₂), will have to be tackled by oil and gas companies under a new EU law.
- Action On Methane Emissions To Be On Agenda At COP28on November 28, 2023 at 8:57 am
The upcoming UN climate talks in the UAE are anticipated to focus heavily on methane emissions, especially in light of China's recent commitment to include this potent greenhouse gas in its 2035 ...
- Alberta hits methane reduction target three years early, says governmenton November 28, 2023 at 6:33 am
The Alberta government says it has now reduced methane emissions from the oil and gas sector by 45 per cent since 2014. Government officials say Alberta was the first province in Canada to set a ...
- Ottawa poised to announce new methane regulations, heading into COP28on November 27, 2023 at 12:52 am
These regulations will be the cornerstone of Canada’s COP28 climate plan, which hopes to reduce emissions by 40 per cent to 45 per cent below 2005 levels by 2030 ...
- Methane mitigationon November 23, 2023 at 4:01 pm
From making methane emissions visible and measurable, Dr. Johnson and his team are working to compile comprehensive emissions inventories with the idea that knowing where methane leaks occur can lead ...
via Bing News