A long-running philosophical debate is being rehashed in the world of business, and big money is at stake, says Stephen Ornes
AT SOME point in their career every mathematician comes up against the question, is mathematics invented or discovered? The query makes some cranky. The answer doesn’t directly affect their work, after all, and the discussion often leads nowhere useful. Spending time debating the ultimate nature of mathematics takes away from actually doing it.
Some scholars take issue with the terms themselves. In his 2008 essay Mathematical Platonism and Its Opposites, Harvard University mathematician Barry Mazur called discovery and invention “those two too-brittle words”. One might be tempted to defuse the question altogether with a merger: perhaps maths involves inventing new relationships between things we have discovered.
It’s a metaphysical query, a nerdy way to ask whether or not some pre-existing truths underlie our existence. Here we bump up against theology. If mathematical ideas are discovered – the Platonist position – then a proof is a real-world encounter with an immortal truth. But then where, exactly, is this ethereal pool of truths? Did prime numbers exist before the big bang?
If, on the other hand, mathematics is invented, then proofs spring from human intelligence a bit like art or law. But then why do mathematicians across time and space always agree on what’s right and wrong?
The question about invention versus discovery flares up every few years, often in a different guise. The latest incarnation concerns something very down to earth: money. In this case, the discovery versus invention question has profound consequences. In fact, there may be no mathematical question with higher stakes. That’s because mathematics powers the algorithms that drive computer software, and software is big business, worth over $300 billion a year to the global economy.
One of the most hotly contested issues in software is whether it should be patentable. At present not all of it can be, because of its dependence on mathematics. Patents are granted for inventions, and most mathematical formulas are deemed to be abstract ideas, not inventions, although the rules vary from country to country; some grant software patents, some don’t. Where patents are granted, they are tantamount to big money.
Writing in the April 2013 issue of Notices of the American Mathematical Society, David Edwards from the University of Georgia in Athens points out that the debate over patents boils down to the difference between discovery and invention. He argues that because abstract mathematical ideas are regarded as “discoveries”, the system is fundamentally Platonic – and broken.
“There is no economic basis for the distinction between discovery and invention,” he told me. “Economically speaking, the difference between discovery and invention should be done away with.” He argues patents should be granted for every new formula and algorithm, including those that power computer software. Such a change would jump-start innovation. “If math were patentable, then you could have independent groups of mathematicians form a group or small company and support themselves that way,” he says.
His position is extreme, but proponents of software patentability similarly argue that the system fuels growth and rewards people for their work.
Critics, notably the nonprofit Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) in San Francisco, say the current patent system actually stymies innovation, because getting a patent requires years and tens of thousands of dollars.
Another criticism is that hazy wording in software patent laws has given rise to “patent trolls”, predatory companies that purchase old, cheap patents simply to use them to sue other companies for infringement. Trolling cost US companies $29 billion in 2011, according to a report from the Boston University School of Law.
The Chicago-based company Soverain Software, for example, has been accused of being a patent troll. It has racked up tens of millions of dollars suing companies including Amazon and Gap over patents for basic online shopping software. The online computer retailer Newegg, sued by Soverain for $2.5 million, fought back – and in January a US District Court in East Texas ruled against Soverain.
Even if trolls get banished, weak patents exist.
The Latest Bing News on:
- Thirty-four NSM Faculty Celebrated for 50-in-5 Achievementson December 2, 2021 at 1:36 pm
More than 100 UH Faculty Members Recognized for National Recognition and Publications Achievements. At the first in-person 50-in-5 celebration event, 116 University of Houston fac ...
- The Key to Fundraising for Startups Is Alumni Networks. Here’s the Surprise.on November 29, 2021 at 3:38 pm
Investors are more likely to fund founders who attended the same university. But it’s not all about elite degrees in Silicon Valley.
- What the media doesn't say about Appleon November 29, 2021 at 6:24 am
And it’s the lack of awareness of those exceptions that's fostering cognitive dissonance in the Apple sphere. Take Apple’s work in energy. Energy is essential. Apple invests in energy across the ...
- Nielsen Sues Two Firms for Patent Infringementson November 25, 2021 at 4:00 pm
Nielsen is suing panel-based TV audience measurement firms HyphaMetrics and TVision, claiming separate patent infringements. Nielsen's suit makes multiple references to an interview between Drews and ...
- Hire MATLAB Developers in Washingtonon November 25, 2021 at 3:11 am
Hire the best freelance MATLAB Developers in Washington on Upwork™, the world’s top freelancing website. It’s simple to post your job and we’ll quickly match you with the top MATLAB Developers in ...
- Two Gatton Academy Alum Receive Prestigious Graduate Study Scholarshipson November 23, 2021 at 12:27 pm
Two alumni of The Gatton Academy recently received two of the country’s most prestigious graduate study awards. Elvin N. Irihamye received the Rhodes Scholarship and Samuel C. Kessler received the ...
- Disney Imagineer inspires youth, builds gadgets of the futureon November 22, 2021 at 11:49 am
By Ada Romano Black Engineer Online Disney Imagineer and research fellow, Lanny Smoot, graced BEYA Stars & Stripes Career Day to give insights on what it means to be a Disney Imagineer and provide ...
- Nielsen Fires Off Duel Lawsuits Against Panel Measurement Startups TVision And HyphaMetricson November 22, 2021 at 11:03 am
Nielsen took some kicks while it was down this year, delivered courtesy of rivals happy to capitalize on its MRC dis-accreditation and soured relationships with broadcasters. But big companies can ...
- Women of Legal Tech: Emily Hostage and Why Legal Could Understand Tech If They Triedon November 22, 2021 at 4:10 am
Burford Capital’s Emily Hostage discusses why legal tech appeals to her polymath instincts, the importance of inviting women to contribute, and why she flips a coin when it comes to big decisions.
- CBF Morning Run: What you need to know today and oh-so-chatty dental hygienistson November 22, 2021 at 2:20 am
To avoid that kind of interaction, I have gone so far as to ask for hygienists who don't chitchat. Is that terrible of me? Does that make me Larry David?
The Latest Google Headlines on:
The Latest Bing News on:
- Take-Two appears to be IP trollingon December 2, 2021 at 3:27 am
Could be the new Atari Take-Two is heading towards becoming the new Atari and look towards IP trolling rather than making successful products, according to Tech Dirt. While Take-Two is nowhere near ...
- Patent trolls kill startups, but the Biden administration has the power to helpon November 30, 2021 at 9:00 am
President Biden has now nominated Kathi Vidal to serve in this role. If she is confirmed by the Senate, Vidal will have an opportunity to support tech startups across the country who just want our ...
- 7 Critical Questions for U.S. Patent and Trademark Office Nominee Kathi Vidal to Answer at December 1st Nomination Hearingon November 30, 2021 at 6:00 am
WASHINGTON, D.C., Nov. 30, 2021 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- via NewMediaWire – Outlining how she will protect America’s position as an innovation leader and preserve manufacturing growth in the U.S. should be ...
- Abolish Copyrights and Patents? A Soho Forum Debateon November 24, 2021 at 12:03 pm
The United States Constitution explicitly calls for copyright and patent laws to "promote the progress of science and useful arts" by "authors and ...
- The Future Of Apple's VR Headsets: Might They Prevent Cyberbullyingon November 22, 2021 at 8:24 am
The future is bright, no shades this time now it’s a headset. Apple’s future Virtual Reality headset, set to appear as early as 2022, claims to have a way to prevent internet bullies and trolls in the ...
- International Trade Commission Reforms: How Far Should They Go?on November 22, 2021 at 5:00 am
In discussions of patent policy, the International Trade Commission (ITC) has often flown under the radar. Despite this, it wields significant authority over patent disputes in the United States. The ...
- The U.S. International Trade Commission: An Empirical Study of Section 337 Investigationson November 22, 2021 at 5:00 am
INTRODUCTION The smartphone patent wars over the last decade have put a spotlight on a little-known federal agency: the U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC). Originally a body for managing the ...
- Patent Absurdityon November 20, 2021 at 2:01 am
I think that this was a stupid thing for my manager to do because now the person working on this feature has no clue if the patent is being violated or not. Was I wrong to try to do the requisite ...
- Be Wary of Patent Trolls in European Medtechon November 18, 2021 at 4:00 pm
Patent trolls aren't only a U.S. phenomenon. Two legal experts discuss why nonpracticing entities have impacted medical device companies doing business in Europe and ways to defend against such ...
- Colorado Cracks Down|on Patent Trollson November 13, 2021 at 4:00 pm
DENVER (CN) - A new Colorado law makes it easier to prosecute patent trolls who use the patent and copyright system to shake down businesses. Twenty-six states have passed similar laws in recent years ...