A long-running philosophical debate is being rehashed in the world of business, and big money is at stake, says Stephen Ornes
AT SOME point in their career every mathematician comes up against the question, is mathematics invented or discovered? The query makes some cranky. The answer doesn’t directly affect their work, after all, and the discussion often leads nowhere useful. Spending time debating the ultimate nature of mathematics takes away from actually doing it.
Some scholars take issue with the terms themselves. In his 2008 essay Mathematical Platonism and Its Opposites, Harvard University mathematician Barry Mazur called discovery and invention “those two too-brittle words”. One might be tempted to defuse the question altogether with a merger: perhaps maths involves inventing new relationships between things we have discovered.
It’s a metaphysical query, a nerdy way to ask whether or not some pre-existing truths underlie our existence. Here we bump up against theology. If mathematical ideas are discovered – the Platonist position – then a proof is a real-world encounter with an immortal truth. But then where, exactly, is this ethereal pool of truths? Did prime numbers exist before the big bang?
If, on the other hand, mathematics is invented, then proofs spring from human intelligence a bit like art or law. But then why do mathematicians across time and space always agree on what’s right and wrong?
The question about invention versus discovery flares up every few years, often in a different guise. The latest incarnation concerns something very down to earth: money. In this case, the discovery versus invention question has profound consequences. In fact, there may be no mathematical question with higher stakes. That’s because mathematics powers the algorithms that drive computer software, and software is big business, worth over $300 billion a year to the global economy.
One of the most hotly contested issues in software is whether it should be patentable. At present not all of it can be, because of its dependence on mathematics. Patents are granted for inventions, and most mathematical formulas are deemed to be abstract ideas, not inventions, although the rules vary from country to country; some grant software patents, some don’t. Where patents are granted, they are tantamount to big money.
Writing in the April 2013 issue of Notices of the American Mathematical Society, David Edwards from the University of Georgia in Athens points out that the debate over patents boils down to the difference between discovery and invention. He argues that because abstract mathematical ideas are regarded as “discoveries”, the system is fundamentally Platonic – and broken.
“There is no economic basis for the distinction between discovery and invention,” he told me. “Economically speaking, the difference between discovery and invention should be done away with.” He argues patents should be granted for every new formula and algorithm, including those that power computer software. Such a change would jump-start innovation. “If math were patentable, then you could have independent groups of mathematicians form a group or small company and support themselves that way,” he says.
His position is extreme, but proponents of software patentability similarly argue that the system fuels growth and rewards people for their work.
Critics, notably the nonprofit Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) in San Francisco, say the current patent system actually stymies innovation, because getting a patent requires years and tens of thousands of dollars.
Another criticism is that hazy wording in software patent laws has given rise to “patent trolls”, predatory companies that purchase old, cheap patents simply to use them to sue other companies for infringement. Trolling cost US companies $29 billion in 2011, according to a report from the Boston University School of Law.
The Chicago-based company Soverain Software, for example, has been accused of being a patent troll. It has racked up tens of millions of dollars suing companies including Amazon and Gap over patents for basic online shopping software. The online computer retailer Newegg, sued by Soverain for $2.5 million, fought back – and in January a US District Court in East Texas ruled against Soverain.
Even if trolls get banished, weak patents exist.
The Latest Bing News on:
- An Alternative to Claim Mirroring in Initial Patent Application Filingon January 27, 2023 at 12:15 am
“Though insight can be gained with mirrored claims, more insight should be available to the patent practitioner when the examiner examines more claims with unique claim scope.” While working ...
- ITIF Report: The U.S. Underestimates China as an ‘Imitator’ Rather Than an Innovator at Its Own Perilon January 26, 2023 at 2:38 pm
On January 23, the Information Technology & Innovation Foundation (ITIF) published a report that applies innovation and industrial performance metrics for comparing relative innovation outputs from ...
- Whirlpool Corporation: Whirlpool Corp. Female Engineers and Designers Put Up Big Patent Numberson January 26, 2023 at 6:38 am
She has patents in laundry and now works in the cooking ... Technology, Engineering and Math (STEM) careers. "My own exposure was that my dad was an engineer, so I knew what he did, and I knew ...
- Whirlpool Corp. Female Engineers and Designers Put Up Big Patent Numberson January 26, 2023 at 5:29 am
NORTHAMPTON, MA / ACCESSWIRE / January 26, 2023 / A report from the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office shows that Berrien County, Michigan, where Whirlpool Corp.'s Global Headquarters is located, was ...
- Patent reform and lower drug prices should be bipartisan prioritieson January 25, 2023 at 11:17 am
Our leaders can — and must — work across the aisle to bring down the cost of health care through patent reform, an area where our elected representatives can find common ground and deliver for ...
- How startups can protect their IP: 8 tips from a patent attorneyon January 25, 2023 at 5:33 am
Startups, however, can overlook IP protection in their initial plans. According to Robert Lind, a patent attorney at IP firm Marks & Clerk, they’re taking a major risk. Lind recently wrote an e ...
- Yavapai College welcomes new Associate Dean of Science, Math and Adult Basic Educationon January 23, 2023 at 11:15 pm
Baker is making a triumphant return to his roots as the new Associate Dean of Science, Math and Adult Basic Education at Yavapai College. “I’m really excited about giving back and being at Yavapai ...
- Tesla obtains patent for Cybertruck’s novel windshieldon January 23, 2023 at 3:43 am
Tesla has obtained a patent for a new way to make glass that is evidently going to be used for Cybertruck’s novel windshield. There are a lot of things about the Cybertrucks that are unlike any ...
- Halliburton says patent ruling derails U.S. Well lawsuit over fracking technologyon January 19, 2023 at 11:34 am
U.S. Patent Office declared U.S. Well patents invalid Lawsuit and countersuit currently set for March trial (Reuters) - Halliburton Co has convinced a U.S. Patent and Trademark Office tribunal to ...
- Does This Nintendo Patent Hint at a Smartphone Revival for Nintendogs?on January 19, 2023 at 8:49 am
Just because a company files a patent for a new device, feature, or random idea, doesn’t necessarily mean it plans to make it a reality. Sometimes, it’s just to prevent other companies from ...
The Latest Google Headlines on:
[google_news title=”” keyword=”patenting mathematics” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]
The Latest Bing News on:
- Clause 8 Podcast: Bruce Berman on Telling a Patent Storyon January 30, 2023 at 4:16 am
Bruce Berman, the PR guru of the IP world, is the CEO of Brody Berman Associates, a communications firm that helps tell patent stories. Berman has implemented marketing and business development ...
- Fearne Cotton calls out trolls for 'judging' her body in mirror pic: 'I love food'on January 29, 2023 at 4:03 am
Fearne Cotton has responded to online trolls "judging" her body for being too slim after she posted a mirror selfie. The star, 41, defended her "knobbly knees" and "spindly ankles" from criticism ...
- Ron DeSantis thinks he can troll his way to the White House — but there's a big flaw in his strategyon January 28, 2023 at 10:50 am
The whole thing was an obvious troll, meant to "trigger the liberals" and get this angry reaction. The crowd heckled people going in and took their photos in hopes of "outing" them, but rather ...
- I have a husband and a boyfriend — trolls call me selfish, but I don’t careon January 28, 2023 at 6:48 am
This TikToker has a husband and a boyfriend — and a lot of haters. User @middlespoonpodcast, known as Sarah, posts videos about her throuple on TikTok and Instagram, answering questions from her ...
- Internet trolls Associated Press for discouraging use of 'the,' calling the word 'dehumanizing'on January 27, 2023 at 6:21 pm
The Associated Press caused a stir online Thursday after it updated its official Stylebook to discourage writers from using the word "the" as it said the word is "dehumanizing" when used as a ...
- 'Trolls say I'm too big to post online - I'll never stop as long as it's helping others'on January 27, 2023 at 7:41 am
A body neutrality influencer who is regularly targeted by trolls claiming she's "too big" to be posting pictures and videos of herself online has said their vile comments only make her want to ...
- Lawyers Can’t Call Jurors ‘Yahoos’ in East Texas Patent Trialon January 26, 2023 at 1:55 am
One would think a rule barring trial attorneys from calling jurors in their case “yahoos” would be gratuitous. But Judge Rodney Gilstrap instituted just such a rule for a patent-infringement trial ...
- I’m 49 and trolls bash me for not dressing my age — I wear what makes me feel goodon January 24, 2023 at 10:55 am
Danelle McDougall, 49, has become a social media sensation showing off her quirky and colorful clothing on TikTok — but trolls say she’s too old to be sporting such eye-catching designs.
- A rocky past haunts the mysterious company behind the Lensa AI photo appon January 20, 2023 at 7:01 am
Little was previously known about the artificial intelligence company founded by five Russian tech workers who for years have been quietly developing AI tools from its homebase of Cyprus.
- Intellectual Propertyon January 18, 2023 at 11:12 pm
The new system is more like that used by every other country in the world. The problem of "patent trolls" -- entities that usually don't create a product of any sort, but buy up patents and sue ...
The Latest Google Headlines on:
[google_news title=”” keyword=”patent trolls” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]