“What disturbs me on the other side is I don’t understand what the decision for you or against you when I write it is going to do to all kinds of other technologies”
Chaitanya (“Chet”) Kanojia is holding his breath over a US Supreme Court ruling on his disruptive technology that he says will revolutionize broadcasting and cheer the public by lowering cost of services. For entirely different reasons, so are major broadcasters (ABC, CBS, NBC, Fox etc): they see the technology gambit leading to copyright infringement, a massive loss of revenue, and the death of broadcasting as we know it.
On Tuesday, the country’s apex court did not give a whiff of which way it would go — itself torn between the two sides as it began hearing the landmark case that has transfixed most people plugged into broadcast, which is pretty much everyone.
At the heart of this profound case is whether Aereo, the nifty New York start-up founded by the Bhopal-born Indian-American, has the right to pick up broadcast signals off the air with its breakthrough technology — an antenna the size of a postage stamp — that it will giving subscribers for a fraction of the cost they pay for cable services. Aereo’s thumb-print sized device can capture TV signals from the airwaves and direct them to your laptop, tablet, or smartphone for as little as $ 8 compared to the up to $80 plus that people currently pay for cable services.
“Your technological model is based solely on circumventing legal prohibitions that you don’t want to comply with,” Chief Justice John Roberts observed sharply at the hearing, seemingly reflecting the argument of the powerful plaintiffs that mooching TV signals off the air amounts to theft of content and copyright violation. Aereo says its technology does nothing more than what subscribers have been able to do lawfully since the time the old-fashioned rabbit ear antenna — watch free broadcast if you are able to catch signals over public airways.
“There’s no content being provided. There’s (only) equipment that’s being provided,” Aereo’s lawyers maintained before the court in Tuesday in a case that attracted nationwide attention.
Times have changed, technology has become niftier, and new trends have caught on — and the Supreme Court appeared to struggle with evolving a new consensus of how to protect traditional and time-tested business models while not putting a crimp on innovation. “What disturbs me on the other side is I don’t understand what the decision for you or against you when I write it is going to do to all kinds of other technologies,” Justice Stephen Breyer agonized.
The Latest on: Disruptive technology
[google_news title=”” keyword=”Disruptive technology” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
via Google News
The Latest on: Disruptive technology
- Progress could be slowing down in science and technology, finds studyon January 9, 2023 at 5:32 am
Big jumps forward in science often come in the form of surprising discoveries that break with preceding work – but this kind of disruptive activity is declining over time. That is according to a new ...
- Disruptive innovation's like a party. It's always happening elsewhereon January 9, 2023 at 2:03 am
We see it in tech up close and personal: news keeps coming thick and fast from medicine, material science, energy, cosmology, palaeontology, environmental sciences, you name it. The speed of change is ...
- Papers and patents are becoming less disruptiveon January 7, 2023 at 5:19 pm
have set out to determine whether this decline holds for science and technology in general. In a study published this week in Nature they analyse 45m papers and 3.9m patents published and filed ...
- Science isn't as disruptive as it used to be. Now we need to understand whyon January 5, 2023 at 5:55 am
According to a study by Russell Funk, a sociologist at the University of Minnesota in Minneapolis, data suggests that the level of "disruptiveness" in scientific research ...
- People will ‘harness’ AI for work amid debate it could be a ‘disruptive technology’on January 4, 2023 at 11:15 pm
KPMG Chief Economist Doctor Brendan Rynne says people are trying to “harness” artificial intelligence for work amid discussions it is a “disruptive technology”. “What we’re seeing is ...
- Meta Materials: Disruptive Technology Needs Customerson December 30, 2022 at 6:26 am
Also about this new disruptive technology, MMAT is moving on the market and has begun important relationships to set up the development and marketing of the product. ADAS is a highly technological ...
- Disruptive technologies in 2022on December 28, 2022 at 4:00 pm
For the most part, technology has proven useful in human history. In the past, its disruptive effects were largely the stuff of science fiction novels and movies. Fast forward to the 21 st century, ...
- Eve Urban Air Mobility: The Price Of Disruptive Technologyon December 28, 2022 at 8:26 am
One risk, I am seeing with coverage of Urban Air Mobility or eVTOL names is that the disruptive technology is often equated to value creation while this is not the case. In my previous report ...
- Top-Read Disruptive Technology Stories of 2022on December 26, 2022 at 2:06 pm
ARK Invest and its suite of actively managed ETFs focus on those firms, as do the top three most-read disruptive technology stories focused on their research and investment strategy. The top ...
via Bing News