Study of thousands of players shows a simple online game works like a “vaccine”, increasing skepticism of fake news by giving people a “weak dose” of the methods behind disinformation.
Our platform offers early evidence of a way to start building blanket protection against deception, by training people to be more attuned to the techniques that underpin most fake news
An online game in which people play the role of propaganda producers to help them identify real world disinformation has been shown to increase “psychological resistance” to fake news, according to a study of 15,000 participants.
In February 2018, University of Cambridge researchers helped launch the browser game Bad News. Thousands of people spent fifteen minutes completing it, with many allowing the data to be used for a study.
Players stoke anger and fear by manipulating news and social media within the simulation: deploying twitter bots, photo-shopping evidence, and inciting conspiracy theories to attract followers – all while maintaining a “credibility score” for persuasiveness.
“Research suggests that fake news spreads faster and deeper than the truth, so combatting disinformation after-the-fact can be like fighting a losing battle,” said Dr Sander van der Linden, Director of the Cambridge Social Decision-Making Lab.
“We wanted to see if we could pre-emptively debunk, or ‘pre-bunk’, fake news by exposing people to a weak dose of the methods used to create and spread disinformation, so they have a better understanding of how they might be deceived.
“This is a version of what psychologists call ‘inoculation theory’, with our game working like a psychological vaccination.”
To gauge the effects of the game, players were asked to rate the reliability of a series of different headlines and tweets before and after gameplay. They were randomly allocated a mixture of real (“control”) and fake news (“treatment”).
The study, published today in the journal Palgrave Communications, showed the perceived reliability of fake news before playing the game had reduced by an average of 21% after completing it. Yet the game made no difference to how users ranked real news.
The researchers also found that those who registered as most susceptible to fake news headlines at the outset benefited most from the “inoculation”.
“We find that just fifteen minutes of gameplay has a moderate effect, but a practically meaningful one when scaled across thousands of people worldwide, if we think in terms of building societal resistance to fake news,” said van der Linden.
Jon Roozenbeek, study co-author also from Cambridge University, said: “We are shifting the target from ideas to tactics. By doing this, we are hoping to create what you might call a general ‘vaccine’ against fake news, rather than trying to counter each specific conspiracy or falsehood.”
Roozenbeek and van der Linden worked with Dutch media collective DROG and design agency Gusmanson to develop Bad News, and the idea of a game to inoculate against fake news has attracted much attention.
Working with the UK Foreign Office, the team have translated the game into nine different languages, including German, Serbian, Polish and Greek. WhatsApp have commissioned the researchers to create a new game for the messaging platform.
The team have also created a “junior version” for children aged 8-10, available in ten different languages so far. “We want to develop a simple and engaging way to establish media literacy at a relatively early age, then look at how long the effects last,” said Roozenbeek.
This first set of results from Bad News has its limitations, say researchers. The sample was self-selecting (those who came across the game online and opted to play), and as such was skewed toward younger, male, liberal, and more educated demographics.
With this in mind, however, the study found the game to be almost equally effective across age, education, gender, and political persuasion. Bad News has ideological balance built in: players can choose to create fake news from the left and right of the political spectrum.
There are six “badges” to earn in the game, each reflecting a common strategy used by purveyors of fake news: impersonation; conspiracy; polarisation; discrediting sources; trolling; emotionally provocative content.
Due to limited bandwidth, in-game questions measuring the effects of Bad News were deployed for four of its featured fake news badges.
For the disinformation tactic of “impersonation”, often seen in the mimicking of trusted personalities on social media, the game reduced perceived reliability of the fake headlines and tweets by 24% from pre to post gameplay.
Bad News gameplay reduced perceived reliability of deliberately polarising headlines by about 10%, and “discrediting” – attacking a legitimate source with accusations of bias – by 19%.
For “conspiracy”, the spreading of false narratives blaming secretive groups for world events, perceived reliability was reduced by 20%.
“Our platform offers early evidence of a way to start building blanket protection against deception, by training people to be more attuned to the techniques that underpin most fake news,” added Roozenbeek.
The Latest on: Fake news vaccine
via Google News
The Latest on: Fake news vaccine
- Imam says get vaccine and 'do not trust fake news' during minister visit to city mosqueon January 23, 2021 at 7:14 am
He met with the imam as well as the pharmacists and staff who run the centre today (January 23). The mosque is one of dozens of new sites across the UK offering coronavirus vaccinations. Others are ...
- Fauci implores Baltimore ministers to help get more people vaccinated against COVID-19on January 22, 2021 at 2:11 pm
Dr. Anthony Fauci met with a group of Baltimore ministers to ask for their help in getting minority communities vaccinated against the coronavirus.
- Coronavirus live news: France death toll surpasses 72,000; Brazil variant found in Germanyon January 22, 2021 at 11:00 am
France registers a further 23,292 new confirmed cases and 649 more deaths; Germany says first case of Brazilian version of virus discovered in Hesse ...
- Didn't check facts: Harbhajan Singh apologises after sharing misleading video of officials getting fake vaccine jabson January 22, 2021 at 6:05 am
Harbhajan Singh recently landed in a soup after he shared an image of two health officials getting fake vaccine jabs. Sharing the picture, Bhajji called it the reality of how leaders are taking ...
- Coronavirus live news: France to require tests for arrivals; South Africa to pay 2.5 times EU price for vaccineon January 21, 2021 at 11:37 pm
France introduces mandatory PCR tests for arrivals; Europe to designate ‘dark red’ Covid travel zones ...
- Ignore fake news about Covid-19 vaccine, says Angela Rippon after getting jabon January 21, 2021 at 10:57 am
Angela Rippon has urged people to ignore the “nonsense” and “fake news” circulating on social media and get the coronavirus vaccination after having one herself. The journalist and television ...
- Scam Alert: Martin County officials warn against fake vaccine registration linkson January 20, 2021 at 2:18 pm
Officials in Martin County are warning users to use caution when registering for COVID-19 vaccine using the third-party website Eventbrite.
- COVID-19 misinformation: scientists create a 'psychological vaccine' to protect against fake newson January 19, 2021 at 7:31 am
Anti-vaccination groups are projected to dominate social media in the next decade if left unchallenged. To counter their viral misinformation at a time when COVID-19 vaccines are being rolled out, our ...
- Fake News Causing Ethnic Minorities to Reject Vaccine, Health Official Warnson January 18, 2021 at 2:57 am
Fake news is likely to be leading people in ethnic minority communities in the U.K. to reject the coronavirus vaccine, a leading National Health Service (NHS) official has warned. Dr Harpreet Sood – ...
- New Yorkers Crowd COVID Vaccine Distribution Site After Fake Message Spreads News of Extra Doseson January 15, 2021 at 11:26 am
A fake WhatsApp message promising vaccine doses to anyone in the area lured hundreds of New Yorkers hoping to get inoculated against COVID-19. Lines wrapped around Brooklyn Army Terminal in the ...
via Bing News