Facial recognition software, which American military and intelligence agencies used for years in Iraq and Afghanistan to identify potential terrorists, is being eagerly adopted by dozens of police departments around the country to pursue drug dealers, prostitutes and other conventional criminal suspects. But because it is being used with few guidelines and with little oversight or public disclosure, it is raising questions of privacy and concerns about potential misuse.
Law enforcement officers say the technology is much faster than fingerprinting at identifying suspects, although it is unclear how much it is helping the police make arrests.
When Aaron Harvey was stopped by the police here in 2013 while driving near his grandmother’s house, an officer not only searched his car, he said, but also took his photograph and ran it through the software to try to confirm his identity and determine whether he had a criminal record.
Eric Hanson, a retired firefighter, had a similar experience last summer. Stopped by the police after a dispute with a man he said was a prowler, he was ordered to sit on a curb, he said, while officers took his photo with an iPad and ran it through the same facial recognition software. The officers also used a cotton swab to collect a DNA sample from the inside of his cheek.
Neither man was arrested. Neither had consented to being photographed. Both said officers had told them that they were using facial recognition technology.
“I was thinking, ‘Why are you taking pictures of me, doing this to me?’ ” said Mr. Hanson, 58, who has no criminal record. “I felt like my identity was being stolen. I’m a straight-up, no lie, cheat or steal guy, and I get treated like a criminal.”
Lt. Scott Wahl, a spokesman for the 1,900-member San Diego Police Department, said the department does not require police officers to file a report when they use the facial recognition technology but do not make an arrest. The department has no record of the stops involving Mr. Hanson and Mr. Harvey, and Lieutenant Wahl said that he did not know about the incidents but that they could have happened.
“It is a test product for the region that we’ve allowed officers to use,” he said of facial recognition software and the hand-held devices the police use to take pictures. “We don’t even know how many are out there” in the region.
He said that until June 19, his department did not have a written policy regulating facial recognition software and only recently began training officers on its lawful use. Before then, he said, there were interim regional guidelines and training available.
County documents show that over 33 days in January and February, 26 San Diego law enforcement agencies used the software to try to identify people on more than 20,600 occasions — although officers found a match to criminal records only about 25 percent of the time.
Lieutenant Wahl said the department was not aware of any complaints about the software or about the policy of collecting DNA samples that Mr. Hanson and others have described.
The department uses the technology judiciously, Lieutenant Wahl said. “We don’t just drive around taking people’s picture and start swabbing them,” he said.
Others say misuse is common.
The Latest on: Facial Recognition Software
via Google News
The Latest on: Facial Recognition Software
- Fix the use of DNA data and facial recognition software, not ban it | COMMENTARYon June 10, 2021 at 2:08 pm
The use of facial recognition technology needs fixing. There’s no doubt about. Let’s fix it rather than throw it out the door.
- RCMP broke the law with Clearview AI facial recognition software: watchdogon June 10, 2021 at 12:13 pm
Privacy Commissioner Daniel Therrien says there were serious failings by the RCMP to ensure compliance with the Privacy Act before it gathered information from Clearview AI.
- Canada privacy regulator says federal police broke laws using facial recognition softwareon June 10, 2021 at 9:02 am
The Canadian federal police force broke the law when they used facial recognition software, the country's top privacy regulator found in a report released on Thursday. The Royal Canadian Mounted ...
- Canada police broke law with facial recognition software, regulator findson June 10, 2021 at 8:43 am
The Canadian federal police force broke the law when it used controversial facial recognition software, the country's top privacy regulator found in a report released on Thursday. The Royal Canadian ...
- Investors call for ethical approach to facial recognition technologyon June 7, 2021 at 4:08 pm
A group of 50 investors managing more than $4.5 trillion in assets is calling on companies involved in the development and use of facial recognition technology, such as Amazon and Facebook, to do so ...
- Ban facial recognition software in Baltimore and beyond | READER COMMENTARYon June 7, 2021 at 2:01 pm
Facial recognition technology is too prone, too much an invasion of privacy and too likely to misidentify Black individuals for any city to allow its routine use.
- King County ban on police use of facial recognition software spotlights local movements across USon June 4, 2021 at 5:15 am
As federal legislation on law enforcement's use of facial recognition software stalls, dozens of cities and counties are taking measures into their own hands.
- EU Privacy Groups File Complaint, Assert Clearview AI Facial Recognition Software Violates Data Protection Lawson June 3, 2021 at 9:00 am
Clearview AI's controversial facial recognition software is facing legal complaints in the EU challenging the troubled company on the basis of violating data protection laws by 'scraping' websites.” ...
- King County Becomes 1st In US To Ban Facial Recognition Softwareon June 2, 2021 at 11:46 am
While a few cities have enacted such bans, King County is the first county to bar its agencies from using facial recognition software.
- Washington county becomes first in U.S. to ban facial recognition softwareon June 2, 2021 at 11:18 am
A county in Washington state has become the first in the country to ban the use of facial recognition software by government agencies, including the sheriff’s department.
via Bing News