
University of Illinois agricultural communications professor Taylor Ruth was a member of a research team that studied American consumers’ attitudes toward genetic modification science in hopes of saving the U.S. citrus industry from citrus greening disease.
Photo by L. Brian Stauffer
A tiny insect, no bigger than the head of a pin, is threatening to topple the multibillion-dollar citrus industry in the U.S. by infecting millions of acres of orchards with an incurable bacterium called citrus greening disease.
The battle to save the citrus industry is pitting crop producers and a team of agriculture researchers – including agricultural communications professor Taylor K. Ruth of the University of Illinois – against a formidable brown bug, the Asian citrus psyllid, which spreads the disease.
Trees infected with the disease, also called Huanglongbing or HB, bear small, misshapen, bitter-tasting green fruit and often die within five years. Currently, there’s no known cure for the disease, which has cost the U.S. citrus industry billions of dollars in crop production and thousands of jobs since it was first identified in Florida in 2005, according to agriculture experts.
Among other solutions, scientists are exploring the possibility of breeding genetically modified trees that are resistant to the disease. But given the controversy over the safety of genetically modified food, scientists need to know whether producers will adopt this technology and whether shoppers will buy and consume GM citrus fruit.
A recent study, funded by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, provides some encouraging answers.
Ruth was on a team of scientists from several universities that surveyed a representative sample of U.S. consumers and conducted focus groups to better understand American consumers’ attitudes about GM food and agriculture.
About half of the 1,050 people who responded to the survey had positive attitudes toward GM science, the researchers found. Nearly 37 percent of the consumers surveyed felt neutral about GM science and 14 percent had negative perceptions of it.
Most of the people who were receptive to GM science were white males who were millennials or younger, the data indicated. They were highly educated – most held a bachelor’s degree or higher – and affluent, with annual incomes of $75,000 or greater.
Women, on the other hand, constituted 64 percent of the group with negative feelings about GM science. Baby boomers and older adults were nearly twice as likely to fall into this group. People in this group also were less educated – about half reported some college but no degree.
The findings were published recently in the journal Science Communication. Co-authors of the paper were Joy N. Rumble, of Ohio State University; Alexa J. Lamm, of the University of Georgia; Traci Irani, of the University of Florida; and Jason D. Ellis, of Kansas State University.
Since social contexts influence public opinion on contentious issues, the survey also assessed respondents’ willingness to share their opinions about GM science, their current perceptions of others’ views on the topic and what they expected public opinion about it to be in the future.
The research team was particularly interested in exploring the potential impact of the “spiral of silence” theory, a hypothesis on public opinion formation that states in part that people who are highly vocal about their opinions in public encourage others with similar views to speak out while effectively silencing those who hold opposite views.
“If people believe the majority of others disagree with them on a topic, they will feel pressure to conform to the majority opinion,” Ruth said. “People aren’t going to be supportive of something if nobody else is supportive of it – no one wants to feel like they are different from the group. That’s the reality of the world that we live in today.”
By contrast, people surveyed who rejected GM science were more likely to express their opinion when they believed others held the opposite view. But people with positive feelings about GM technology were less likely to speak out when they believed others supported it too.
“The way others express their attitude has an indirect effect on what our attitude ends up being,” Ruth said. “We might fall in the actual majority opinion about some of these complex topics, but if other people aren’t vocalizing their opinions, we don’t know that others out there are like-minded.
“Then we start to think ‘Well, maybe I should realign my attitude to what I’m seeing in the media.’ What we see in the media is just reflective of the most dominant voice in the conversation, not necessarily the majority opinion. And I think sometimes people don’t quite understand that.”
Like climate change, GM science is among the complex challenges that some researchers call “wicked issues” – societal problems that are often poorly understood and fraught with conflict, even when the public is provided with relevant science and facts, Ruth, Rumble, Lamm and Ellis wrote in a related study.
That paper was published recently in the Journal of Agricultural Education.
“We must have these conversations about these wicked issues,” Ruth said. “If scientists let other people who don’t have a scientific background fill the void, we’re not going to be a part of that conversation and help people make decisions based upon all of the facts.”
Learn more: Future of US citrus may hinge on consumer acceptance of genetically modified food
The Latest on: Citrus greening
[google_news title=”” keyword=”citrus greening” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
via Google News
The Latest on: Citrus greening
- Fruit in crisis: Florida's orange groves buffeted by hurricane, diseaseon March 30, 2023 at 1:16 am
Vernon Hollingsworth grew up in Florida among his family's orange trees, recently ravaged by a double whammy of disease and a hurricane that have sent juice prices spiraling and left farmers blinking ...
- Walmart joins Canadian grocery rivals in pushing back against profiteering claimson March 27, 2023 at 4:57 pm
Like its Canadian counterparts, Walmart is pushing back against claims that grocers are profiting from the rising cost of food. Gonzalo Gebara, the head of Walmart Canada, told MPs on the House ...
- Scott Franklin, Debbie Wasserman Schultz lead push to change orange juice standardson March 25, 2023 at 5:27 am
Scott Franklin, a Lakeland Republican, joined forces with U.S. Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz, a Weston Democrat, to introduce the. The bill would direct the U.S. Food and Drug Administration to alter ...
- U.S.: Citrus Greening Still Throwing New Curveballs at Scientists and Growerson March 23, 2023 at 10:02 am
Citrus greening (aka, HLB) has been a major pain for Florida growers and a puzzle for scientists from more than 15 years.
- Citrus crisis: As an iconic Florida crop fades, another tree riseson March 2, 2023 at 1:37 pm
Years after the arrival of what’s called citrus greening disease, “we really don’t have a good answer,” he says. What he does have is a willingness to adapt. He and other farmers aim to ...
- Biological control against citrus greeningon May 9, 2022 at 1:27 pm
to combat citrus greening, one of the most devastating citrus grove diseases in history. Also known as HLB, which refers to its original name in Chinese (Huanglongbing, or yellow dragon disease), ...
- Trump EPA Approves Treating Citrus With Dangerous Pesticide Banned in More Than 100 Nations, Medically Important Antibioticon January 13, 2021 at 11:01 am
Both aldicarb and streptomycin were approved to combat citrus greening disease, which has harmed Florida’s citrus industry. But the EPA has already approved at least 18 different pesticides to kill ...
- Biological controls to combat citrus greeningon August 5, 2020 at 4:09 pm
in order to combat citrus greening, one of the most devastating citrus grove diseases in history. Also known as HLB, which refers to its original name in Chinese (Huanglongbing, or yellow dragon ...
- The Citrus Tree: Multiple Kinds of Fruit, One Treeon July 17, 2018 at 7:17 pm
Despite growing five or six different types of fruit, these trees require the same basic care as any citrus. The Fruit Salad Tree Company says that trees with multiple grafts do need extra pruning ...
- Length of Life for Citrus Treeson June 11, 2016 at 1:30 pm
Life-Shortening Disease A life-threatening and life-shortening disease called citrus greening, or Huanglongbing disease is a common bacterium that affects citrus plants and trees. Affected trees ...
via Bing News