Majority wants both punishment for tax evaders and things to go fine for themselves
In most modern states, central institutions are funded by public taxation. This means, however, that tax evaders must also be punished. Once such a system has been established, it is also good for the community: it makes co-existence easier and it helps maintain common standards. However, such advantageous institutions do not come about by themselves. The community must first agree that such a common punishment authority makes sense and decide what powers it should be given. Climate protection is a case in point, demonstrating that this cannot always be achieved. But how can a community agree on sensible institutions and self-limitations?
The Max Planck researchers allowed participants in a modified public goods game to decide whether to pay taxes towards a policing institution with their starting capital. They were additionally able to pay money into a common pot. The total paid in was then tripled and paid out to all participants. If taxes had been paid beforehand, free riders who did not contribute to the group pot were punished by the police. In the absence of taxation, however, there would be no police and the group would run the risk that no-one would pay into the common pot.
Police punishment of both free riders and tax evaders quickly established cooperative behaviour in the experiment. If, however, tax evaders were not punished, the opposite happened and the participants avoided paying taxes. Without policing, there was no longer any incentive to pay into the group pot, so reducing the profits for the group members. Ultimately, each individual thus benefits if tax evaders are punished.
But can participants foresee this development? To find out, the scientists gave the participants a choice: they were now able to choose individually whether they joined a group in which the police also punish tax evaders. Alternatively, they could choose a group in which only those participants who did not pay into the common pot were penalised. Faced with this choice, the majority preferred a community without punishment for tax evaders – with the result that virtually no taxes were paid and, subsequently, that contributions to the group pot also fell.
In a second experimental scenario, the players were instead able to decide by democratic vote whether, for all subsequent rounds, the police should be authorised to punish tax evaders as well as free riders or only free riders. In this case, the players clearly voted for institutions in which tax evaders were also punished. “People are often prepared to impose rules on themselves, but only if they know that these rules apply to everyone,” summarises Christian Hilbe, the lead author of the study. A majority decision ensures that all participants are equally affected by the outcome of the vote. This makes it easier to introduce rules and institutions which, while demanding individual sacrifice, are best for the group.
The Latest on: Democracy
via Google News
The Latest on: Democracy
- Hong Kong Court Adjourns Hearing for Democracy Activists Charged With Subversionon March 3, 2021 at 2:32 pm
Pro-democracy activist Benny Tai flashes thumbs up as he walks to a prison van to head to court, over the national security law charge, in the early morning, in Hong Kong, China March 2, 2021. REUTERS ...
- Trump's final year in office was the worst for global democracy in a decade and a half, watchdog sayson March 3, 2021 at 12:54 pm
Less than 20% of the world's population "now lives in a Free country," a new report on global democracy said.
- WorldView: U.K. hospitals still strained; Hong Kong charges pro-democracy activistson March 3, 2021 at 10:39 am
Despite a successful vaccine rollout so far, ICUs in Britain are still bearing the brunt of the pandemic. Meanwhile, Hong Kong has charged over 40 pro-democracy activists for violating the national ...
- Myanmar's neighbours press junta for Suu Kyi's release, restoration of democracyon March 3, 2021 at 8:46 am
The calls from fellow members of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) came as Myanmar police again opened fire to disperse crowds after weeks of demonstrations against military rule.
- Orban’s Party Quits EU Lawmaker Group in Hungary Democracy Rowon March 3, 2021 at 7:27 am
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban pulled his ruling party out of the parliamentary caucus of the European Union’s largest political group as the bloc piles pressure on him over the erosion of ...
- Trump Is Gone, but Democracy Is in Troubleon March 3, 2021 at 6:17 am
I allowed myself to dream that the battered troops of democracy would regain their courage and go on the offensive. For a decade or more, authoritarian populists around the globe had won one upset ...
- Democracy is under siege in U.S. and around the world, new report sayson March 3, 2021 at 2:00 am
The past year was a terrible year for democracy — not only in the United States but around the world — according to a report released Wednesday by a leading advocate for political freedoms and human ...
- Iowa police find live pipe bomb at polling center: ‘Attempted violence against our democracy’on March 2, 2021 at 10:45 pm
Police in Ankeny, Iowa, disarmed a live pipe bomb found outside a community center being used as a polling place in local elections.
- Hong Kong democracy activists' bail hearing enters 3rd dayon March 2, 2021 at 5:44 pm
Bail proceedings for 47 Hong Kong democracy activists charged with conspiracy to commit subversion enter the third day on Wednesday, following marathon hearings that have gone on late into the night ...
- Hong Kong democracy activists headed to court for second dayon March 1, 2021 at 5:52 pm
A court hearing for 47 democracy activists charged under Hong Kong's national security law was set to resume Tuesday after a marathon session that was adjourned well past ...
via Bing News