Ever wonder why flat earthers, birthers, climate change and Holocaust deniers stick to their beliefs in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary?
New findings from researchers at UC Berkeley suggest that feedback, rather than hard evidence, boosts people’s sense of certainty when learning new things or trying to tell right from wrong.
Developmental psychologists have found that people’s beliefs are more likely to be reinforced by the positive or negative reactions they receive in response to an opinion, task or interaction, than by logic, reasoning and scientific data.
Their findings, published today in the online issue of the journal Open Mind, shed new light on how people handle information that challenges their worldview, and how certain learning habits can limit one’s intellectual horizons.
“If you think you know a lot about something, even though you don’t, you’re less likely to be curious enough to explore the topic further, and will fail to learn how little you know,” said study lead author Louis Marti, a Ph.D. student in psychology at UC Berkeley.
This cognitive dynamic can play out in all walks of actual and virtual life, including social media and cable-news echo chambers, and may explain why some people are easily duped by charlatans.
“If you use a crazy theory to make a correct prediction a couple of times, you can get stuck in that belief and may not be as interested in gathering more information,” said study senior author Celeste Kidd, an assistant professor of psychology at UC Berkeley.
Specifically, the study examined what influences people’s certainty while learning. It found that study participants’ confidence was based on their most recent performance rather than long-term cumulative results. The experiments were conducted at the University of Rochester.
For the study, more than 500 adults, recruited online through Amazon’s Mechanical Turk crowdsourcing platform, looked at different combinations of colored shapes on their computer screens. They were asked to identify which colored shapes qualified as a “Daxxy,” a make-believe object invented by the researchers for the purpose of the experiment.
With no clues about the defining characteristics of a Daxxy, study participants had to guess blindly which items constituted a Daxxy as they viewed 24 different colored shapes and received feedback on whether they had guessed right or wrong. After each guess, they reported on whether or not they were certain of their answer.
The final results showed that participants consistently based their certainty on whether they had correctly identified a Daxxy during the last four or five guesses instead of all the information they had gathered throughout.
“What we found interesting is that they could get the first 19 guesses in a row wrong, but if they got the last five right, they felt very confident,” Marti said. “It’s not that they weren’t paying attention, they were learning what a Daxxy was, but they weren’t using most of what they learned to inform their certainty.”
An ideal learner’s certainty would be based on the observations amassed over time as well as the feedback, Marti said.
“If your goal is to arrive at the truth, the strategy of using your most recent feedback, rather than all of the data you’ve accumulated, is not a great tactic,” he said.
The Latest on: Feedback vs hard evidence
via Google News
The Latest on: Feedback vs hard evidence
- You perform better at work if it’s fun or hard workon January 13, 2021 at 5:54 am
Daily job crafting and playful work design are important work strategies that supervisors and managers should encourage in order to improve organisational functioning. Making your work more playful ...
- Pompeo says al Qaeda has new home in Iran, gives no hard evidenceon January 12, 2021 at 2:53 pm
U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said on Tuesday, without providing hard evidence, that al Qaeda had established a new home base in Iran and the United States had fewer options in dealing with the ...
- Mike Pompeo accuses says Al-Qaeda has new home in Iran, gives no hard evidenceon January 12, 2021 at 10:57 am
US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said on Tuesday (Jan 12), without providing hard evidence, that Al-Qaeda had established a new home base in Iran and the United States had fewer options in dealing ...
- UK Treasury Calls for Feedback on Approach to Cryptocurrency and Stablecoin Regulationon January 12, 2021 at 8:47 am
The U.K. Treasury has released a consultation paper aimed to gather feedback from stakeholders on its regulatory approach to cryptocurrencies.
- Improving feedback to improve student success in introductory math courseson January 8, 2021 at 12:48 pm
UB professor receives National Science Foundation grant to examine feedback strategies that may boost students’ confidence in STEM classes.
- Priesthood of All Professors? Court to Consider ‘Ministerial Exception’ for Gordon Collegeon December 28, 2020 at 4:18 am
“If Gordon is not a religious institution of higher learning, it is hard ... record [of] evidence, including Gordon’s Faculty Handbook, plaintiff’s own tenure papers, and feedback from ...
- 'No Hard Evidence' New Virus Variant More Contagious: US Officialon December 21, 2020 at 7:18 pm
"There is no hard evidence that this virus is actually more transmissible, (but) there is clear evidence that there is more of it in the population," the vaccine scientist and former ...
- Selecting Australian teams is a lot harder now, players are picked based on not a lot of evidence: Jamie Coxon January 23, 2019 at 8:17 am
"The selectors are picking teams based on not a lot of evidence. That's really hard. They have to trust ... And in his opinion, while there needs to be feedback, the communication should be ...
- Genetec and Appriss Retail integration enables instant video correlation with suspicious transactions to detect theft and fraudon August 10, 2018 at 4:47 am
With this integration, retailers can now immediately disprove or validate suspicious transactions by accessing the security video evidence associated with ... performance feedback - is hard enough ...
via Bing News