Researchers say ‘benevolent bots’, otherwise known as software robots, that are designed to make articles on Wikipedia better often end up having online fights lasting years over changes in content.
Editing bots on Wikipedia undo vandalism, enforce bans, check spelling, create links and import content automatically, whereas other bots (which are non-editing) can mine data, identify data or identify copyright infringements. The team looked at how much disruption they caused on Wikipedia sites, seeing how they interacted on 13 different language editions over ten years (from 2001 to 2010). They found that bots interacted with one another, whether or not this was by design, which led to unpredictable consequences. The research paper, published in PLOS ONE, concludes that bots are more like humans than you might expect as they appear to behave differently in culturally distinct online environments. The paper says the findings are a warning to those using artificial intelligence for building autonomous vehicles, cyber security systems or for managing social media. It suggests that scientists may have to devote more attention to bots’ diverse ‘social life’ and their different cultures.
The research paper by the University of Oxford and the Alan Turing Institute in the UK explains that although the online world has become an ecosystem of bots, our knowledge of how they interact with each other is still rather poor. Although bots are automatons that do not have the capacity for emotions, bot to bot interactions are unpredictable and act in distinctive ways. It finds that German editions of Wikipedia had fewest conflicts between bots, with each undoing another’s edits 24 times, on average, over ten years. This shows relative efficiency, says the research paper, when compared with bots on the Portuguese Wikipedia edition, which undid another bot’s edits 185 times, on average, over ten years. Bots on English Wikipedia undid another bot’s work 105 times, on average, over ten years, three times the rate of human reverts, says the paper.
The findings show that even simple autonomous algorithms can produce complex interactions that result in unintended consequences – ‘sterile fights’ that may continue for years, or reach deadlock in some cases. The paper says while bots constitute a tiny proportion (0.1%) of Wikipedia editors, they stand behind a significant proportion of all edits. Although such conflicts represent a small proportion of the bots’ overall editorial activity, these findings are significant in highlighting their unpredictability and complexity. Smaller language editions, such as the Polish Wikipedia, have far more content created by bots than the large language editions, such as English Wikipedia.
Lead author Dr Milena Tsvetkova, from the Oxford Internet Institute, said: ‘We find that bots behave differently in different cultural environments and their conflicts are also very different to the ones between human editors. This has implications not only for how we design artificial agents but also for how we study them. We need more research into the sociology of bots.’
Even the same technology leads to different outcomes depending on the cultural environment. An automated vehicle will drive differently on a German autobahn to how it will through the Tuscan hills of Italy. Similarly, local online infrastructure that bots inhabit will have some bearing on how they behave and their performance
Dr Taha Yasseri from the Oxford Internet Institute
The paper was co-authored by the principal investigator of the EC-Horizon2020-funded project, HUMANE, Dr Taha Yasseri, also from the Oxford Internet Institute. He added: ‘The findings show that even the same technology leads to different outcomes depending on the cultural environment.An automated vehicle will drive differently on a German autobahn to how it will through the Tuscan hills of Italy. Similarly, the local online infrastructure that bots inhabit will have some bearing on how they behave and their performance. Bots are designed by humans from different countries so when they encounter one another, this can lead to online clashes. We see differences in the technology used in the different Wikipedia language editions and the different cultures of the communities of Wikipedia editors involved create complicated interactions. This complexity is a fundamental feature that needs to be considered in any conversation related to automation and artificial intelligence.’
Professor Luciano Floridi, also an author of the paper, remarked: ‘We tend to forget that coordination even among collaborative agents is often achieved only through frameworks of rules that facilitate the wanted outcomes. This infrastructural ethics or infra-ethics needs to be designed as much and as carefully as the agents that inhabit it.’
The research finds that the number of reverts is smaller for bots than for humans, but the bots’ behaviour is more varied and conflicts involving bots last longer and are triggered later. The average time between successive reverts for humans is 2 minutes, then 24 hours or one year, says the paper. The first bot to bot revert happened a month later, on average, but further reverts often continued for years. The paper suggests that humans use automatic tools that report live changes and can react more quickly, whereas bots systematically crawl over web articles and they can be restricted on the number of edits allowed. The fact that bots’ conflicts are longstanding also flags that humans are failing to spot the problems early enough, suggests the paper.
Receive an email update when we add a new SOFTWARE ROBOTS article.
The Latest on: Software robots
via Google News
The Latest on: Software robots
- Ava Robotics Powers Johnson Controls’ New Tyco Security Roboton October 11, 2021 at 11:59 am
The fully autonomous security robot includes sensors, touchscreen and integrates two Tyco Illustra cameras to streamline security operations and increase operational efficiency, creating unprecedented ...
- Leaf-Cutting Autonomous Robot Can Operate 24/7, Promises Over 85 Percent Accuracyon October 11, 2021 at 3:38 am
Dutch company Priva aims to revolutionize horticulture with this ultimate tomato de-leafing machine. Its new creation, Kompano, is touted as the first robot on the market to safely and independently ...
- UAV Software Market Insights with Upcoming Trends, Opportunities and Forecast to 2028 | Airware, 3D Robotics, Lockheed Martin, General Atomicson October 10, 2021 at 11:59 pm
The study report offers a complete analysis of the business models key strategies and respective market shares of most prominent players in this landscape this UAV Software market report gives a deep ...
- This New Virtual Obstacle Course Is Teaching Robots How To Walkon October 10, 2021 at 11:46 am
Advertisement Humans, beware! A robot army is in training and won’t be long till they take over the world According to an initial report from Wired, a virtual army of 4,000 dog-like robots was used to ...
- Red Thunder roboton October 10, 2021 at 3:53 am
A remote-controlled robot, designed, created, programmed and tested by past members of the Laingsburg High School robotics team, is now being used by a Lansing-based virtual reality development ...
- These virtual obstacle courses help real robots learn to walkon October 10, 2021 at 3:34 am
As a result, the researchers say they were able to train the robots in less than one-hundredth the time that’s normally required. Using the specialized chips also presented challenges. Nvidia’s chips ...
- How Robotics is Benefitting the Logistics Sectoron October 6, 2021 at 1:56 am
How Robotics is Benefitting the Logistics Sector - The logistics sector is using robotics because it can help to improve the operations within the warehouse and reduces ...
- UiPath Toughens Software Robots As Core Platform Widenson October 5, 2021 at 4:29 pm
If anything, software robots are more like humans than hardware robots; we can say this because they are capable of executing workplace tasks that we humans are all used to performing when sat in the ...
- Intelligent automation brings robots and clothing design to the same chic partyon October 5, 2021 at 5:12 am
Robots might still sound futuristic to some, but automation technologies are already being widely used in many industries comprising from manufacturing, ...
via Bing News