A long-running philosophical debate is being rehashed in the world of business, and big money is at stake, says Stephen Ornes
AT SOME point in their career every mathematician comes up against the question, is mathematics invented or discovered? The query makes some cranky. The answer doesn’t directly affect their work, after all, and the discussion often leads nowhere useful. Spending time debating the ultimate nature of mathematics takes away from actually doing it.
Some scholars take issue with the terms themselves. In his 2008 essay Mathematical Platonism and Its Opposites, Harvard University mathematician Barry Mazur called discovery and invention “those two too-brittle words”. One might be tempted to defuse the question altogether with a merger: perhaps maths involves inventing new relationships between things we have discovered.
It’s a metaphysical query, a nerdy way to ask whether or not some pre-existing truths underlie our existence. Here we bump up against theology. If mathematical ideas are discovered – the Platonist position – then a proof is a real-world encounter with an immortal truth. But then where, exactly, is this ethereal pool of truths? Did prime numbers exist before the big bang?
If, on the other hand, mathematics is invented, then proofs spring from human intelligence a bit like art or law. But then why do mathematicians across time and space always agree on what’s right and wrong?
The question about invention versus discovery flares up every few years, often in a different guise. The latest incarnation concerns something very down to earth: money. In this case, the discovery versus invention question has profound consequences. In fact, there may be no mathematical question with higher stakes. That’s because mathematics powers the algorithms that drive computer software, and software is big business, worth over $300 billion a year to the global economy.
One of the most hotly contested issues in software is whether it should be patentable. At present not all of it can be, because of its dependence on mathematics. Patents are granted for inventions, and most mathematical formulas are deemed to be abstract ideas, not inventions, although the rules vary from country to country; some grant software patents, some don’t. Where patents are granted, they are tantamount to big money.
Writing in the April 2013 issue of Notices of the American Mathematical Society, David Edwards from the University of Georgia in Athens points out that the debate over patents boils down to the difference between discovery and invention. He argues that because abstract mathematical ideas are regarded as “discoveries”, the system is fundamentally Platonic – and broken.
“There is no economic basis for the distinction between discovery and invention,” he told me. “Economically speaking, the difference between discovery and invention should be done away with.” He argues patents should be granted for every new formula and algorithm, including those that power computer software. Such a change would jump-start innovation. “If math were patentable, then you could have independent groups of mathematicians form a group or small company and support themselves that way,” he says.
His position is extreme, but proponents of software patentability similarly argue that the system fuels growth and rewards people for their work.
Critics, notably the nonprofit Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) in San Francisco, say the current patent system actually stymies innovation, because getting a patent requires years and tens of thousands of dollars.
Another criticism is that hazy wording in software patent laws has given rise to “patent trolls”, predatory companies that purchase old, cheap patents simply to use them to sue other companies for infringement. Trolling cost US companies $29 billion in 2011, according to a report from the Boston University School of Law.
The Chicago-based company Soverain Software, for example, has been accused of being a patent troll. It has racked up tens of millions of dollars suing companies including Amazon and Gap over patents for basic online shopping software. The online computer retailer Newegg, sued by Soverain for $2.5 million, fought back – and in January a US District Court in East Texas ruled against Soverain.
Even if trolls get banished, weak patents exist.
The Latest Bing News on:
Patenting mathematics
- Be the first to knowon August 7, 2022 at 4:25 am
It was July 31, 1921, when Christian Kent Nelson found in Omaha a believer and financial angel — Russell Stover — in his invention of a chocolate shell for ice ...
- Raymond Vahan Damadian, the Father of MRI, Chairman and Founder of FONAR Corporation, Dies at 86on August 5, 2022 at 3:00 pm
The Inventor of MR Scanning ™, reported today the passing of Founder and Chairman Raymond V. Damadian, MD on August 3, 2022. Highlights of the life of Dr. Raymond Damadian: Founded FONAR Corporation ...
- New patent-pending method mass-produces antitumor cells to treat blood diseases and canceron August 2, 2022 at 5:00 pm
Bao has developed a patent-pending method to mass-produce CAR-neutrophils from human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs), that is, cells that self-renew and are able to become any type of human cell.
- SNIPR Biome Granted New US Patent Covering Lytic CRISPR Phageon August 1, 2022 at 11:16 pm
Copenhagen, August 2nd, 2022: SNIPR Biome ApS (or “the Company”), a clinical-stage biotechnology company developing CRISPR-based precision medicines, announces today the grant of patent number ...
- The United Arab Emirates University publishes 1077 research articles and is awarded 14 patents in the first half of 2022on August 1, 2022 at 3:08 am
He concluded by highlighting the importance of producing patents and new inventions as “patents represent one of the most important research outcomes of academic institutions”. During the ...
- Camp Invention returning to Franklin Elementary in Auguston July 31, 2022 at 11:00 pm
The program is known as Camp Invention and the camp is a program of the National Inventors Hall of Fame in partnership with the United States Patent and Trademark Office. Camp Invention is designed to ...
- UAEU publishes 1077 research articles, awarded 14 patents in first half of 2022on July 31, 2022 at 5:00 pm
The United Arab Emirates University (UAEU) has set scientific research at the forefront of its ambitious strategic vision, where research is considered a key to institutional innovation and foresight, ...
- How to Improve Diversity in the Legal Professionon July 21, 2022 at 5:00 pm
Foundational programs are needed to achieve greater diversity in the legal profession. Imagine the future if the focus shifts to where a majority of organizations and clients together are developing ...
- Matthew Hortonon July 18, 2022 at 4:14 am
Matthew regularly helps clients with strategic IP portfolio development and patent litigation. With hands-on knowledge on software code and complex mathematics, Matthew is able to engage engineers ...
- Publications and Patentson July 16, 2022 at 1:53 am
Involve, a Journal of Mathematics 12 (6), 1051-1068. Radillo A.E., Veliz-Cuba A., Josić K., Kilpatrick Z.P. "Performance of normative and approximate evidence accumulation on the dynamic clicks task." ...
The Latest Google Headlines on:
Patenting mathematics
[/vc_column_text]
The Latest Bing News on:
Patent trolls
- Is this Triangle company a patent troll?on August 4, 2022 at 4:26 pm
Is this Triangle company a ? Our lawyers had to go through this story carefully. Patent trolls are companies that don’t make a product ...
- Local View: Patent reform a growing issueon August 3, 2022 at 6:21 am
Among these new problems is dealing with non-practicing entities – often referred to as “patent trolls.” Patent trolls are shell companies that buy low-quality patents – patents that ...
- Conversation With The Experts: Latest Trends In Intellectual Property Licensing And Litigationon August 1, 2022 at 12:00 am
The Latest Trends in Intellectual Property Licensing and Litigation panel is produced by the L.A. Times B2B Publishing team in conjunction with Citrin Cooperman and Nixon Peabody LLP.
- LOT, the anti-patent-troll group, launches Adapt to tackle inclusion in the world of IPon July 28, 2022 at 1:44 pm
Patent trolling, critics say, is guided by one principle alone: money. Yet tackling it remains a complex task with many angles. Today, a consortium called LOT — set up to help improve how the tech ...
- Netflix Beats Back Patent Troll, Collects $409K in Attorney's Feeson July 28, 2022 at 11:52 am
A U.S. federal appeals court described the legal strategy executed by Realtime Adaptive Streaming LLC as "blatant gamesmanship," and ruled that the Texas patent troll must reimburse Netflix $409,000 ...
- Lot, the big-tech anti-patent-troll group, launches Adapt to tackle inclusion in the world of IPon July 28, 2022 at 6:40 am
"There is a pipeline." Patent trolls were a very regular presence in the landscape of technology a decade or so ago, and although you may not hear about patent cases every day nowadays, they are ...
- Lot, the big-tech anti-patent-troll group, launches Adapt to tackle inclusion in the world of IPon July 28, 2022 at 6:03 am
"There is a pipeline." Patent trolls were a very regular presence in the landscape of technology a decade or so ago, and although you may not hear about patent cases every day nowadays, they are ...
- Lot, the big-tech anti-patent-troll group, launches Adapt to tackle inclusion in the world of IPon July 28, 2022 at 5:00 am
Patent trolling, critics say, is guided by one principle alone: money. Today, a consortium called LOT -- set up to help improve how the tech world, and the IP industry at large, handle trolling -- is ...
- Patent troll Sonrai Memory sues Apple for alleged infringements of HP techon July 18, 2022 at 5:47 am
Another week, another patent troll suing Apple for alleged infringements of patents purchased for the sole purpose of filing lawsuits. Sonrai Memory has filed similar infringement claims against a ...