Mellon-funded report Mind the Gap catalogs and analyzes all available open-source software for publishing and warns that open publishing must grapple with the dual challenges of siloed development and organization of the community-owned ecosystem
The MIT Press is pleased to release Mind the Gap (openly published at mindthegap.pubpub.org), a major report on the current state of all available open-source software for publishing. Funded by a grant from The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, the report “shed[s] light on the development and deployment of open-source publishing technologies in order to aid institutions’ and individuals’ decision-making and project planning.” It will be an unparalleled resource for the scholarly publishing community and complements the recently released Mapping the Scholarly Communication Landscape census.
The report authors, led by John Maxwell, Associate Professor and Director of the Publishing Program at Simon Fraser University, catalog 52 open-source online publishing platforms, i.e. production and hosting systems for scholarly books and journals, that meet the survey criteria of “available, documented open-source software relevant to scholarly publishing” and in active development. This research provides the foundation for a thorough analysis of the open publishing ecosystem and the availability, affordances, and current limitations of these platforms and tools.
The number of open-source online publishing platforms has proliferated in the last decade, but the report finds that they are often too small, too siloed, and too niche to have much impact beyond their host organization or institution. This leaves them vulnerable to shifts in organizational priorities and external funding sources that emphasize new projects over the maintenance and improvement of existing projects. This fractured ecosystem is difficult to navigate, and the report concludes that if open publishing is to become a durable alternative to complex and costly proprietary services, it must grapple with the dual challenges of siloed development and organization of the community-owned ecosystem itself.
“What are the forces–and organizations–that serve the larger community, that mediate between individual projects, between projects and use cases, and between projects and resources,” asks the report. “Neither a chaotic plurality of disparate projects nor an efficiency-driven, enforced standard is itself desirable, but mediating between these two will require broad agreement about high-level goals, governance, and funding priorities–and perhaps some agency for integration/mediation.”?
“We found that even though platform leaders and developers recognize that collaboration, standardization, and even common code layers can provide considerable benefit to project ambitions, functionality, and sustainability, the funding and infrastructure supporting open publishing projects discourages these activities,” explains Maxwell. “If the goal is to build a viable alternative to proprietary publishing models, then open publishing needs new infrastructure that incentivizes sustainability, cooperation, collaboration, and integration.”
“John Maxwell and his team have done a tremendous job collecting and analyzing data that confirm that open publishing is at a pivotal crossroads,” says Amy Brand, Director of the MIT Press. “It is imperative that the scholarly publishing community come together to find new ways to fund and incentivize collaboration and adoption if we want these projects to succeed. I look forward to the discussions that will emerge from these findings.”
The Latest on: Open-source software
via Google News
The Latest on: Open-source software
- Open source initiative to help developers measure product usageon March 7, 2021 at 11:45 am
Scarf, a company that helps open source developers measure the usage of their products and keep in touch with their commercial end-users, has launched its first initiative, known as Scarf Gateway. In ...
- Scarf exits stealth with analytics tools that help open source developers get paidon March 3, 2021 at 2:00 pm
Scarf is betting that better analytics tools can revolutionize the way open source software is developed and supported.
- $1.3M in grants go toward making the web's open-source infrastructure more equitableon March 3, 2021 at 1:40 pm
Open-source software is at the core of... well, practically everything online. To that end, $1.3 million worth of grants were announced today, split among 13 projects looking to ensure open-source ...
- Red Hat survey points to enterprises' biggest pain point with open source: Supporton March 3, 2021 at 10:58 am
Commentary: Enterprises want their vendors to contribute to open source projects, but code is just the beginning.
- Red Hat's survey results on the state of enterprise open-source softwareon March 3, 2021 at 6:50 am
If you're surprised 90% of IT leaders are using enterprise open-source software, you've been living under a rock for the last few decades. In its latest State of Enterprise Open Source report, that's ...
- Open source considered more secure than proprietary softwareon March 3, 2021 at 3:34 am
Most businesses now believe that open source software is equally or more secure than proprietary equivalents, signaling a massive shift in the perception of open source. The findings were part of the ...
- Scarf Shifts Open-Source Power Dynamics With Launch of the Scarf Gatewayon March 3, 2021 at 1:00 am
Company exits stealth, launches the Scarf Gateway to lead new movement in open-source distribution and sustainability. Scarf, the company helping open-source developers measure th ...
- Scarf Systems aims to give developers more control of their open-source softwareon March 2, 2021 at 11:14 pm
Exiting stealth mode today, Scarf Systems Inc. says it’s on a mission to help open-source software developers make better, data-informed decisions and ensure they receive more compensation for their ...
- Infrastructure modernization remains the biggest use case for enterprise open sourceon March 2, 2021 at 9:22 am
A new Red Hat report also finds that app development and digital transformation are important to users and that security perceptions have improved.
- Red Hat: Enterprises embraced open source during the pandemicon March 2, 2021 at 8:18 am
Learn more. The pandemic may have left an indelible mark on cloud infrastructure and enterprise open source software, according to a new report commissioned by Red Hat, the purveyor of enterprise ...
via Bing News