Superweeds? Suicides? Stealthy genes? The true, the false and the still unknown about transgenic crops
In the pitched debate over genetically modified (GM) foods and crops, it can be hard to see where scientific evidence ends and dogma and speculation begin. In the nearly 20 years since they were first commercialized, GM crop technologies have seen dramatic uptake. Advocates say that they have increased agricultural production by more than US$98 billion and saved an estimated 473 million kilograms of pesticides from being sprayed. But critics question their environmental, social and economic impacts.
Researchers, farmers, activists and GM seed companies all stridently promote their views, but the scientific data are often inconclusive or contradictory. Complicated truths have long been obscured by the fierce rhetoric. “I find it frustrating that the debate has not moved on,” says Dominic Glover, an agricultural socioeconomist at Wageningen University and Research Center in the Netherlands. “The two sides speak different languages and have different opinions on what evidence and issues matter,” he says.
Here, Nature takes a look at three pressing questions: are GM crops fuelling the rise of herbicide-resistant ‘superweeds’? Are they driving farmers in India to suicide? And are the foreign transgenes in GM crops spreading into other plants? These controversial case studies show how blame shifts, myths are spread and cultural insensitivities can inflame debate.
GM crops have bred superweeds: True
Jay Holder, a farming consultant in Ashburn, Georgia, first noticed Palmer amaranth (Amaranthus palmeri) in a client’s transgenic cotton fields about five years ago. Palmer amaranth is a particular pain for farmers in the southeastern United States, where it outcompetes cotton for moisture, light and soil nutrients and can quickly take over fields.
Since the late 1990s, US farmers had widely adopted GM cotton engineered to tolerate the herbicide glyphosate, which is marketed as Roundup by Monsanto in St Louis, Missouri. The herbicide–crop combination worked spectacularly well — until it didn’t. In 2004, herbicide-resistant amaranth was found in one county in Georgia; by 2011, it had spread to 76. “It got to the point where some farmers were losing half their cotton fields to the weed,” says Holder.
Some scientists and anti-GM groups warned that GM crops, by encouraging liberal use of glyphosate, were spurring the evolution of herbicide resistance in many weeds. Twenty-four glyphosate-resistant weed species have been identified since Roundup-tolerant crops were introduced in 1996. But herbicide resistance is a problem for farmers regardless of whether they plant GM crops.
The Latest Bing News on:
Genetically Modified Crops
- 3 years before GM corn ban, farmers group claims government stalling on import permitson June 10, 2021 at 3:42 pm
An agricultural lobby says that federal regulators' delays are effectively pushing forward the announced 2024 start date for the prohibition.
- Maharashtra: Farmers’ union to provide seeds of HtBt cotton, asks farmers to register onlineon June 9, 2021 at 8:38 am
Since 2018, the Shetkari Sanghatana has started a public civil disobedience movement demanding the legalisation of this transgenic cotton.
- Texas vineyard owners sue seed companies, alleging weedkiller has crippled their industryon June 8, 2021 at 11:29 am
The owners and operators of 57 wine grape farms in Texas on Friday sued two large companies that they allege sold a faulty seed system and a volatile weedkiller that’s crippled vineyards, threatening ...
- Commentary: The story of the Mayan beekeeper that formed a coalition to fight the growth of genetically modified plants by Monsanto in Mexicoon June 8, 2021 at 10:15 am
This Mayan Beekeeper Formed a Swarm of Environmentalists to Combat the Growth of Genetically Modified Plants in Her Native Mexico”, 20 May 2021 … [I]t was devastating to the community when Monsanto, ...
- Mexico wants to import non-GMO corn and US farmers say they can deliver iton June 8, 2021 at 3:02 am
Ken Roseboro * Mexico's GMO corn ban presents an opportunity for US farmers to supply non-GMO corn south of the borderWhile US agribusiness groups are trying to pressure Mexico into abandoning their ...
- CRISPR Gene Editing Newson June 7, 2021 at 5:00 pm
Apr. 7, 2021 — Eucalyptus, a pest-resistant evergreen valued for its hardy lumber and wellness-promoting oil, can be genetically modified not ... Just 15 plant crops provide 90 per cent of ...
- No genetically modified fish in Nigerian market ― Biosafety D-Gon June 4, 2021 at 10:34 pm
General, National Biosafety ManagementBMA), Dr Rufus Ebegba, says there are no genetically modified fish and animals yet in the Nigerian market. He made this assertion on Friday in Abuja during ...
- NBMA chief: No genetically modified fish in Nigerian marketon June 4, 2021 at 10:27 am
Dr Rufus Ebegba, says there are no genetically modified fish and animals yet in the Nigerian market. He made this assertion on Friday in Abuja during stakeholders meeting for the review of draft ...
- Buzz off: Genetically-modified mosquitoes released in Florida to combat dengue and Zikaon June 1, 2021 at 5:31 am
Thousands of genetically-modified mosquitoes have been released in Florida as part of a scientific experiment. In some parts of the world, mosquitoes transmit a range of life-threatening infections, ...
- A new chance for genetically engineered crops is within sighton May 31, 2021 at 9:00 am
The EU is reviewing its rules on genetically modified organisms (GMOs) with an eye to loosening restrictions on genetically engineered (GE) crops. It is a welcome move, and African countries should ...
The Latest Google Headlines on:
Genetically Modified Crops
The Latest Bing News on:
- Wine Walk: Weather, herbicide impacts on the Texas High Plains grapeson June 10, 2021 at 9:31 am
Many Texans believe that the Texas Hill Country grows most of the grapes. The Texas Hill Country has hundreds of acres of vineyards. The Texas High Plains has thousands of acres of vineyards on this ...
- Texas Grape Growers Sue Over Herbicide Damageon June 10, 2021 at 1:19 am
Wine grape growers in Texas and surrounding states filed a lawsuit for the damage a cotton herbicide has caused to vineyards.
- Grape growers in Texas region sue over herbicide damage | Raleigh News & Observeron June 9, 2021 at 10:17 am
Wine grape growers in Texas and surrounding states have filed a lawsuit against drug-maker Bayer-Monsanto and chemical giant BASF for the damage their cotton herbicide has caused to vineyards.
- Grape growers in Texas region sue over herbicide damageon June 9, 2021 at 10:13 am
Wine grape growers in Texas and surrounding states filed a lawsuit last week against drug-maker Bayer-Monsanto and chemical giant BASF for the damage their cotton herbicide has caused to vineyards.
- EPA approves herbicide for resistant waterhemp in sugarbeetson June 9, 2021 at 12:00 am
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has approved a request for a Section 18 emergency exemption for Ultra Blazer, enabling North Dakota growers a new tool to combat glyphosate-resistant ...
- Herbicide resistance field day planned in Iowaon June 7, 2021 at 11:00 pm
Iowa State University Extension and Outreach will host a herbicide resistance management field day on June 15, from 1 to 3 p.m. at the A. Knaphus farm located 1 mile south of McCallsburg on County ...
- Bayer Repurposes Herbicideon June 3, 2021 at 9:24 am
With no new herbicide modes of action on the horizon, agrichemical companies are combing through the archives for options to battle herbicide-resistant weeds. Now, for Bayer Crop Science, that ...
- Agronomist talks pest resistance managementon June 3, 2021 at 1:04 am
Mike Witt discusses recent findings from the Iowa Pest Resistance Management Program's weed seed screening efforts.
- The occurrence of herbicide-resistant Avena fatua (wild oats) populations to ACCase-inhibiting herbicides in Irelandon June 2, 2021 at 8:39 pm
Following growers’ reports of herbicide control problems, populations of 30 wild oats, Avena fatua, were collected from the south-east main arable counties of Ireland in 2016 and investigated for the ...
- 2021 status of herbicide-resistant weeds in Michiganon May 31, 2021 at 11:30 am
Erin Hill, Michigan State University, Department of Plant, Soil and Microbial Sciences – May 20, 2021. Work continues on new herbicide resistance cases in waterhemp and fall pan ...