It’s difficult to express how important and worthwhile analysis this is.
Chris Tolles points us to what I have to say is an absolute must read piece by Jim Manzi (who I haven’t always agreed with in the past), exploring the biggest challenge the US faces in going forward. It’s difficult to express how important and worthwhile analysis this is. I don’t agree with everything, but it frames the issues in ways that are incredibly helpful. There’s very little I disagree with in the first half, which highlights the basic struggle that the US faces in really clear terms: innovation is necessary for economic growth, and less government interference is key for the type of innovation we need. However, with such innovation comes social upheaval and disruption that creates a different set of problems that could be just as bad for the US:
First is the inherent conflict between the creative destruction involved in free-market capitalism and the innate human propensity to avoid risk and change. Second is ever-increasing international competition. And third is the growing disparity in behavioral norms and social conditions between the upper and lower income strata of American society.
These realities combine to form a daunting problem. And the task of resolving it turns out not, by and large, to be a matter of foreign policy. Rather, it compels us to consider how we balance economic dynamism and growth against the unity and stability of our society. After all, we must have continuous, rapid technological and business-model innovation to grow our economy fast enough to avoid losing power to those who do not share America’s values — and this innovation requires increasingly deregulated markets and fewer restrictions on behavior. But such deregulation would cause significant displacement and disruption that could seriously undermine America’s social cohesion — which is not only essential to a decent and just society, but also to producing the kind of skilled and responsible citizens that free markets ultimately require. Moreover, preserving the integrity of our social fabric by minimizing the divisions that can rend society often requires government policies — to reduce inequality or ensure access to jobs, education, housing, or health care — that can in turn undercut growth and prosperity. Neither innovation nor cohesion can do without the other, but neither, it seems, can avoid undermining the other.
There’s a lot in the piece that I wanted to quote, but you should just go read the whole thing yourself. Manzi basically points out the difficulty in pulling any of the levers: if you increase the pace of innovation, you also increase social upheaval at the lower end of the pyramid. But if you work to protect social upheaval, you decrease the pace of innovation, and in a global economy, that can actually lead to another set of problems that, in turn, also could result in serious problems for the economy.
It’s a really sobering picture that is inherently non-partisan, and highlights how the views and plans of both major political parties, when implemented by people who don’t understand these countervailing forces, is likely to make the overall situation worse, not better.
The Latest on: Innovation and social upheaval
via Google News
The Latest on: Innovation and social upheaval
- Technology & Innovation Roundup: Brothers create animation app with millions of userson August 1, 2022 at 3:06 am
It was apparent decades ago, when the brothers would record self-made shows on an old camcorder before camera phones existed. Marcos would use PowerPoint to animate the openings of the makeshift ...
- Tidal wave of social disruption lies ahead, warns CSIROon July 26, 2022 at 6:30 am
Resource scarcity, drug-resistant superbugs, disrupted international trade, an ageing population and increasingly unstable climate feature in the megatrends identified by the CSIRO to dictate how ...
- Impact Investing Unlocked: Inside The White-Hot Equity Crowdfunding Revolutionon July 25, 2022 at 4:50 am
Extremely political, social and market volatility has left ... companies and new investors to the ECF space, has driven innovation and has given well-deserved capital to companies changing the ...
- CMOs to Watch: Marketing chiefs that Visa, Netflix, and others recently tapped to stoke demand, drive innovation, and push into new areason July 25, 2022 at 4:00 am
All eyes are on these new or first-time chief marketing officers at Netflix, Taco Bell, and others tackling the biggest challenges in marketing.
- Financial innovation driving green-energy innovationon July 19, 2022 at 8:11 am
Finding solutions for Africa’s transition to a more sustainable energy mix will require significant innovation in the area of green technology. But what is sometimes overlooked is that a transition to ...
- Can Innovation Save Us?on July 12, 2022 at 5:00 pm
During a summer that’s been marred by political upheaval and horrific violence ... journalists—to wonder about the role of innovation in solving social problems. In the wake of the murder ...
- RIGGED Wins Best Short Documentary at the Septimius Awardson July 6, 2022 at 8:53 am
RIGGED builds on the historical premise that growing economic imbalance ultimately leads to social unrest, political upheaval ... critical thought, and innovation — i.e., the elements for ...
- Governance and Development in the COVID-19 Eraon July 4, 2022 at 5:00 pm
As aptly captured by Stanley Johny, pandemics have triggered the collapse of empires, weakened pre-eminent powers and institutions, created social upheaval and brought down wars. Walter Scheidel ...
via Bing News