Seeing a child steal a toy from a fellow playmate. Watching a stranger cut in line at the grocery store. When we witness something unjust, our emotions often shape our behavior both toward the person wronged and the wrongdoer.
But why we help the victim in some cases or punish the transgressor in others isn’t that simple, according to researchers at the University of Wisconsin–Madison. Published in the journal PLoS ONE, a new set of studies suggests that compassion — and intentionally cultivating it through training — may lead us to do more to help the wronged than to punish the wrongdoer. Researchers found compassion may also impact the extent to which people punish the transgressor.
Understanding what motivates people to be altruistic can not only inform our own behaviors, it may also play a role in creating more just societal institutions, including the legal and penal systems. It can also help researchers develop better interventions to cultivate compassion.
“Any action — helping or punishing — can arise from compassion, which involves at least two components: a ‘feeling’ component of empathic concern and caring for the suffering of another; and a cognitive, motivational component of wanting to alleviate that suffering,” says lead researcher Helen Weng, a former graduate student at the UW–Madison Center for Investigating Healthy Minds at the Waisman Center, and current postdoctoral scholar at the University of California, San Francisco. “It may seem counterintuitive that punishment behavior can arise from compassion, but if the goal is to alleviate suffering of others, this may include providing negative feedback to the wrongdoer so that they change their behavior in the future.”
These findings build upon previous work by Weng and others, which demonstrates that as little as two weeks of compassion training can result in measurable changes in the brain. These previous studies gathered fMRI imaging and measured altruistic behavior in research subjects to reach these conclusions, but did not fully separate helping and punishing behavior to learn which is most related to compassion.
To answer this question, the investigators tested whether compassion was related to helping or punishment in two studies where participants played the “Helping Game” or “Punishment Game,” using real money they could keep at the end of the game.
In both games, participants watched through online interactions as one player with more funds chose to split an unfair amount of money with another player with no funds. In the Helping Game, the third-party observers could choose to do nothing or give some of their own funds to “help” the victim. In the Punishment Game, the third-party observers could choose to do nothing or “punish” the transgressor by spending their own funds to take money away from the wrongdoer.
Understanding what motivates people to be altruistic can not only inform our own behaviors, it may also play a role in creating more just societal institutions, including the legal and penal systems.
In one study examining 260 people who had no training in compassion, the team explored whether high self-reported empathic concern — the feeling component of compassion where one reports caring for those who are suffering — was associated with helping victims, punishing transgressors, or both.
“People with higher empathic concern were more likely to help the victim than punish the transgressor,” Weng says. “But, interestingly, within the group of people who decided to punish the transgressor, those with more empathic concern decided to punish less.”
The Latest on: Compassionate approach
via Google News
The Latest on: Compassionate approach
- Scandals reveal Cuomo known by New Yorkers to wider nationon March 5, 2021 at 10:02 pm
New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo pauses as he marks his ballot, at the Presbyterian Church of Mount Kisco, in Mt. Kisco, N.Y. New Yorks attorney general has promised a thorough investigation of allegations ...
- In Memoriam: David Cope, a brilliant intellect and devoted, compassionate teacheron March 5, 2021 at 2:08 pm
A brilliant intellect and devoted, compassionate teacher, Harvard Law School Lecturer on Law David Cope, who taught at Harvard Law School for more than 20 years, died Jan. 26, 2021.
- Learning services coordinator embodies inclusivity and compassionon March 5, 2021 at 8:57 am
Dal Sohal has received a Staff Achievement Award in the area of Diversity and Inclusion for demonstrating a compassionate, curious, and dedicated approach to advancing equity and inclusion at SFU.
- Zohar Yakobson - Acting with compassionon March 4, 2021 at 10:54 pm
Despite her unbridled professional success, some 10 years ago Yakobson was struck by personal tragedy, as her daughter Tal, was diagnosed with a rare cancer and passed away.
- Davis Law Firm Has The Compassionate and Experienced Family Law and Bankruptcy Lawyers That Families Need in Kingston, TNon March 2, 2021 at 12:21 pm
Davis Law Firm has attorneys who bring a level of compassion and knowledge to all of their clients’ cases. Over the years, their legal team ...
- Numinus and Syreon Provide Psilocybin Compassionate Access Trial Updateon March 2, 2021 at 7:10 am
Significant progress made as Numinus-sponsored PRIME study on psilocybin-assisted psychotherapy for opioid, stimulant and/or alcohol use ...
- Covid 19: 'Where is our compassion?' Managed isolation fee hike hits familieson March 1, 2021 at 5:43 pm
A government announcement that the cost for managed isolation will increase this month has angered those waiting for a place.
- Philly Surgeon Delivers COVID Tests, Vaccines and Compassionate Care to the Black Communityon February 25, 2021 at 8:02 am
Dr. Ala Stanford took to the streets to eliminate the "barrier on top of barrier" that prevented her people from getting the help they deserved ...
- Emory University’s Compassion Center Announces Plans for Global 21-Day Compassion Challenge That Begins March 6, 2021on February 25, 2021 at 6:36 am
Emory University’s Compassion Center, with the support of His Holiness The Dalai Lama, will kick off a 21-Day Compassion Challenge March 6, 2021.
- The Compassionate Corporate Warrior’s Journeyon February 24, 2021 at 4:00 pm
I had a neighbor who’d scored a big job at an ascendant tech company. This company had captured my admiration for its underdog mentality, constant innovation, and willingness to publicly declare when ...
via Bing News