GOTCHA Scheme Could Foil Growing Problem of Automated Brute Force Attacks
Carnegie Mellon University computer scientists have developed a new password system that incorporates inkblots to provide an extra measure of protection when, as so often occurs, lists of passwords get stolen from websites.
This new type of password, dubbed a GOTCHA (Generating panOptic Turing Tests to Tell Computers and Humans Apart), would be suitable for protecting high-value accounts, such as bank accounts, medical records and other sensitive information.
To create a GOTCHA, a user chooses a password and a computer then generates several random, multi-colored inkblots. The user describes each inkblot with a text phrase. These phrases are then stored in a random order along with the password. When the user returns to the site and signs in with the password, the inkblots are displayed again along with the list of descriptive phrases; the user then matches each phrase with the appropriate inkblot.
“These are puzzles that are easy for a human to solve, but hard for a computer to solve, even if it has the random bits used to generate the puzzle,” said Jeremiah Blocki, a Ph.D. student in computer science who developed GOTCHAs along with Manuel Blum, professor of computer science, and Anupam Datta, associate professor of computer science and electrical and computer engineering.
These puzzles would prove significant when security breaches of websites result in the loss of millions of user passwords – a common occurrence that has plagued such companies as LinkedIn, Sony and Gawker. These passwords are stored as cryptographic hash functions, in which passwords of any length are converted into strings of bits of uniform length. A thief can’t readily decipher these hashes, but can mount what’s called an automated offline dictionary attack. Computers today can evaluate as many as 250 million possible hash values every second, Blocki noted.
Given the continued popularity of easy passwords, such as “123456” or “password,” it’s not always difficult to crack these hashes. But even hard passwords are vulnerable to the latest brute force methods, Blocki said.
In the case of a GOTCHA, however, a computer program alone wouldn’t be enough to break into an account.
“To crack the user’s password offline, the adversary must simultaneously guess the user’s password and the answer to the corresponding puzzle,” Datta said. “A computer can’t do that alone. And if the computer must constantly interact with a human to solve the puzzle, it no longer can bring its brute force to bear to crack hashes.”
The researchers described GOTCHAs at the Association for Computing Machinery’s Workshop on Artificial Intelligence and Security in Berlin, Germany, Nov. 4.
Because the user’s descriptive phrases for inkblots are stored, users don’t have to memorize their descriptions, but have to be able to pick them out from a list. To see if people could do this reliably, the researchers performed a user study with 70 people hired through Mechanical Turk. First, each user was asked to describe 10 inkblots with creative titles, such as “evil clown” or “lady with poofy dress.” Ten days later, they were asked to match those titles with the inkblots. Of the 58 participants who participated in the second round of testing, one-third correctly matched all of the inkblots and more than two-thirds got half right.
Blocki said the design of the user study, including financial incentives that were too low, might account for the less-than-stellar performance. But he said there also are ways to make descriptions more memorable. One way would be to use more elaborate stories, such as “a happy guy on the ground protecting himself from ticklers.”
Go deeper with Bing News on:
- Let's crush these 4 retirement myths holding you backon February 23, 2021 at 3:05 am
Your retirement will likely be the biggest financial goal you'll face in your life. If all goes well, you may need to cover decades of living expenses from your savings.
- David Gardner: Preparing for a COVID tax yearon February 21, 2021 at 6:00 am
While 2020 was a year to forget for many, it was one filled with tax curveballs thrown by lawmakers to soften the financial impact of COVID-19.
- Hands-On: GreatFET Is An Embedded Tool That Does It Allon February 17, 2021 at 4:00 pm
But chances are you have the I2C address wrong, or you hooked up TX/RX or MISO/MOSI backwards, or myriad other common gotchas. At its simplest, GreatFET is designed to give you an interactive ...
- Ed Perkins on Travel: Road trip car rental gotchason February 15, 2021 at 9:18 pm
If you plan to rent your road trip car, however, be on the lookout for the several perennial gotchas the rental companies throw at you to extract a few more of your dollars than necessary.
- DDD official: Gotcha’s bikeshare expansion will benefit downtownon February 12, 2021 at 12:58 pm
Following a largely pandemic-triggered surge in ridership, Gotcha Baton Rouge will grow its local footprint in 2021—a move downtown officials believe will benefit the city’s central business district.
Go deeper with Google Headlines on:
Go deeper with Bing News on:
New password system
- Android gets scheduled Messages, new in-car UI & games, plus password safety checkson February 23, 2021 at 10:22 am
The new Android Auto features will be rolling out on Android 6 phones and above over the coming days, Google says. For Android 9 or more recent devices, Google’s Password Checkup system is being ...
- Google Shows Off 6 New Android Features That Everyone Getson February 23, 2021 at 9:00 am
Like they did at the end of December, Google spent this morning showing off another six new features that are coming to Android that everyone should get to use. Unlike a typical software update that ...
- Jealous Computers Releases New Strong Password Generatoron February 22, 2021 at 8:54 pm
Jealous Computers announced today that it has developed a strong password generator capable of creating passwords that would take 43 quattuordecillion years to break. (That’s 4.3 x 10 45 years, many ...
- On Computers: What's the word on best password manager?on February 20, 2021 at 11:06 pm
A reader asked me to name the best password manager. That’s tough. I’ve had bad luck with nearly all of them. I’ll never forget the time I lost the master password to a Dashlane account, waving ...
- Federal cybersecurity advisory offers new details on Oldsmar water supply cyberattackon February 19, 2021 at 6:06 pm
A federal cybersecurity advisory issued on Feb. 11 by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the ...