The Internet is routinely described as borderless, and that is often how it feels. Tweet a photo or post a comment, and it is instantly viewable in nearly every country in the world. But a global Internet unbounded by territorial limits is pure fantasy.
Down where the cables lie and the servers spin, territory still matters.
Take user data. While 90 percent of the Internet’s users are outside the United States, the web is dominated by American firms. As a result, a great deal of non-American data is held on American servers. This was tolerable when trust in the United States was high. But after Edward J. Snowden peeled back the curtain on the National Security Agency’s Internet surveillance efforts, that trust withered.
In response, other nations are increasingly exercising their territorial control over the Internet, often in ways that mimic America’s worst practices.
Earlier this month, the British Home Secretary introduced a bill known as the Snoopers’ Charter that would broadly expand the government’s ability to collect user data — from authorizing the police to hack into phones and computers, to mandating that Internet companies decrypt encrypted communications. The bill goes too far and privacy advocates are right to oppose it.
But governments do have legitimate reasons to seek user data beyond their territorial reach, and privacy advocates ignore that need at their peril.
Ask a police officer anywhere outside of the United States and he’ll tell you that evidence for routine crimes — murder, theft, burglary — is very often stored in the cloud, typically in another jurisdiction. Last year alone, British law enforcement agents made nearly 54,000 requests for data from just five American firms: Facebook, Google, Microsoft, Twitter and Yahoo.
These requests often go nowhere because America’s 1986 Electronic Communications Privacy Act only allows technology firms to release American-held data in response to orders from an American judge. So if a British cop is investigating a murder in London, and he has good reason to believe that Google or Facebook has evidence about the crime, he must satisfy an American judge using an American constitutional standard to obtain the evidence. This cross-border process is notoriously slow. Requests take an average of 10 months — an eon in a criminal investigation — and many languish for years.
Exasperation with this process was a key motivation behind the Snoopers’ Charter, and Britain is hardly alone.
Because American law has made it nearly impossible to obtain digital evidence through legitimate channels, foreign police are turning to illegitimate ones. I recently attended a conference for purveyors of surveillance software — an event unofficially known as the “Wiretappers’ Ball.” I asked one vendor if he was aware of law enforcement’s frustrations with American tech firms. The salesman grinned and told me that police departments now buy his malware precisely because they’re tired of waiting for evidence through established diplomatic channels. This is alarming: Making it harder for the police to get criminal evidence lawfully may actually incentivize them to seek that data by snooping.
Read more: Dark Clouds Over the Internet
The Latest on: Dark Clouds Over the Internet
via Google News
The Latest on: Dark Clouds Over the Internet
- Parler goes dark after Amazon pulls hosting amid concerns over violent postson January 13, 2021 at 3:29 pm
Tech companies, including Apple and Google, are distancing themselves from Parler in the wake of mob violence on Capitol Hill.
- Ark. Gov. Asa Hutchinson calls for unity over the election and Covid-19 in State of the State Addresson January 12, 2021 at 2:20 pm
He urged Arkansas lawmakers to come together on issues about COVID-19, hate crime legislation and teacher pay.
- Parler sues Amazon after pro-Trump site goes darkon January 11, 2021 at 3:53 pm
Social media site Parler was effectively taken off the Internet when Amazon, Apple and Google all pulled technical support.
- Social media platform Parler goes dark after Amazon cloud suspensionon January 11, 2021 at 12:14 pm
Social media platform Parler is down following Amazon Web Services' decision to suspend Parler from its cloud hosting service after Wednesday's U.S. Capitol riot.
- Alibaba's Bottoming Despite Odds, Baidu's Dog Days Are Overon January 11, 2021 at 12:12 pm
The outperformance came despite the dark cloud of investment bans on Alibaba and Tencent, as well as usage prohibition of certain Chinese apps in the U.S., including Alipay and WeChat Pay. The level ...
- Parler Goes Dark After Being Dropped by Apple, Google and Amazonon January 11, 2021 at 9:24 am
Parler has been removed from Apple's App Store, following a move by Google to ban the social networking app from its Google Play store.
- Amazon's decision to sever ties with Parler might not kill the controversial social media platformon January 10, 2021 at 9:21 am
Amazon will kick Parler off its servers in the early hours of Monday morning, likely forcing the social network to temporarily go down.
- Managing Spend Under The Dark Cloud Of Shadow ITon January 5, 2021 at 4:00 am
Com Solutions discusses the evolving needs and challenges of organizations managing IT spend and usage among employees working from home.
- Yearender 2020: Amid the dark clouds of pandemic, IPL was just the silver lining sports fans neededon December 29, 2020 at 5:20 am
He promised one and all that the IPL would be the silver lining in the dark clouds that had gathered around ... and Virat Kohli back on the ground after a gap of over six months was no less ...
- Rugby-Concussion case casts dark cloud over the sporton December 17, 2020 at 7:20 pm
Their points difference triumph over France, followed by victory over the same team via a sudden-death extra-time penalty in the Autumn Nations Cup final cemented their position as Europe's ...
via Bing News