It is wartime. You and your fellow refugees are hiding from enemy soldiers, when a baby begins to cry. You cover her mouth to block the sound. If you remove your hand, her crying will draw the attention of the soldiers, who will kill everyone. If you smother the child, you’ll save yourself and the others.
If you were in that situation, which was dramatized in the final episode of the ’70s and ’80s TV series “M.A.S.H.,” what would you do?
The results of a new UCLA study suggest that scientists could make a good guess based on how the brain responds when people watch someone else experience pain. The study found that those responses predict whether people will be inclined to avoid causing harm to others when facing moral dilemmas.
“The findings give us a glimpse into what is the nature of morality,” said Dr. Marco Iacoboni, director of the Neuromodulation Lab at UCLA’s Ahmanson-Lovelace Brain Mapping Center and the study’s senior author. “This is a foundational question to understand ourselves, and to understand how the brain shapes our own nature.”
In the study, which was published in Frontiers in Integrative Neuroscience, Iacoboni and colleagues analyzed mirror neurons, brain cells that respond equally when someone performs an action or simply watches someone else perform the same action. Mirror neurons play a vital role in how people learn through mimicry and feel empathy for others.
When you wince while seeing someone experience pain — a phenomenon called “neural resonance” — mirror neurons are responsible.
Iacoboni wondered if neural resonance might play a role in how people navigate complicated problems that require both conscious deliberation and consideration of another’s feelings.
To find out, researchers showed 19 volunteers two videos: one of a hypodermic needle piercing a hand, and another of a hand being gently touched by a cotton swab. During both, the scientists used a functional MRI machine to measure activity in the volunteers’ brains.
Researchers later asked the participants how they would behave in a variety of moral dilemmas, including the scenario involving the crying baby during wartime, the prospect of torturing another person to prevent a bomb from killing several other people and whether to harm research animals in order to cure AIDS.
Participants also responded to scenarios in which causing harm would make the world worse — inflicting harm on another person in order to avoid two weeks of hard labor, for example — to gauge their willingness to cause harm for moral reasons and for less-noble motives.
Iacoboni and his colleagues hypothesized that people who had greater neural resonance than the other participants while watching the hand-piercing video would also be less likely to choose to silence the baby in the hypothetical dilemma, and that proved to be true. Indeed, people with stronger activity in the inferior frontal cortex, a part of the brain essential for empathy and imitation, were less willing to cause direct harm, such as silencing the baby.
But the researchers found no correlation between people’s brain activity and their willingness to hypothetically harm one person in the interest of the greater good — such as silencing the baby to save more lives. Those decisions are thought to stem from more cognitive, deliberative processes.
The study confirms that genuine concern for others’ pain plays a causal role in moral dilemma judgments, Iacoboni said. In other words, a person’s refusal to silence the baby is due to concern for the baby, not just the person’s own discomfort in taking that action.
Iacoboni’s next project will explore whether a person’s decision-making in moral dilemmas can be influenced by decreasing or enhancing activity in the areas of the brain that were targeted in the current study.
“It would be fascinating to see if we can use brain stimulation to change complex moral decisions through impacting the amount of concern people experience for others’ pain,” Iacoboni said. “It could provide a new method for increasing concern for others’ well-being.”
The research could point to a way to help people with mental disorders such as schizophrenia that make interpersonal communication difficult, Iacoboni said.
The Latest on: Nature of morality
- Jose Mourinho takes aim at Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and accuses media of a lack of honesty in diversionary ranton April 11, 2021 at 12:55 pm
“It’s sad you don’t have the moral honestly to treat me the same way as you treat ... Sometimes wrong. That’s the nature of the job,” he said. “I can’t say what I think. You [the media] know that. You ...
- 14 of ministers in ex-Maharashtra CM’s cabinet faced allegations, but none resigned: Sanjay Rauton April 11, 2021 at 11:57 am
Sanjay Raut slammed the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) over the current political situation in Maharashtra. Raut said that 14 ministers in the previous BJP-led Devendra Fadnavis government faced serious ...
- Ebenezer Obey-Fabiyi: Commander of Music and Evangelist of Morals, By Toyin Falolaon April 11, 2021 at 9:34 am
Since humans know that everything in nature comes before them, they would be guided on their moral perception of life. Nature’s gifts are, therefore, meant to be enjoyed and valued accordingly. People ...
- ‘Voyagers’: Neil Burger’s ‘Lord Of The Flies’ In Space Morality Tale Is Never Quite True To Its Nature [Review]on April 10, 2021 at 6:54 am
To say that Lionsgate’s sci-fi film “Voyagers” never honors its true nature would be overstating the case and unfair to filmmaker well-intentioned Neil Burger’s latest directorial effort. But as an ...
- World meeting on the family concludes calling for protection of “natural marriage”on April 8, 2021 at 11:41 am
The statement declares that “the family is an institution of natural right, the origin of society and its most basic and fundamental unit,” adding that “marriage, based on human nature, is the ...
- In the Act of Livingon April 8, 2021 at 6:34 am
The data is in place, but we also see the dance of morality, the implicit motions of social existence ... He is not that, and Lee is spirited at catching the unpredictable nature of his talent and the ...
- Students to Present at Fourth Annual Power of Language Conferenceon April 7, 2021 at 5:00 pm
Power of Language Conference began in 2018 as an opportunity for students to showcase multilingualism and language learning at the University. This year, there are seven panels and one performance ...
- The candy-coated morality tales of Wong Pingon April 7, 2021 at 10:43 am
The artist, animator, and self-proclaimed comedian touches on the personal and political with his “Digital Fables.” ...
- The possibility of decriminalizing gambling in Brazil by the Supreme Courton April 7, 2021 at 6:46 am
In an article on the decriminalization of gambling from the vote in the Supreme Court (STF) of General Repercussion 966.177, which should take place this afternoon (7), lawyer Mariana Chamelette says ...
- Methods of Poweron April 6, 2021 at 2:01 am
It can arise and destroy democracy wherever people lack the moral and institutional force to successfully ... much more to investigate their relationship to the broader history and nature of ...
via Google News and Bing News