A long-running philosophical debate is being rehashed in the world of business, and big money is at stake, says Stephen Ornes
AT SOME point in their career every mathematician comes up against the question, is mathematics invented or discovered? The query makes some cranky. The answer doesn’t directly affect their work, after all, and the discussion often leads nowhere useful. Spending time debating the ultimate nature of mathematics takes away from actually doing it.
Some scholars take issue with the terms themselves. In his 2008 essay Mathematical Platonism and Its Opposites, Harvard University mathematician Barry Mazur called discovery and invention “those two too-brittle words”. One might be tempted to defuse the question altogether with a merger: perhaps maths involves inventing new relationships between things we have discovered.
It’s a metaphysical query, a nerdy way to ask whether or not some pre-existing truths underlie our existence. Here we bump up against theology. If mathematical ideas are discovered – the Platonist position – then a proof is a real-world encounter with an immortal truth. But then where, exactly, is this ethereal pool of truths? Did prime numbers exist before the big bang?
If, on the other hand, mathematics is invented, then proofs spring from human intelligence a bit like art or law. But then why do mathematicians across time and space always agree on what’s right and wrong?
The question about invention versus discovery flares up every few years, often in a different guise. The latest incarnation concerns something very down to earth: money. In this case, the discovery versus invention question has profound consequences. In fact, there may be no mathematical question with higher stakes. That’s because mathematics powers the algorithms that drive computer software, and software is big business, worth over $300 billion a year to the global economy.
One of the most hotly contested issues in software is whether it should be patentable. At present not all of it can be, because of its dependence on mathematics. Patents are granted for inventions, and most mathematical formulas are deemed to be abstract ideas, not inventions, although the rules vary from country to country; some grant software patents, some don’t. Where patents are granted, they are tantamount to big money.
Writing in the April 2013 issue of Notices of the American Mathematical Society, David Edwards from the University of Georgia in Athens points out that the debate over patents boils down to the difference between discovery and invention. He argues that because abstract mathematical ideas are regarded as “discoveries”, the system is fundamentally Platonic – and broken.
“There is no economic basis for the distinction between discovery and invention,” he told me. “Economically speaking, the difference between discovery and invention should be done away with.” He argues patents should be granted for every new formula and algorithm, including those that power computer software. Such a change would jump-start innovation. “If math were patentable, then you could have independent groups of mathematicians form a group or small company and support themselves that way,” he says.
His position is extreme, but proponents of software patentability similarly argue that the system fuels growth and rewards people for their work.
Critics, notably the nonprofit Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) in San Francisco, say the current patent system actually stymies innovation, because getting a patent requires years and tens of thousands of dollars.
Another criticism is that hazy wording in software patent laws has given rise to “patent trolls”, predatory companies that purchase old, cheap patents simply to use them to sue other companies for infringement. Trolling cost US companies $29 billion in 2011, according to a report from the Boston University School of Law.
The Chicago-based company Soverain Software, for example, has been accused of being a patent troll. It has racked up tens of millions of dollars suing companies including Amazon and Gap over patents for basic online shopping software. The online computer retailer Newegg, sued by Soverain for $2.5 million, fought back – and in January a US District Court in East Texas ruled against Soverain.
Even if trolls get banished, weak patents exist.
The Latest Bing News on:
- Acton mom scores deal pitching invention to 'Shark Tank'on April 9, 2021 at 5:45 pm
THIS IS NOT MELISSA’S FIRST FORAY INTO THE BUSINESS WORLD HER OTHER RATHER SUCCESSFUL VENTURE IS A JEWELRY LINE CALLED TINY TAGS, AND THIS ACTON MOM IS HOPEFUL THAT NOW THE SHARKS WILL GO TO THE ...
- Landmark Fair Use Victory at the Supreme Court in Software Caseon April 9, 2021 at 8:17 am
(For example, the declaring code “java.lang.Math.max” corresponds to a more complex set of ... two trips to the Federal Circuit (Oracle’s complaint previously included patent claims). Over the years, ...
- Candidate statement: Tricia Liu running for Weston School Committeeon April 8, 2021 at 7:43 am
Tricia Liu, a 12-year Weston resident, mother of two, engineer and former CEO, is running for Weston School Committee at the Town Election.
- Women and Girls to the Fronton April 7, 2021 at 4:57 am
Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, women in the UAE, China and elsewhere have also led ground-breaking efforts against the virus in the fields of public health, vaccines and treatments. The Hope ...
- Combining materials science and entrepreneurship to found a spin-offon April 5, 2021 at 4:00 am
Materials scientist Arnab Basu, head of radiation-detection technology developer Kromek, on spin-offs, COVID-19 and the future ...
- BlackBerry Limited: BlackBerry Hampered by Auto Chip Shortage in Q4; Negotiating Patent Sale; Raising FVE to $7.00on March 30, 2021 at 5:00 pm
Kerwin was an intern on Morningstar's basic- materials team.Kerwin holds a Bachelor of Science in economics with a math emphasis and French from the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
- Holland Patent Central School Districton March 25, 2021 at 6:25 pm
Holland Patent Central School District contains 4 schools and 1,370 students. Also, 40.0% of students are economically disadvantaged. The student body at the schools served by Holland Patent ...
- Holland Patent Middle Schoolon March 25, 2021 at 5:06 pm
and the school serves 6-8.At Holland Patent Middle School, 52% of students scored at or above the proficient level for math, and 52% scored at or above that level for reading.The school’s ...
- Patenting Strategies For Nonfungible Token Technologyon March 25, 2021 at 12:24 pm
Despite the math recited in the claim, Example 41 states that it is patent eligible as it sufficiently limits the use of the mathematical concepts to the practical application of transmitting the ...
- Stanford’s Abstract Idea: A Method for Resolving Haplotype Phaseon March 13, 2021 at 9:09 am
That rejection was affirmed by the PTAB and how has been affirmed by the Federal Circuit. Patenting Math: On appeal, the Federal Circuit found the claims directed to an abstract mathematical ...
The Latest Google Headlines on:
The Latest Bing News on:
- Patent troll sues Apple and Qualcomm for allegedly infringing on a patent related to 5G transceiverson April 9, 2021 at 7:49 pm
Remember when Apple and Qualcomm were suing each other every day over alleged patent infringements? Apple was getting so desperate to find a source of 5G modem chips that it was willing to bet the ...
- What's Up With Apple: Epic Lawsuit, Patent Troll and Moreon April 9, 2021 at 5:14 am
With the next chapter of the Epic Games lawsuit against Apple Inc. (NASDAQ: AAPL) set to begin in a few more weeks, the two companies have just filed documents with the court outlining the positions ...
- Liner patent lawsuits rage as Zim becomes the latest boxship player pulled inon April 7, 2021 at 11:02 pm
Zim is the latest boxship company caught in the sights of an alleged patent troll, while two of its competitors have returned ...
- Irish company snaps up patents belonging to LGon April 6, 2021 at 8:35 pm
A subsidiary of LG Electronics recently sold more than 100 US patents to an Irish-headquartered companythat has issued a wave of multimillion-dollar lawsuits against well-known technology giants. LG ...
- Protecting innovation from trollson March 31, 2021 at 10:45 pm
Her research showed how product innovation also declined during the period of litigation. In her study, she found that: “An explanation for this lack of innovation is that the vendors didn’t want to ...
- Holo (HOT) Price Spikes Following US Patent Approvalon March 30, 2021 at 3:53 am
HOT, the native token of the Holo cloud hosting market has increased by more than 2,000% since the beginning of February 2021.
- Lil Nas X responds to backlasheson March 29, 2021 at 8:33 am
"The star also followed up with an anecdote to troll his critics and said that he showed the video ... where he gives Satan a now-infamous lap dance in patent leather thigh-high stilettos. Responding ...
- Motorola found guilty of infringing on a patent from infamous trollon March 25, 2021 at 5:00 pm
Intellectual Ventures, as you've probably heard, has built quite the reputation as an infamous patent troll. While it licenses its portfolio out to companies like HTC and Samsung, it's more well ...
- Metamaterial boosts defence against patent trolls by joining LOT Networkon March 24, 2021 at 3:06 pm
If a small company like us ends up going under and our IP ends up in the hands of a patent troll, then our partners and everyone else in the network is protected.” Since Metamaterial went public on ...
- Be Wary of Patent Trolls in European Medtechon March 18, 2021 at 5:01 pm
Patent trolls aren't only a U.S. phenomenon. Two legal experts discuss why nonpracticing entities have impacted medical device companies doing business in Europe and ways to defend against such ...