Crowdfunding academic research might be changing, from a near-stunt to an widely used method of filling gaps in a research group’s money supply.
At least, that’s the impression this article at Nature Jobs gives:
The practice has exploded in recent years, especially as success rates for research-grant applications have fallen in many places. Although crowd-funding campaigns are no replacement for grants — they usually provide much smaller amounts of money, and basic research tends to be less popular with public donors than applied sciences or arts projects — they can be effective, especially if the appeals are poignant or personal, involving research into subjects such as disease treatments.
The article details several venues that have been used for this sort of fund-raising, including Indiegogo, Kickstarter, RocketHub, FundaGeek, and SciFund Challenge. I’d add Microryza to that list. And there’s a lot of good advice for people thinking about trying it themselves, including how much money to try for (at least at first), the timelines one can expect, and how to get your message out to potential donors.
Overall, I’m in favor of this sort of thing, but there are some potential problems. This gives the general pubic a way to feel more connected to scientific research, and to understand more about what it’s actually like, both of which are goals I feel a close connection to. But (as that quote above demonstrates), some kinds of research are going to be an easier sell than others. I worry about a slow (or maybe not so slow) race to the bottom, with lab heads overpromising what their research can deliver, exaggerating its importance to immediate human concerns, and overselling whatever results come out.
These problems have, of course, been noted. Ethan Perlstein, formerly of Princeton, used RocketHub for his crowdfunding experiment that I wrote about here. And he’s written at Microryza with advice about how to get the word out to potential donors, but that very advice has prompted a worried response over at SciFund Challenge, where Jai Ranganathan had this to say:
His bottom line? The secret is to hustle, hustle, hustle during a crowdfunding campaign to get the word out and to get media attention. With all respect to Ethan, if all researchers running campaigns follow his advice, then that’s the end for science crowdfunding. And that would be a tragedy because science crowdfunding has the potential to solve one of the key problems of our time: the giant gap between science and society.
Up to a point, these two are talking about different things. Perlstein’s advice is focused on how to run a successful crowdsourcing campaign (based on his own experience, which is one of the better guides we have so far), while Ranganathan is looking at crowdsourcing as part of something larger. Where they intersect, as he says, is that it’s possible that we’ll end up with a tragedy of the commons, where the strategy that’s optimal for each individual’s case turns out to be (very) suboptimal for everyone taken together. He’s at pains to mention that Ethan Perlstein has himself done a great job with outreach to the public, but worries about those to follow:
Because, by only focusing on the mechanics of the campaign itself (and not talking about all of the necessary outreach), there lurks a danger that could sink science crowdfunding. Positive connections to an audience are important for crowdfunding success in any field, but they are especially important for scientists, since all we have to offer (basically) is a personal connection to the science. If scientists omit the outreach and just contact audiences when they want money, that will go a long way to poisoning the connections between science and the public. Science crowdfunding has barely gotten started and already I hear continuous complaints about audience exasperation with the nonstop fundraising appeals. The reason for this audience fatigue is that few scientists have done the necessary building of connections with an audience before they started banging the drum for cash. Imagine how poisonous the atmosphere will become if many more outreach-free scientists aggressively cold call (or cold e-mail or cold tweet) the universe about their fundraising pleas.
Now, when it comes to overpromising and overselling, a cynical observer might say that I’ve just described the current granting system. (And if we want even more of that sort of thing, all we have to do is pass a scheme like this one). But the general public will probably be a bit easier to fool than a review committee, at least, if you can find the right segment of the general public. Someone will probably buy your pitch, eventually, if you can throw away your pride long enough to keep on digging for them.
That same cynical observer might say that I’ve just described the way that we set up donations to charities, and indeed Ranganathan makes an analogy to NPR’s fundraising appeals. That’s the high end. The low end of the charitable-donation game is about as low as you can go – just run a search for the words “fake” and “charity” through Google News any day, any time, and you can find examples that will make you ashamed that you have the same number of chromosomes as the people you’re reading about. (You probably do). Avoiding this state really is important, and I’m glad that people are raising the issue already.
The Latest Bing News on:
Crowdfunding Research
- Sunbirds SAS Launches Crowdfunding Campaign For World's First Solar Drone Called SB4 Phoenixon January 20, 2021 at 11:30 pm
Sunbirds SAS has today launched its newly invented solar SB4 Phoenix drones on sowefund.com, a French equity crowdfunding platform. With ...
- Crowdfunding for Conservation on a Deserted Tourist Islandon January 20, 2021 at 7:44 pm
COVID times, some half a million tourists would descend on the tiny Thai island of Koh Tao, one of Southeast Asia’s most pristine diving destinations. But that all changed in April, when the country ...
- Alternative ways of funding journalism: Crowdfunding has raised $20m+ and seeded some major titleson January 20, 2021 at 10:11 am
As the advertising model has been hit, publishers are experimenting with new revenue streams for journalism such as crowdfunding and membership.
- Crowdfunding Litigation Market Is in Huge Demand : Fundable, Kickstarter, RocketHub, CircleUp, Patreonon January 19, 2021 at 12:52 pm
Stay up-to-date with Crowdfunding Litigation Market research offered by HTF MI. Check how key trends and emerging drivers are shaping this industry growth.
- Group urges state to explore new marijuana tax, clinical pot researchon January 19, 2021 at 6:57 am
A group commissioned to bring racial equity to Michigan’s marijuana industry has suggested a range of changes to Michigan laws ...
- Why You Should Conduct Product Surveys Before Launching Your Crowdfunding Campaign?on January 19, 2021 at 4:40 am
It’s always essential to gather as much feedback as possible before you launch a crowdfunding campaign. This will help you plan your campaign well and give you enough time to work on those loopholes.
- 'Do research before donating' | FBI warns about giving to Capitol riot crowdfunding, charity siteson January 17, 2021 at 12:42 pm
FBI officials want people to make sure they research who they are giving money to as charities are being made in the wake of the Capitol riot on Jan. 6. "Fraudsters will take advantage of any tragedy ...
- Comics Crowdfunding Round-Up: ENDLESS MOONS, THE COLOR GUARD, and 3 more campaigns we loveon January 15, 2021 at 10:11 am
We’re checking out the sci-fi adventure series, Endless Moons, the all-ages story of courage and high school, The Color Guard, and more.
- Crowdfunding boosts Te Horo based medicinal cannabis company Phytotecniaon January 13, 2021 at 4:40 pm
A medicinal cannabis company based in Te Horo, north of Wellington, has proved very popular with the public. Agricultural engineers Irene Lopez-Ubiria and Alvaro Vidiella-Salaberry sought crowdfunding ...
- Mysterious 'Mostly Harmless' Hiker Found Dead In Tent Identified Through 'Cutting Edge' Genetic Researchon January 13, 2021 at 11:42 am
The mystery surrounding the identity of a hiker found dead in a Florida tent has been solved, thanks to a combination of DNA testing, crowdfunding and public outreach, it was announced this week.
The Latest Google Headlines on:
Crowdfunding Research
The Latest Bing News on:
Crowdfunding
- Dutch Crowdfunding Platform Lendahand Announces €5 million Debt Facility For Funding Societies to Support Southeast Asian Underserved SMEson January 25, 2021 at 5:36 am
Lendahand, a Netherlands-based for-profit crowdfunding platform for impact investing, announced over the weekend that it has agreed to provide Singapore-based Funding Societies with an up to €5 ...
- Ask SCORE: Should I use crowdfunding for my small business?on January 24, 2021 at 2:33 pm
For startup entrepreneurs experiencing difficulty — or exasperation — in trying to get financing for their businesses via traditional means, crowdfunding offers an alternative. Crowdfunding can be an ...
- Katelyn McClure, NJ crowdfunding scam defendant, has sentencing delayed: reportson January 23, 2021 at 8:50 pm
A New Jersey woman who faces up to four years in prison after pleading guilty to a role in a crowdfunding scam has had her sentencing hearing delayed, according to reports.
- Crowdfunding Breathes Life Into Malawi's Covid Fighton January 23, 2021 at 7:01 am
A new crowdfunding campaign in Malawi has raised $100,000 in a week and helped provide basic equipment and medicines in state hospitals to fight the Covid-19 pandemic.
- Crowdfunding campaigns bent but didn't break in 2020on January 22, 2021 at 3:15 am
Crowdfunding in Minnesota didn't reach the impressive heights of previous years in 2020, but that doesn't mean it took the year off.
- An Overview of Modern Crypto Crowdfunding Mechanismson January 21, 2021 at 11:19 am
Several newer solutions have emerged, which promise to provide a safer, fairer way to invest in new crypto projects. Read on to know more.
- 7 Crowdfunding Platforms You Can Use To Boost Your Ideason January 21, 2021 at 1:44 am
What are crowdfundings ?They are Internet platforms that allow you to collect resources from an online community that contributes money in exchange for rewards –such as a t-shirt or a version of the ...
- RealtyFeed is crowdfunding a 'disruptive social network' for real estateon January 20, 2021 at 4:00 pm
Looking for a minimum of $25K, RealtyFeed is a product of technology company Realtyna, and it aims to combine agent collaboration features with search tools for consumers ...
- Crowdfunding Litigation Market Is in Huge Demand : Fundable, Kickstarter, RocketHub, CircleUp, Patreonon January 19, 2021 at 12:52 pm
Stay up-to-date with Crowdfunding Litigation Market research offered by HTF MI. Check how key trends and emerging drivers are shaping this industry growth.
- Why You Should Conduct Product Surveys Before Launching Your Crowdfunding Campaign?on January 19, 2021 at 4:40 am
It’s always essential to gather as much feedback as possible before you launch a crowdfunding campaign. This will help you plan your campaign well and give you enough time to work on those loopholes.