Economic modelling shows that the possible methane emissions caused by shrinking sea ice from just one area of the Arctic could come with a global price tag of 60 trillion dollars – the size of the world economy in 2012.
As the Arctic warms and sea ice melts at an unprecedented rate, hitting a record low last summer, the thawing of offshore ‘permafrost’ – frozen soil – in the region is releasing methane, a powerful greenhouse gas.
Scientists have previously warned that there are vast reservoirs of methane in the Arctic, hundreds of billions of tonnes of a gas many times worse than carbon dioxide for global warming – of which only a fraction needs releasing into the atmosphere to trigger possibly catastrophic climate change.
Now, researchers from Cambridge and Rotterdam have for the first time calculated the potential economic impact of a scenario some scientists consider increasingly likely: that the methane below the East Siberian Sea will be emitted, either steadily over the next 30 years or in one giant “burp”.
Writing in the journal Nature, the academics say that just this area’s methane alone – some 50 billion tonnes, or 50 gigatonnes – would have a mean global impact of 60 trillion dollars, an amount very similar to the size of the entire global economy last year. Current US national debt stands at a mere 16 trillion dollars in comparison.
The economic impact modelled was only for the methane existing on the East Siberian Arctic Shelf, and “the total price of Arctic change will be much higher,” they warn.
“Arctic science is a strategic asset for human economies because the region drives critical effects in our biophysical, political and economic systems,” write the academics, who say that world leaders will “miss the bigger picture” without factoring in Arctic methane projections – as neither the World Economic Forum or the International Monetary Fund currently recognise the economic danger of Arctic change.
The new results were achieved using PAGE09, the latest version of the PAGE integrated assessment model developed by Dr Chris Hope from Cambridge Judge Business School. PAGE09 is currently used by the US Environmental Protection Agency, and an earlier version was used for the UK Government’s Stern Review in 2006 – the major report on climate change economics on which Hope was a specialist advisor.
For the latest research, Hope worked with Gail Whiteman, Professor of Sustainability at Erasmus University, and Cambridge’s Peter Wadhams, Professor of Ocean Physics, who has been studying the disappearance of Arctic ice for 40 years.
The three academics, who co-authored today’s Nature Comment article, built the projections on previous fieldwork in the region by Dr Natalia Shakhova and colleagues from the International Arctic Research Center at the University of Alaska, described by Wadhams as “the only people with the geological knowledge to make estimates about methane emission in this area”.
The PAGE09 model was then employed to translate the extra methane emissions from the East Siberian Sea into global impacts by considering the huge range of environmental changes they might cause – from increasing global temperature and sea levels to consequent flooding, public health and extreme weather.
The model was run 10,000 times to assess the range of risks and provide robust results. The team insist that both the scientific predictions and economic modelling are far from worst-case scenarios, and that the figures represent the mean result from “the whole range of available science and economics”.
“That’s how the model works, how it was used for Stern and by the EPA, it’s the only way I’ll allow it to be used,” said Hope. “The model has to be run with broad ranges for the inputs, it’s not justifiable otherwise.”
“This is the first calculation of its kind that we know of,” he adds, “and we welcome anyone who wants to take this forward and build on it so we can have a discussion – but we don’t have long to discuss it! This is so big and if it happens it could happen fast; people need to wake up to the possible reality we face”.
“This is a warning to the world borne out of many decades of research on all our parts, including forty years of ice thinning measurements from UK submarines,” said Wadhams, “it is a considered statement with enormous implications”.
The Latest Bing News on:
Arctic methane release
- What can I do right now to reduce my environmental impact?on August 31, 2021 at 10:20 pm
Heat destroys permafrost, and when we choose to use heat free technology, we lower our energy consumption which helps to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and slows permafrost thaw.” To make copies of ...
- U.S. House Democrat proposes repeal of Arctic refuge oil leaseon August 31, 2021 at 1:55 pm
A Democratic lawmaker in the U.S. House of Representatives proposed infrastructure legislation on Tuesday that would end oil and gas leases in an Alaskan wildlife refuge while charging billions of ...
- Aircraft Mobilized To Measure Arctic Methane Emissionson August 25, 2021 at 2:55 pm
Aircraft and satellites are being used in a research campaign to measure methane being released as the permafrost thaws in regions north of the Arctic Circle. Methane is a greenhouse gas with much ...
- Facing the Climate Catastrophe: What We Do Now Matterson August 23, 2021 at 2:09 pm
The forecast on climate is stark, but the Biden administration can take meaningful action now to help avoid the worst effects of the crisis.
- The Present and (Possible) Future Arcticon August 19, 2021 at 5:05 pm
The Atlas of Disappearing Places” presents a realistic but not completely hopeless future for the Arctic. Sea ice first forms as tiny, cellophane-thin, star-shaped crystals that spread across the ...
- Thawing Permafrost Fuels Worries Over Global Warmingon August 16, 2021 at 5:00 pm
Arctic permafrost caps frozen material over mineral resources ... “We wanted to find out how much methane is released in a region and were looking for spatial patterns in gas emissions,” Kohnert said.
- Permafrost Thaw in Siberia Creates a Ticking ‘Methane Bomb’ of Greenhouse Gases, Scientists Warnon August 15, 2021 at 2:37 am
The CCAG report cautions that warming temperatures could be pushing the Arctic toward an “irreversible” tipping point, causing the release of methane and other gases, as well as crumbling ...
- How Much Worse Will Thawing Arctic Permafrost Make Climate Change?on August 11, 2021 at 8:19 am
Global warming is setting free carbon from life buried long ago in the Arctic’s frozen soils, but its impact on the climate crisis is unclear ...
- Ancient Arctic Craters Still Leaking Methane, Study Findson August 7, 2021 at 5:01 pm
which steadily release methane into the ocean. “The crater area was covered by a thick ice sheet during the last ice age, much as West Antarctica is today,” said lead author Karin Andreassen, a ...
- Siberian heatwave could spell doom for the planeton August 5, 2021 at 12:58 pm
One of the greatest dangers of melting permafrost is the release of astronomical ... stocks and the extent of possible methane emissions from the Arctic are still subject to considerable ...
The Latest Google Headlines on:
Arctic methane release
The Latest Bing News on:
- These entrepreneurs plan to spin waste into gold - and cut methane emissions in the processon September 3, 2021 at 5:18 am
But what if all that food waste came to a different end? Two Houston entrepreneurs are testing that proposition, shuttling food waste to a factory where a banana peel in Montrose and excess parsley in ...
- Guest opinion: Stopping methane pollution is vital to climate progresson September 3, 2021 at 5:00 am
On the drive north around Flathead Lake, you can see the destruction of the Boulder 2700 fire: 31 “structures,” including 14 homes, some right on the lake, lie in cinders.
- Satellites Spot Methane Plumes Over U.S. Caused by 'Routine Work'on September 2, 2021 at 6:01 pm
Plumes of the super-warming greenhouse gas methane were spotted over the Midwest last month. U.S. pipeline giant Energy Transfer LP said the releases were triggered by “routine work” on its ...
- Satellites find methane plumes over Midwest caused by Energy Transferon September 2, 2021 at 12:46 pm
In August 2020, the EPA opened an investigation after Bloomberg News reported on a methane release over Florida to determine if the Clean Air Act was violated. Preliminary findings indicate the ...
- Fact check: Just how harmful is methane?on September 2, 2021 at 9:25 am
Methane contributes to global warming; it is therefore a greenhouse gas. Of all the methane produced in the Netherlands, 70% comes from livestock farming. A substantial percentage. But how harmful is ...
- Large Methane Plume Detected Over Southern Iraqon September 2, 2021 at 8:00 am
Satellites detected a large release of super-warming methane gas over southern Iraq last month. The methane cloud, spotted by geoanalytics firm Kayrros SAS using European Space Agency satellite data, ...
- Quantum-enabled camera to help cut methane emissions from oil & gas industryon September 2, 2021 at 6:05 am
QLM Technology developed a quantum-enabled gas imaging camera that is expected to help cut methane leaks from the oil and gas industry.
- New data exposes the potentially catastrophic threat from unchecked, invisible methane emissionson September 2, 2021 at 2:49 am
New evidence from Romania has thrown a spotlight on an unseen climate disaster – methane emissions. Incomplete data and lack of political priority makes methane an invisible catastrophe for the ...
- Moo-ve Over Greenhouse Gas, Red Seaweed Helps Cows Reduce Methane Releaseon September 1, 2021 at 8:39 pm
A supreme seaweed helps reduce the methane gas that cows exude. Founder and CEO of Symbrosia Alexia Akbay told The Conversation about the promising work underway.
- Coal Bed Methane Market Size Report 2021 Offers Major Drivers and Opportunities by Region and Forecast to 2027on August 30, 2021 at 10:20 pm
Aug 31, 2021 (The Expresswire) -- "Final Report will add the analysis of the impact of COVID-19 on this industry" “Coal Bed Methane Market” 2021 ...