The results from a set of international studies may now revolutionise fishing regulations.
Many popular measures to combat overfishing help conserve mostly small juvenile fish. The results from a set of international studies may now revolutionise fishing regulations.
Before it lands on our plate, any wild fish should spawn at least once. This is a basic principle in fishery management. Accordingly, professional fishers and recreational anglers have to release any fish they catch that is smaller than the minimum size stipulated in many fisheries regulations; only the big ones they are allowed to retain. However, this policy does not take into account the extraordinary ecological importance of large spawners, as was pointed out in several recent studies led by Dr Robert Arlinghaus, Professor for Integrative Fisheries Management, of the Leibniz-Institute of Freshwater Ecology and Inland Fisheries (IGB) and the Humboldt-University of Berlin. The unintended consequences are lower harvest in terms of number of fish and smaller fish within the stock. Scientists from the Australia, Germany and the United States now propose that it might be better to implement harvest slots as an alternative to the popular minimum size regulation in recreational fisheries. These ‘harvest windows’ would protect both the young offspring and the experienced heavyweights, and at the same time conserve the big fish that are rather popular with hobby anglers.
“I’m glad that I’m not fat (…) I’m glad that I’m such a thin herring, because to be thin means to be free“. These controversial lyrics from a song by the German singer Marius Müller-Westernhagen describe – albeit unintentionally – the dilemma of many existing fishing regulations. Because up to this point, many measures taken against overfishing aim at protecting the small fish, the ones that reach sexual maturity for the first time. Initially, the underlying idea sounds plausible: juveniles are to be conserved until they are big enough to proliferate at least once. After the reproduction process is completed, they can easily fall victim to a fishhook or end up in a fishing-net. But this only works as long as the existing fish stock keeps producing enough offspring.
Old fisheries biological models were not encompassing of reproduction
The traditional fisheries biological models from the 1940s and 1950s claimed that the fishing yield was to be best when the existing fish stock consists mainly of small and young fish that grow quickly. “While this is still the case, the calculations of that time did not take into account the reproduction ability of fishes of different sizes and ages. Many of the traditional mathematic models only considered the growth and mortality rate of fish stocks, while the reproduction factor was considered unlimited or unpredictable,” explains Professor Robert Arlinghaus, the senior author of the set of new studies, from the IGB in Berlin. “They simply could not fathom that the effects of fishing would decimate the spawning stock so strongly that there would be an offspring shortage.”
Big fish have an extraordinary ecological and economic function
One thing holds true for many fish species: When the quantity of parental fish is low due to overfishing or environmental impacts on habitats, a greater quantity of eggs usually leads to a higher number of juvenile fish. In this regard, the productive large female fish play a fundamental role in repopulation. If the mega spawners are systematically taken out, this favours more inexperienced, smaller females whose reproductive output is lower. But there are also reasons in our economy and our society that speak in favour of protecting the “Big Old Fat Females”. “Anglers love photos with big fish in remembrance of the special catch, and professional fishers get higher market prices for some fish species, such as cod, if the fish is bigger,” says fisheries scientist Arlinghaus. Unfortunately, big fish are extremely rare in harvested fish stocks.
Big is sexy
Even fin-wearing underwater residents prefer large lovers in their world. That is hardly surprising. Several recent studies, including work in the laboratory of Prof. Arlinghaus, have shown that larger fish not only produce disproportionately more eggs, but also larger eggs, which in turn results in offspring that is more resistant. In contrast to many mammals and to us humans, fish grow all their life and invest in reproduction well into old age. “From an ecological point of view it is better if a fish population consists of different size and age classes. This diversity in age pays off. Oftentimes, fish of various sizes and ages reproduce at different times,” explains Arlinghaus. “If events in the environment destroy the eggs of a specific timeframe, the population can still guarantee the offspring and thus contribute to more stable stocks.” Also, the big and the small onesmay take with you any fish that fits within the slot,” explains Arlinghaus. Anything smaller or bigger than the harvest window must be returned to the water and is allowed to stay alive. “We have shown in computer simulations that the use of the harvest slots m, the old and the young ones, they all have different places to stay, different routes to migrate, and different nutritional plans. If you strongly exploit the population by catching and removing a vast amount of fish, consequently creating a fish stock that mainly consists of juvenile and first maturing fish, this will negatively affect not only the reproductive performance of the stock, but also the entire food web and ecosystem.
The Latest on: Overfishing
via Google News
The Latest on: Overfishing
- China Tries To Reel In Its Overfishing Habiton August 5, 2022 at 3:54 am
Global fish stocks face a crisis, with nearly all classified as either fully exploited, overexploited or significantly depleted . China is the la ...
- Snow crab thrives thanks to sustainable managementon August 5, 2022 at 2:32 am
Snow crab on the coast of Newfoundland and Labrador has recovered thanks to sustainable management measures, finding new markets since the Covid pandemic.
- With Ecosystem-Based Reference Points in Place, Atlantic Menhaden Assessment Again Shows Fishery Healthy, Sustainable, Not Overfishedon August 3, 2022 at 7:08 pm
Atlantic menhaden are not overfished and overfishing is not occurring, according to the latest ASMFC stock assessment using ecological reference points. In the past, single-species stock assessments ...
- Can Coral Reefs Escape to the Deep?on August 3, 2022 at 12:00 pm
Magazine is an editorially independent, non-profit newsroom producing open-access science journalism and scientific fact-checking for the global public.
- WTO reaches deal to curb overfishing and subsidies, with the target of fisheries sustainabilityon August 2, 2022 at 5:00 pm
After two decades of discussions, the World Trade Organization, WTO, finally reached a deal aimed at curbing overfishing which was hailed by conservation groups as a major turning point ...
- Holiday warning as shark attack capitals revealed with 15ft beasts spotted prowling in the Mediterraneanon July 31, 2022 at 2:41 am
Overfishing and a return in tourist numbers after two years of the Covid pandemic could see sharks entering waters ever closer to humans in several holiday hotspots. It comes after the world's ...
- Senegal's underwater museum tackles overfishingon July 11, 2022 at 11:24 am
Made from ecological concrete, they're designed to restore marine life in an area that's suffered from overfishing. The pieces, donated by artists at the end of last year, are also intended to raise ...
- After many years, New England cod seems to be rebounding from overfishingon July 7, 2022 at 10:08 pm
Some areas are still closed because regulators believe cod never rebounded from overfishing. But new research from Kevin Stokesbury, a professor of fishery science at the University of ...
via Bing News