A new analysis looks at what it would take for oil companies to start pumping millions of tons of carbon dioxide into their wells to boost crude production – and what it would mean for the climate.
in February 2018, Donald Trump signed into law new tax credits that reward oil companies for capturing carbon dioxide and preventing it from entering the atmosphere – either by burying the gas underground or by pumping it into wells to boost production. These tax credits, which have bipartisan support, are encouraging for those who believe that trapping CO2 from the fossil fuel industry – though no substitute for deploying cleaner energy sources – could help combat runaway climate change while society remains reliant on oil, gas and coal.
Now, a Stanford University analysis published Aug. 15 in the journal Joule suggests another way the government could encourage the oil and gas industry to capture and store carbon. The article proposes a model for how relatively small government payments could pave the way for oil reservoirs to stash away more CO2 than their burned contents unleash.
“If you look at air transport, shipping, heavy-duty land-based transportation, these are uses of fossil fuels that are definitely expected to grow,” said lead author Sally Benson, a professor of energy resources engineering at the School of Earth, Energy & Environmental Sciences (Stanford Earth). “As an insurance policy, getting everybody to contribute to solving this problem is really important, including the oil and gas industry.”
Carbon in, oil out
When injected into reservoirs, carbon dioxide can help drive oil and profits from aging wells. The technique, known as carbon dioxide-enhanced oil recovery, has been in use since the 1970s. Oil companies using it today pump in about two-and-a-half tons of carbon for every barrel of oil produced. “When you do that, the emissions from burning the oil are almost identical to the CO2 you’re putting in the reservoir,” said Benson, who co-directs Stanford’s Precourt Institute for Energy.
The problem is that most of the 65 million metric tons of CO2 used in these oil recovery projects each year comes from natural reservoirs – not refineries, power plants or other sources contributing to climate change.
In their analysis, Benson and co-author John Deutch, a professor emeritus at MIT, propose a cost-effective way of encouraging oil and gas companies to double the amount of carbon injected for every barrel of oil and to draw their CO2 from human-related sources. They say a 10-fold increase in the amount drawn from these sources could shrink the nation’s climate emissions by as much as 9.5 percent – even when accounting for the additional oil extraction made possible by injecting all that carbon.
All of this could be done at surprisingly low cost, the researchers claim, if companies start out trapping CO2 from relatively pure streams, like those vented from ethanol and fertilizer plants. According to Benson, experience gained on these projects could then help to drive down the cost of capturing and treating CO2 from mixed emission sources, such as cement and power plants.
As an insurance policy, getting everybody to contribute to solving this problem is really important, including the oil and gas industry.
Director, Precourt Institute for Energy and Professor of Energy Resources Engineering and Senior Fellow at the Precourt Institute for Energy
Lighting a fire
Benson and Deutch, who is a former head of the Central Intelligence Agency and deputy defense secretary, argue that government should encourage industry to prepare for a future with an economy-wide price on carbon emissions – in part by developing better carbon storage technology.
Doubling the amount of CO2 per barrel of oil compared to the standard practice today, as Benson and Deutch envision, would almost certainly be more expensive for operators. The new analysis suggests it would add at least $22 per ton of injected carbon in a hypothetical scenario where oil costs $100 a barrel.
“That’s a lot of cost for an oil company,” Benson said. “If one company does it and they don’t all do it, then your products are just more expensive than the competition. People just buy the cheapest crude oil they can.”
To overcome those costs and spur development of technology for carbon-negative oil recovery, the researchers suggest the government pilot test something called a reverse Dutch auction. Owners of new oil recovery projects would submit bids to the government specifying how much money they would want as a reward for carbon injection and how much CO2 they expect the project to ultimately sequester.
With this system, Benson and Deutch estimate it would cost the government about $25 per ton of carbon dioxide captured. If 30 projects earned that amount for a decade apiece, the program would trap 264 million tons of CO2, and government spending on the experiment would total $6.6 billion.
For comparison, the newly expanded tax credits offer $35 per ton of CO2 captured and put to use, or $50 per ton if the carbon is simply buried. According to Benson, her proposed pilot program could cost less and provide incentives for a wider variety of companies that may not benefit from a tax credit.
The Latest on: Carbon injection
[google_news title=”” keyword=”carbon injection” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
via Google News
The Latest on: Carbon injection
- Emergency atmospheric geoengineering wouldn't save the oceanson March 4, 2024 at 1:27 pm
Climate change is heating the oceans, altering currents and circulation patterns responsible for regulating climate on a global scale. If temperatures dropped, some of that damage could theoretically ...
- Bison and Carbon Management Canada to collaborate on MMV for deep CO2 storage on a commercial scale at the Meadowbrook Storage Hubon March 4, 2024 at 10:19 am
Carbon Management Canada (CMC) is pleased to announce Bison Low Carbon Ventures (BLCV) is a new member of CMC’s Joint Industry Partnership (JIP) Program. The collaboration between CMC and BLCV will ...
- The North Sea could become a 'central storage camp' for carbon waste. Not everyone likes the ideaon March 3, 2024 at 10:07 pm
Norway's Energy Minister Terje Aasland told CNBC that the country's so-called Longship project is seeking to create a full, large-scale value chain for carbon capture and storage. "I think the North ...
- If you build wells, carbon will comeon February 29, 2024 at 6:04 pm
“Carbon capture itself doesn’t produce any jobs,” said ... Both Chevron and Aera Energy, recently acquired by CRC, have applications in with EPA for injection wells on their own oil fields in Kern.
- Louisiana lawmakers receive briefing on carbon capture issueson February 29, 2024 at 4:00 pm
It’s the same question residents concerned about dozens of proposed carbon capture and sequestration projects ... aired a wide variety of concerns — from the impact of drilling injection wells on ...
- Scientists create new idea on how to hack a warming planet: drying the upper atmosphereon February 28, 2024 at 11:17 am
Government scientists have cooked up a new concept for how to potentially cool an overheating Earth: Fiddle with the upper atmosphere to make it a bit drier.
- Risks Ahead for $12B Alberta Oil Sands Carbon Capture Projecton February 28, 2024 at 4:00 am
Uncertain economic returns and duration of federal tax credits could delay or cancel project proposed by six oil firm majors, set to be the world’s largest, says energy sector research firm Wood ...
- Carbon Sequestration/Class VI Underground Injection: U.S. EPA Environmental Appeals Board Petition Challenging Two Indiana Permitson February 27, 2024 at 4:00 pm
The Petition requests that the EAB review two Class VI federal Underground Injection Control (“UIC”) permits issued to Wabash Carbon Services, LLC (“WCS”). The Petition states that EPA Region 5 issued ...
- Carbon TerraVault Provides 2023 Updateon February 27, 2024 at 2:14 pm
Carbon TerraVault (CTV) today provided an update on its 2023 operations. California Resources Corporation (NYSE: CRC) conducts its carbon management business through Carbon TerraVault which pursues ...
via Bing News